3 days ago
Puerto Rico Allows LGBTQ+ People To Use 'X' Gender Marker On Birth Certificates
In what activists say is a landmark decision for Puerto Rico, a federal judge issued a ruling on Monday allowing nonbinary, intersex and gender-fluid individuals in the territory to adjust their birth certificate so that it accurately reflects their gender identity.
Judge María Antongiorgi Jordán, of the Federal District of Puerto Rico, ordered the Demographic Registry to amend a form so that people can select 'X' as a gender marker on their birth certificate. Gov. Jenniffer González Colón said she was awaiting recommendations from the territory's Justice Department regarding the ruling, and applicants will have to wait to change their gender marker until the new form is available.
'At a time when nonbinary, gender nonconforming and trans communities are under attack, this historic decision opens the door to the full recognition of their dignity,' said Pedro Julio Serrano, activist and president of the LGBTQ+ Federation of Puerto Rico. 'We celebrate a milestone that allows the equality promised in the Constitution to be put in practice.'
Trans people in Puerto Rico have been allowed to change their gender marker from 'male' to 'female' and vice versa since 2018, but until Monday could not choose an option that aligned with an identity outside the gender binary. This difference violates the right to equal protection of all people, according to the court order.
'The Court finds there is no rational basis to deny the plaintiff's request,' the order said. 'The Commonwealth of Puerto Rico's current birth certificate policy arbitrarily distinguishes between binary and nonbinary individuals and subjects nonbinary individuals to disadvantaged treatment without any justification for doing so.'
The ruling is in response to an October 2023 lawsuit against González Colón requesting the 'X' marker on birth certificates. The suit was filed by six nonbinary Puerto Ricans: Ínaru Nadia de la Fuente Díaz, Maru Rosa Hernández, André Rodil, Yelvy Vélez Bartolomei, Gé Castro Cruz and Deni Juste.
The ruling 'represents a respite from so much repression … It's an unexpected victory,' de la Fuente Díaz told Puerto Rican outlet Todas. 'The fact that you wake up every day knowing that they're trying to take away your rights, and the next day you wake up and find that they won the lawsuit, that there's a possibility of continuing to fight in this political climate, shows once again that [U.S. President Donald Trump] doesn't have absolute power, nor does the government of Puerto Rico.'
Puerto Rico has long had a history of grassroots activism that protects and uplifts the territory's LGBTQ+ communities — beating 30 states and other U.S. territories in overall LGBTQ+ rights and equity, according to the Movement Advancement Project. Trans and nonbinary Puerto Ricans had been able to choose a third gender marker on their passports since 2021, until Trump signed an executive order threatening it.
The January order prohibits the use of 'X' on federal documents like U.S. passports, military IDs and Social Security cards — not state- and territory-issued papers like birth certificates and driver's licenses. Trump's order, which is policy and not law, was temporarily halted by a federal judge in April.
At least 16 states and the District of Columbia currently allow citizens to use the 'X' gender marker on their birth certificates, according to the Movement Advancement Project. Many in the LGBTQ+ community have expressed concern about that changing under an administration actively working to roll back civil rights, but activists say they're determined to keep fighting for equality.
'This is proof that when you fight, you win,' said Ivana Fred Millán, director of the LGBTQ+ Federation that's made up of hundreds of individuals and more than 100 community and allied organizations.
'Even with so many attacks, the LGBTQ+ communities are still fighting to achieve the promised equality,' she continued. 'We will not take a step back and will continue fighting until equality is achieved.'
