Latest news with #CongregationJeshuatIsrael
Boston Globe
3 days ago
- Politics
- Boston Globe
Tours of historic Touro Synagogue in Newport, R.I. to restart, now led by N.Y. congregation
Congregation Shearith Israel brought the Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up Members of both congregations confirmed earlier this week there is an overlap in membership between the foundation's board and Congregation Jeshuat Israel. Advertisement Louis M. Solomon, president of Congregation Shearith Israel, said Tuesday that because Congregation Jeshuat Israel could not commit to returning items it allegedly took from the synagogue, he would not provide the foundation access to the building for the tours. Instead, Congregation Shearith Israel will now offer tours of the synagogue, a National Historic Site, beginning Friday, according to the 'Shearith Israel is pleased that tours will be continuing,' Solomon wrote in an email. 'It was always our intention to do so – just not with [the foundation] and its controlling entity CJI until the Court decides whether CJI has wrongfully misappropriated religious objects from Touro Synagogue.' Related : Advertisement Solomon added Monday and Tuesday were Jewish holidays, which 'both precluded tours on those days but set us back a day in getting an excellent replacement.' According to the website, tours are now scheduled for various times between Friday and June 23, and a handful of times in July, although additional dates are coming soon. 'We will have even greater coverage after the near term,' Solomon wrote. Registration is required for the approximately 45-minute tours, which are free of charge 'but donations of any amount are appreciated,' the website states. Built in 1763, the synagogue has long stood as a symbol of religious freedom in the United States, especially after President George Washington visited Newport following Rhode Island's ratification of the US Constitution in 1790, and assured the Jewish congregation in a letter that the newly formed country would give 'to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.' After the synagogue foundation was barred from the building, the not-for-profit organization said it has been providing presentations of the synagogue's history in the nearby Loeb Visitors Center and in Patriots' Park. Despite the dispute over tour access, the synagogue has remained open to the public for prayer and worship during services, according to Paul Tobak, president of Congregation Ahavath Israel, the synagogue's new tenant congregation. Material from previous Globe stories was used in this report. Christopher Gavin can be reached at
Yahoo
4 days ago
- General
- Yahoo
Tours temporarily halted at Touro Synagogue amid long-standing dispute
NEWPORT, R.I. (WPRI) — Craig and Cathy Bell were saddened to learn that the historic Touro Synagogue has temporarily stopped offering tours. The Bells traveled from Long Island to Newport to celebrate their 46th wedding anniversary and were looking forward to seeing the nation's oldest synagogue, which was built in 1763 and has long stood as a symbol of religious freedom. 'We're not coming back anytime soon,' Craig Bell said. 'So, it's very disappointing.' Newport tour guide and University of Rhode Island professor Art Spivack was also disheartened to learn the building is currently closed to the public. 'It's a sad reflection of this ongoing conflict,' Spivack said. Congregation Jeshuat Israel, which used to worship at the Touro Synagogue, has been embroiled in a legal battle with the New York-based Congregation Shearith Israel for years. Congregation Shearith Israel, which owns the historic building, kicked Congregation Jeshuat Israel out of the synagogue nearly a month ago. The Newport congregation was ousted from the synagogue after the R.I. Supreme Court upheld a 2023 ruling that allowed the New York congregation to do so. The long-standing feud first erupted back in 2012, when the Congregation Jeshuat Israel attempted to sell a pair of Colonial-era Torah bells to the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston for $7.4 million. Congregation Shearith Israel, which had been leasing the synagogue to Congregation Jeshuat Israel for $1 a year since the early 1900s, objected to the sale and sought to be declared the rightful owner of the bells. The First U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals eventually determined that the bells belonged to Congregation Shearith Israel, which stopped the sale from moving forward. Now, Congregation Shearith Israel is accusing Congregation Jeshuat Israel of misappropriating funds set aside for the building's upkeep and failing to make at least $300,000 worth of repairs. The New