16-04-2025
Removing transgender books affects Rutherford library director search: 'Deeply concerned'
Rutherford County library officials lost a consultant for a director-search after deciding "to protect children" by removing books on transgender topics.
The Rutherford County Library System Board had been working with Deiters & Todd Library Consulting in Chicago to pursue director applicants to replace Rita Shacklett, who retired early in 2024.
First Amendment issue: Divided Rutherford County Library System Board bans transgender books 'to protect children'
The consulting firm's services remained prior to the March 17 majority decision in a 5-3 vote to "remove material that promotes, encourages, advocates for or normalizes transgenderism or 'gender confusion' in minors."
The same five in the majority of the board also voted to remove the picture book, "Me & My Dysphoria Monster" from the library system. The book is by author Laura Kate Dale and Illustrated by Ang Hui Qing.
"Deiters & Todd stepped away from the search because of recent actions taken by the board," consulting firm partner Jim Deiters told The Daily News Journal.
"As working librarians, we were deeply concerned by those decisions," said Deiters, adding that his firm returned the initial payment for the search to the library board. "Not an easy thing to do, but the right thing."
Library board chairman Phil King said a search committee soon will move ahead to examine applicants for the system's director job.
2023 book banning decisions: Library supporters upset by board pulling 4 books say they're 'fighting against censorship'
The board on Monday met in private executive session in Murfreesboro with Nashville attorney Robert "Bob" Burns "to discuss and seek input from counsel" pertaining to decisions to remove the books in question, he confirmed.
While the meeting took place within a conference room of the library system's administrative offices, two protesters upset by the decisions to remove books stood outside by the edge of the parking lot holding signs.
The sign Jessica Robertson of Murfreesboro offered the following message: "EVERBODY BELONGS AT THE LIBRARY."
"I don't know why they are taking books off the shelf that represent people who exist in this world," Robertson said.
Robertson recently told the board during the public comment part of the March 17 meeting that she's the mother of a transgender child.
Complaint upsets officials: Speaker complaint on book on transgender topic disrupts Murfreesboro school board meeting
Fellow book-freedom advocate Heather Ahmie of Rutherford County held a sign saying, "No room for BIGOTRY on our Shelves."
"Where does it end?" Ahmie told The Daily News Journal. "You can't start erasing people from the public library, which is there for everyone."
The board member's private executive session for legal counsel took place about a week before they meet next at 5 p.m. April 21 at Smyrna Public Library. The meeting agenda is yet to be announced on the library system's webpage.
'It was a hard decision': Murfreesboro school board bans book on transgender topic after December meeting disruption
The library board officials also have also faced complaints about the book removal decisions in letters from three national free speech advocacy organizations:
Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression in Philadelphia.
National Coalition Against Censorship in New York;
The Freedom to Read Foundation in Chicago.
Free speech challenges: Rutherford library officials draw national opposition for removing books on transgender issues
Burns, the library board's attorney, told The Daily News Journal that he thought the letters were reasonably well-written.
"I reviewed and considered some, but not all, of the information and points contained in the letters," Burns said.
'We are banished': Rutherford County Board of Education book banning upsets free speech advocates
The letter from the Freedom to Read Foundation came from Deborah Caldwell Stone, the organization's executive director.
Stone questioned why the board would remove books based on "moral and religious beliefs" of individuals and organizations, "even though other parents believe these books are important and valued reading materials for their children."
"Such viewpoint discrimination is both unconstitutional and problematic for public institutions, ascourts have consistently held that restricting intended readers' access to materials based on viewsexpressed in the books violates the First Amendment rights of library users of all ages," Stone said in her letter.
"The First Amendment protects each person's right to access and read any book in a public librarythat a reasonable person would view as having literary, artistic, political, or scientific value,whether for an adult or for a minor."
More book banning decisions: Rutherford schools removal of 160 more books draws opposition from 1st Amendment advocates
Reach reporter Scott Broden with news tips or questions by emailing him at sbroden@ To support his work with The Daily News Journal, sign up for a digital subscription.
This article originally appeared on Murfreesboro Daily News Journal: Banning transgender books affects Rutherford library director search
