26-04-2025
Experts give Colts mixed grades for Day 2 NFL draft picks
Experts give Colts mixed grades for Day 2 NFL draft picks What grades did the experts give the Indianapolis Colts for their Day 2 NFL draft selections?
What grades did the experts give the Indianapolis Colts for their Day 2 NFL draft selections?
In the second round, the Colts would land polished defensive end JT Tuimoloau from Ohio State. Tuimoloau fits the typical mold we see GM Chris Ballard target at defensive end with this size and athleticism.
He's also an experienced player who was a three-down presence at Ohio State, ranking sixth in PFF's run defense grade and 14th in pressures among his position group.
The Colts landed a Day 1 contributor who brings a well-rounded skill set to a position where more depth and consistency are needed.
Then in the third round, the Colts selected Minnesota cornerback Justin Walley, who has spent his college career on the boundary, but is someone the Colts believe can play inside.
Walley has been stingy in his career in coverage, surrendering a completion rate of just 53%, although he has given up big plays as well, with opponents averaging over 17 yards per catch in 2024. While a bit undersized, Ballard noted his speed and toughness, which he believes will help Walley's skill set translate to the NFL level.
Versatility is important in Lou Anarumo's scheme, and perhaps Walley can be the backup option behind Kenny Moore in the slot--prior to the draft, there wasn't a clear option for that role on the roster--but even so, particularly with the unknown on the offensive line, this felt like a luxury pick that I don't know the Colts are in a position to make.
So with the dust having somewhat settled on these selections, what grades did the Colts receive?
Colts Day 2 NFL draft grades from experts
USA Today
JT Tuimoloau: B
Justin Walley: C-
Pro Football Focus
JT Tuimoloau: Average
Justin Walley: Below Average
33rd Team
JT Tuimoloau: C+
Justin Walley: C
Bleacher Report
JT Tuimoloau: B
Justin Walley: C+
CBS Sports
JT Tuimoloau: B+
Justin Wiley: C
Sports Illustrated