Latest news with #DigitalNationPakistanBill2024
Express Tribune
08-02-2025
- Politics
- Express Tribune
Media rights under threat
Listen to article Pakistan is once again gaining the attention of foreign media - and for negative reasons. This time foreign media is accusing the Pakistani government of media strangulation. Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) has called on overseas Pakistanis to protest globally against the Prevention of Electronic Crimes (PECA) (Amendment) Bill 2025 and the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill 2024. Media rights organisations claim that the PECA (Amendment) Bill 2025 and the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill 2024 would be the last nail in the coffin of an already dead media. Yes, I also believe that media in Pakistan is dead because what is being produced and provided to consumers could be anything but journalistic content. Wishes of anchors are portrayed as news, allegations are called facts, insulting anybody is considered professionalism, and hatemongering against the state is called a valid accountability measure against state institutions. How could media survive in these circumstances that have led the journalistic scene in Pakistan over the last 20 years? As a researcher in the field of Communication Philosophy, I have consistently called out the hybrid media-persons who are ruling TV screens and Op-Ed pages for not having any background in media studies and thus not following media ethics. Placing three cameras in studios inviting four guests free of cost and producing an hour-long show every hour between 7pm and 10pm is a lucrative business, with 'the more the slurs, the more the rating' being the mantra. Political parties use the same hybrid journalists against each other as soon as they come into power in this so-called democratic electoral process. That has been the Pakistani media scene for the last 20 years. Media rights organisations never reprimand absurd media-persons for their unethical media practices and now the same organisations have suddenly joined hands to protect media rights from this monster of their own creation. Does only media have the right to dignity and self-preservation in Pakistan? What about the politicians, judges, civil servants, and military officials who have been abused, insulted and defamed under the pretence of true journalism? Has any other media rights organisation ever taken any action against any media-person spreading unverified defamatory material against government employees, politicians, and state institutions as a household journalistic practice? Are we aware of the damage caused by these decades of unchecked, unverified fearmongering that they pass as journalism in Pakistan? Amidst all these malpractices, there might still be hope for ethical journalistic practices in Pakistan, for there are those that still follow media ethics where news gathering and reporting still follow the rule of accuracy, objectivity, and transparency; where editing and production of paper still go through professional editors who protect the privacy of others, get consent if mentioning someone as an official source, follow rule of balance and diversity when deciding which stories to run and how to present them. They avoid spreading verificatory content and only share verifiable content with their consumers taking the foremost responsibility to keep this content credible, unbiased, and reliable. My experience in Europe over the last 12 years has taught me one vital rule - communication must not have any factor of insult and defamation of anybody around you. In Europe, you cannot get away with insulting anybody or defaming any individual or institution. Insult and defamation are criminal acts all over Europe. In Pakistan, insult is not considered a crime, and defaming anybody has become the only tool in the toolbox of media-persons. If the PECA Act can ensure that nobody can get away with abusing, insulting and defaming any individual in mainstream media and social media then what is the harm in it? It will just put some extra financial burden on media houses to train their employees and teach them media ethics and media laws because 'a free-for-all free fall' cannot be the answer anymore.
Times of Oman
30-01-2025
- Politics
- Times of Oman
Pakistan journalists rally against PECA amendments, decry 'Civilian Martial Law'
Islamabad: The Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (Amendment) Bill 2025 and the Digital Nation Pakistan Bill 2024, which seek to establish a digital economy, society, and governance, were adopted by the upper house on Tuesday despite protests from the opposition benches according to a report by Geo News. The Senate also approved the revisions on Wednesday after it was already passed in the National Assembly. The changes are intended to tighten the noose around people who spread false information and fake news on social media, the government said according to Geo News. The journalism community staged nationwide demonstrations against the "controversial" Prevention of Electronic Crimes (PECA) (Amendment) Bill 2025 on Tuesday. After labelling the PECA law "controversial" due to "lack of clarity" in several legal elements, including the term "fake news," the journalist organisation joined forces in nationwide protests against controversial changes to the law, Geo News reported. Media professionals worry that the altered law may affect press freedom and be used to target them as well. The media community was also incensed at the current administration for enacting the modifications without seeking their input or taking them seriously. Geo News reported that many journalists, attorneys, and members of civil society took part in the agitation organized by the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) outside the National Press Club in Islamabad yesterday, as protests spread throughout the nation's major towns. While chanting anti-PECA Act slogans at the rally, the journalists were observed protesting by wearing chains as per a report by Geo News. Once the protesters arrived near D-Chowk, the rally took the form of a sit-in. Speaking to the participants, the president of PFUJ made it clear that while they did not oppose rules, no one would be permitted to undermine the nation's freedom of expression. Geo News reported that barbed wire was put up and large police contingents were sent to D-Chowk in an attempt to halt the demonstrators' movement. Journalists attempted to break through police-erected obstacles to continue their march but were injured when they attempted to remove the barbed wire. The PFUJ leader was also prevented from leading the march to the Red Zone, where he was tried to be detained by some police officers. Senior journalist Mazhar Abbas, addressing the protest rally, said, "This is the beginning of a historical struggle against a civilian martial law as the first attack was carried out on the judiciary and the second on media." Expressing outrage over the PECA tweaks, he claimed that digital media has been targeted since 2016 and slammed the rulers, saying: "Fake news is not an issue but the actual issue is reporting news" as quoted by Geo News. Abbas further said that some state elements wanted to keep journalism under their control and warned stakeholders not to compromise on the new tweaks, "otherwise, everyone would be controlled".
