06-05-2025
Cleaner who smuggled phone into mental hospital loses unfair dismissal case
A cleaner who was sacked after smuggling a mobile phone into an institution for prisoners with mental disorders has lost a case for unfair dismissal against her former employer.
Lina Leliugiene worked for Derrycourt Cleaning Specialists Limited at the National Forensic Mental Health Services in Portrane, which also accommodates those found not guilty of crimes by reason of insanity.
An adjudication hearing of the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) was told that there was 'airport-like security' at the hospital, which was described as 'a facility for mentally ill patients and prisoners'.
Phones and other contraband items have to be placed in secure lockers before cleaning staff present themselves at security and enter the facility.
However, Ms Leliugiene, who is from Lithuania, admitted smuggling a mobile phone into a restricted area of the hospital and taking photographs in May 2023.
She claimed to be taking pictures of areas that weekend staff had failed to clean properly, and argued that she had acted out of frustration as grievances about this issue had not been acted upon.
Ms Leliugiene was given a final written warning following a disciplinary investigation into the incident and continued in employment until February 2024, when she emailed an area manager accusing a colleague of taking drugs and forging documents.
No evidence was found to substantiate these allegations, and the subject of the complaint told management that Ms Leliugiene had handed her an 'intimidatory' note accusing her of committing a crime.
The colleague said she was afraid of Ms Leliugiene to the extent that it had affected her health. The complainant was suspended on March 3, 2024 pending a formal investigation.
The WRC heard that she had sent an email to her area manager, stating: 'I want to ask. Because I can't understand how a person like [her] who is addicted to strong drugs, can still work here after falsifying a lot of documents?'
Ms Leliugiene was also accused of 'gossiping' with co-workers and nurses at the National Forensic Mental Health Service about her colleague's alleged drug addiction.
At a subsequent disciplinary hearing, an assistant regional manager for the company concluded that Ms Leliugiene had exhibited 'malicious intent' and 'complete disregard for the dignity and respect' of her colleague.
She said her conduct had been inappropriate and unacceptable, and she was dismissed on May 8, 2024. The decision was upheld following an appeal by Ms Leliugiene.
The complainant clarified that, by 'strong drugs', she had meant prescription drugs, recalling that she had given her Tramadol painkillers once when she had a sore back.
Ms Leliugiene claimed that she had a bad reaction to this medication, losing consciousness and requiring CPR from a colleague. She had to spend a week in Beaumont Hospital afterwards, she added. The Labour Court and Workplace Relations Commission offices on Lansdowne Road (Image: Google Maps)
She could not recall the date when this allegedly occurred, however, and told the WRC that she had not reported the incident to her employer.
In her decision, WRC adjudication officer Catherine Byrne said Ms Leliugiene had been wrong to take concerns over cleaning standards into her own hands by smuggling a phone into the hospital.
This was a 'serious breach of security protocols', and the final written warning she received in response had been justified, she added.
The 'tendency' to take matters into her own hands was repeated when she acted 'in an intimidating manner' towards her colleague, Ms Byrne said.
'I have considered all the evidence and I am satisfied that there were substantial grounds for the dismissal of the complainant and that any reasonable employer in the same circumstances would have dismissed her,' she said.
Ms Byrne further found that the procedures followed by her former employer had been fair 'in all respects', and concluded that the complaint of unfair dismissal was therefore not well founded.
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