York congregation filed a lawsuit against the Newport congregation back in April, accusing them of withdrawing $1.6 million from two funds created in the 1800s to cover synagogue maintenance and pay the rabbi's salary. Congregation Shearith Israel also claims Congregation Jeshuat Israel removed Torah scrolls and other religious artifacts from the building without their permission. The Newport congregation has since moved its prayer services to the Levi Gale House, which is across the street from the synagogue. The Touro Synagogue Foundation initially hoped that the New York congregation would allow them to continue offering tours to visitors. But Laura Freedman Pedrick, chair of the Touro Synagogue Foundation, told 12 News she was sadly mistaken. 'Unfortunately, we were unable to come to terms with that congregation to allow us entry,' Freedman Pedrick explained. 'We've been denied access to the building and are no longer able to give tours.' A sign was posted on the door of the Loeb Visitor Center alerting the public that tours are suspended. Lou Solomon, president of Congregation Shearith Israel, told 12 News that there's a reason the Foundation is not allowed in the building. 'The Touro Synagogue Foundation is allied with the former tenant, which took our ritual objects and refuse to return them,' Solomon said. 'I can't let them come in and take more.' For now, Freedman Pedrick told 12 News the Touro Synagogue Foundation is offering historic presentations at the visitor center. She said tour fees will be waived for the presentations, which are offered every half-hour between 10 a.m. and 1:30 p.m. Sunday through Friday. Meanwhile, Solomon stressed that tours of the synagogue will resume this Friday, but not with the Touro Synagogue Foundation. He said Congregation Shearith Israel found someone else to host the tours. 'We're very pleased about that,' Solomon added. Solomon said the reason no tours were offered Monday and Tuesday were due to the Jewish holiday Shavuot. The Bells remain hopeful that the two congregations will resolve their issues in the near future. 'Knock it off. Find a way to make this work,' Craig Bell said. 'We're all on the same team, supposedly, and we all wear the same uniform.' 'It's disappointing that two affiliations want to fight over who has the right to do XYZ, and who suffers? The public,' he continued. 'Let everyone see what a beautiful building this is and stop being a bunch of knuckleheads.' Spivack echoed that sentiment. 'I think [the congregations] should be able to resolve this,' Spivack said. 'It would be to their mutual benefit.' Download the and apps to get breaking news and weather alerts. Watch or with the new . Follow us on social media: Close Thanks for signing up! Watch for us in your inbox. Subscribe Now Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Boston Globe
5 days ago
- General
- Boston Globe
Public tours of historic Touro Synagogue halted amid ongoing dispute between Newport and New York congregations
The synagogue remains open to the public for prayer and worship during services, according to Paul Tobak, president of Congregation Ahavath Israel, the synagogue's tenant congregation. The foundation, which has brought tour groups through the historic synagogue for 78 years, was the only entity providing tours inside the building for members of the public who are not worshipping there, Freedman Pedrick confirmed. Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up The tours are now on hold indefinitely, although the foundation said it is still providing presentations of the synagogue's history 'in the Loeb Visitors Center or, weather permitting, outdoors in Patriots' Park, overlooking the synagogue.' Advertisement 'I can't tell you enough how upsetting it is that we have been denied access for exactly that reason: To be able to share the story [of the synagogue] in that space,' Freedman Pedrick said. Built in 1763, the synagogue has long stood as a symbol of religious freedom in the United States, especially after President George Washington visited Newport following Rhode Island's ratification of the US Constitution in 1790, and assured the Jewish congregation in a letter that the newly formed country would give 'to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.' Advertisement Inside Touro Synagogue in Newport, R.I. David L. Ryan/Globe Staff In recent years, the synagogue has been at The Rhode Island Supreme Court ruled in April the former could And in Michael Pimental, co-president of Congregation Jeshuat Israel, has called the allegations 'meritless.' Louis M. Solomon, president of Congregation Shearith Israel, did not return requests for comment. But according to Tobak, some members of the synagogue foundation's board also belong to Congregation Jeshuat Israel's litigation committee. 'With these issues outstanding, Shearith Israel did not want people from the leadership of CJI and also the leadership of the Touro Synagogue Foundation … having keys and other things for the synagogue,' Tobak said. Pimental said 'there has always been, historically, some overlap as it relates to either membership or maybe board representation' between the foundation and Congregation Jeshuat Israel. 'I can't speak to the basis for which [members of Congregation Shearith Israel] justify continuing to harass all the Newport community,' he said. Advertisement According to Tobak and Freedman Pedrick, Congregation Shearith Israel and the Touro Synagogue Foundation attempted to negotiate to allow the tours to continue, but could not reach an agreement. 'They wanted to dictate how we were going to tell the story and the history of Touro Synagogue, of religious freedom, of the history of what went on in that building,' Freedman Pedrick said. She declined to provide more details, but added, 'That was not how we were willing to go forward.' Tobak said Congregation Shearith Israel wants to have tours available, and had reached out to the Newport Historical Society about spearheading the tours. In an email, Lauren Craig, the society's membership engagement and social media coordinator, confirmed the congregation reached out to the organization. 'But our walking tour schedule is currently full and there are no plans for Newport Historical Society to take over tours of Touro Synagogue,' Craig wrote. According to the foundation, through its publicly-available presentations on the synagogue's history visitors will 'learn about Touro Synagogue, Newport's colonial Jewish community, the origins of religious freedom, and the separation of church and state in the United States.' There is no admission fee, but the foundation is accepting donations. Freedman Pedrick said the foundation remains focused on sharing the history 'because we think it's so important to America.' 'In the biggest scheme of it all … I'm hopeful that and I anticipate that that building is going to outlast all of us, right?' she said. 'They are the stewards right now. I hope that they take good care of that building, because it's so significant.' Touro Synagogue is the oldest standing synagogue in the US. David L. Ryan/Globe Staff Christopher Gavin can be reached at
Boston Globe
11-04-2025
- Politics
- Boston Globe
R.I. Supreme Court rules congregation can be evicted from Newport's Touro Synagogue, the nation's oldest synagogue
Advertisement 'Our review of the record reveals that the trial justice did not err in entering judgment in favor of Shearith Israel, granting it 'the right to take immediate possession of the [p]remises together with the appurtenances and paraphernalia belonging thereto in accordance with the 1903 and 1908 leases,'' reads the decision, penned by Chief Justice Paul A. Suttell. Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up In a statement, Congregation Jeshuat Israel said it was 'deeply saddened' by the ruling, but added it 'remains committed to being the vibrant center of Jewish worship, culture, and community for generations to come.' NEWPORT, RI - 11/16/2023: xxritouro…..A closed gate at street level outside entrance of The Touro Synagogue which is the oldest standing synagogue in the US, and a symbol of religious freedom in America. It is open several days per week for tours, and more people than usual are visiting for this time of year, both jewish and non-jewish, to reflect given the violence in Israel/Gaza. Newport is also home to one of the first Jewish congregations in the country. (David L Ryan/Globe Staff ) SECTION: METRO David L. Ryan/Globe Staff 'This decision comes at a particularly emotional time, as we prepare to gather for Passover, a holiday that honors the Jewish people's enduring strength and liberation,' the statement said. 'While this ruling is a painful moment in our history, it does not shake our foundation.' Advertisement The synagogue has been the congregation's spiritual home for nearly 140 years. 'For nearly a century and a half, CJI has been at the heart of Jewish life in Newport,' Michael Pimental, the congregation's co-president, said in a statement. 'Our congregation is not defined by walls, but by the community we have built through shared faith, values, and connection. That spirit lives on.' In its own statement, Congregation Shearith Israel said it welcomed the court's decision, and added Congregation Ahavath Israel, of Newport, is now 'ready to step in to ensure a seamless transition of occupancy.' Congregation Ahavath Israel already has plans to hold services at the synagogue on Friday evening, and worshipers from all congregations are welcome, Dr. James Herstoff, the incoming congregation's secretary-treasurer and head of ritual, told the Globe. 'We are welcoming and hope that the rift can be overcome over time – [that] the bad feelings on some people's parts will be able to be soothed, and that is our desire,' Herstoff said in an interview. 'We hope and encourage that all the congregants in Congregation Jeshuat Israel will desire to continue praying in Touro Synagogue with us.' FOR USE WITH THIS STORY ONLY XXRITOURO NEWPORT, RI - 11/16/2023: Touro Synagogue is the oldest standing synagogue in the US, and a symbol of religious freedom in America. It is open several days per week for tours, and more people than usual are visiting for this time of year, both jewish and non-jewish, to reflect given the violence in Israel/Gaza. Newport is also home to one of the first Jewish congregations in the country. (David L Ryan/Globe Staff ) SECTION: METRO David L. Ryan/Globe Staff As Suttell acknowledged in the court's decision, the two congregations had quarrels over their interests in the property as far back as the early 1900s. In 1903, they ultimately entered into a five-year lease allowing Congregation Jeshuat Israel to be a tenant at the synagogue. A subsequent lease was signed in 1908, and when that agreement expired in 1913, Congregation Jeshuat Israel became a holdover tenant. In 1945, the two congregations entered into an agreement with the Secretary of the Interior to help preserve the synagogue and to help give it landmark status, according to court filings. Advertisement 'Sadly, Jeshuat Israel and Shearith Israel do not enjoy a harmonious relationship, leading to litigation in the federal courts seeking to resolve issues other than those which are before this Court,' Suttell wrote. 'Both parties have recognized, in their papers and through witness testimony at trial, that their relationship had 'deteriorated.'' Controversy erupted in 2012 when Congregation Jeshuat Israel In a letter to its congregants this week that it shared with the Globe, Congregation Shearith Israel said it went on to make 'strenuous and ongoing efforts to reconcile' that were ultimately unsuccessful. 'CJI continued to act in ways that Shearith Israel felt was not in the best interests of Touro Synagogue,' the letter said. 'This led us to pursue eviction.' NEWPORT, RI - 11/16/2023: Touro Synagogue is the oldest standing synagogue in the US, and a symbol of religious freedom in America. It is open several days per week for tours, and more people than usual are visiting for this time of year, both jewish and non-jewish, to reflect given the violence in Israel/Gaza. Newport is also home to one of the first Jewish congregations in the country. (David L Ryan/Globe Staff ) SECTION: METRO David L. Ryan/Globe Staff This week's Supreme Court decision upheld a September 2023 ruling from Superior Court Judge Maureen B. Keough that found an October 2022 tenant termination notice Congregation Shearith Israel sent to Congregation Jeshuat Israel was legally valid. Keough granted a stay of execution, however, allowing the congregation to remain at the synagogue, pending appeal of the case. Congregation Jeshuat Israel did appeal the decision to the state Supreme Court, arguing, in part, that the 1945 agreement was a modification of the 1908 lease and that Congregation Shearith Israel was required to consult with the Secretary of the Interior before removing the congregation, according to the decision. Advertisement Suttell wrote the court agreed with Keough. 'It is clear that these terms [of the 1945 agreement] seek to protect Touro Synagogue as a historic site and require collaboration among the parties before the Synagogue building or grounds are altered, but the terms do not reach back to modify any of the terms of the lease agreement,' Suttell wrote. Additionally, Suttell wrote the court saw 'no reason to disturb' Keough's findings regarding whether 'the elements required for ejectment were satisfied.' 'It is unfortunate that the circumstances arose that necessitated this,' Herstoff said Friday. 'I don't think anybody is happy that it was necessary to do this.' Paul Tobak, president of the incoming Congregation Ahavath Israel, said there is no celebrating the court decision. 'The only celebration is that we got closure,' he said. His congregation is now reaching out to Congregation Jeshuat Israel on an 'individual basis, encouraging them to come,' Tobak said. 'My hope is that, as it has always been, … that the community come together and put any kind of ill feelings behind them,' he said. Christopher Gavin can be reached at
