Latest news with #ErieCountyCourtofCommonPleas
Yahoo
21-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Verdict in Erie judge race to come in fall as Mosco and Lightner score party nominations
The three-way race for Erie County judge is down to two nominees. In a race in which one of the candidates could have won both party nominations and locked up the race, Emily Mosco Merski took the Democratic nomination and Jeremy Lightner took the Republican nomination, according to final unofficial vote totals the Erie County Elections and Voter Registration Office released at 11:28 p.m. on May 20. The total includes all mail-in ballots, the office said. The third candidate in the judge's race, Leigh Ann Orton, lost both nominations. Merski and Lightner will run against each other in the Nov. 4 municipal election for a seat on the nine-member Erie County Court of Common Pleas. Merski and Lightner are both registered Democrats who cross-filed on the Democratic and Republican ballots. Orton is a registered Republican who also cross-filed. With 100% of precincts reporting, Merski, a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County, received 15,100 votes on the Democratic ballot, or 58.2%, according to the unofficial totals. Lightner received 7,859 Democratic votes, or 30.29%, and Orton received 2,936 or 11.32%. On the Republican side, Lightner led with 5,801 votes, or 37.27%. Orton received 4,924 Republican votes, or 31.63%, and Merski received 4,806, or 30.87%. Merski, 42, is a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County who also has a private law practice. Lightner, 39, is one of two chief deputy district attorneys for Erie County. Both live in the city of Erie. More: Review coverage from the Erie County municipal primary Orton, 53, is the first assistant solicitor for Erie County. She lives in North East Township and unsuccessfully ran for judge in 2023. Merski was the only candidate who received a "recommended" rating in the Erie County Bar Association's lawyers' poll. Lightner and Orton both received "no rating." Merski and Lightner's campaigns both relied on personal loans and in-kind contributions for funding. Orton's campaign raised the least of the three, according to pre-primary campaign finance filings. The winner on Nov. 4 will fill the seat on the local bench that has been vacant since Judge Elizabeth K. Kelly retired in April 2024. Contact Ed Palattella at epalattella@ or 814-870-1813. This article originally appeared on Erie Times-News: Mosco, Lightner win nominations in judge's race, will compete in fall
Yahoo
12-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
'Comfortable making hard decisions': Q&A with prosecutor Jeremy Lightner in judge's race
As one of two chief deputy district attorneys for Erie County, Jeremy Lightner helps District Attorney Elizabeth Hirz run the office. Lightner has spent much of his career prosecuting cases that involve guns and gangs. He said he wants to use that experience "to help make this county a better place" as a judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas. Lightner is running in the May 20 municipal primary against Emily Mosco Merski, a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County; and Leigh Ann Orton, the first assistant solicitor for Erie County. Party registration: Democrat. Lightner is cross-filed as a Democrat and a Republican. Age: 39 Residence: City of Erie Experience: Prosecutor in the Erie County District Attorney's Office since 2014. Trial chief deputy district attorney since 2023. Started career as law clerk to Erie County Judge Shad Connelly, now retired. Education: Bloomsburg University; law degree from University of Illinois. Admitted to Pennsylvania bar in 2012. Personal: Married to Sarah Lipiec Lightner, an intensive care unit nurse; one child Social media: Erie County Bar Association poll: No rating Question: Why do you want to be a judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas? Answer: I'm excited to use my skills to help make this county a better place. A good judge comes down to sound decision-making, and we need to elect people that are comfortable making hard decisions. I've been making hard decisions about whom to prosecute harshly and leniently for years, and I've been getting those decisions right — the drop in gun violence in Erie coincides with my assignment to reduce gun and gang violence in 2021. But the criminal justice system is just a small part of our legal system, and crime is a downstream result of the biggest problem plaguing our county: poverty. I'm excited to work to get decisions right for vulnerable people so that their lives can be bettered, rather than harmed, by the court system. Describe the case that has had the most impact on you as a lawyer. When I was a prosecutor on Veterans Court, one of the veterans struggled with addiction. He had significant issues from his service in the Iraq war, and he had fallen into addiction and crime. In Veterans Court, you have weekly meetings with the veteran to keep on top of him and ensure he's in a good place. This veteran kept relapsing, no matter how hard he tried. The fifth time this happened, the veteran came into court crying and I ended up alone with him and one of the probation officers. He talked about his nightmares and what caused him to relapse with deep insight, and thanked us for all we had done to make his life better, because it was better than it had been before Veterans Court. It was one of the most emotional conversations of my life, and I will never forget it. That veteran eventually lost his battle with addiction. That "case" taught me that we can never stop fighting for those in our community, and even if we don't reach our loftiest goals, putting in the time and energy to improve their lives is worth it. It also reminded me that being a lawyer isn't about rules and statutes. Those may be the tools of the trade, but we joined this profession to help make people's lives better, and fighting the noble fight is the most important thing you can do. Describe any changes or innovations that you would like to bring to Common Pleas Court. Watching youth gun violence in the city, I want to create programming that attacks these problems, rather than manages them. First, I think that court programming can be more aggressive with at-risk kids at an earlier age, and can try to incorporate mentorship, consequences and development into a cohesive program before they have committed crimes of violence, rather than punishing them appropriately after. Second, I believe that a program needs to exist for those charged with crimes. Right now, pretrial bond is the same whether an individual has a DUI, a retail theft or is charged with attempted homicide for shooting someone. That doesn't seem right, and I have noticed that other cities in our state have developed a "gun court" to make sure these cases, which involve significantly more public danger than the average case, are handled in thoughtful ways to make sure the community is safe and those charged are given the best chance to come out of the case as safer, better members of society. Finally, I think that housing issues are a blight upon Erie, and I do think that a housing court would allow the city, landlords and tenants to fully handle issues that seem to fall to the wayside currently in the system. Contact Ed Palattella at epalattella@ or 814-870-1813. This article originally appeared on Erie Times-News: Erie County judge race: Jeremy Lightner touts work as prosecutor
Yahoo
12-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
'Well-rounded understanding': Q&A with public defender Emily Mosco Merski in judge's race
Emily Mosco Merski is a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County who has handled a range of other matters, including in civil and family court. Merski said her "diverse legal background" is among her qualifications to be the next judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas. Merski is running in the May 20 municipal primary against Jeremy Lightner, a chief district attorney for Erie County; and Leigh Ann Orton, the first assistant solicitor for Erie County. Party registration: Democrat. Merski is cross-filed as a Democrat and a Republican. Age: 42 Residence: City of Erie Experience: Solo practice at Vendetti & Vendetti law firm in Erie for past 13 years. Part-time assistant public defender for Erie County, specializing in appeals, since 2012. Started career as an associate at Knox Law Firm in Erie. Education: Mercyhurst College; law degree from Penn State Dickinson Law. Admitted to the Pennsylvania bar in 2011. Personal: Married to state Rep. Bob Merski, a Democrat who represents the 2nd District in the Pennsylvania House; two children Social media: Erie County Bar Association poll: Recommended Question: Why do you want to be a judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas? Answer: I believe my diverse legal background, commitment to justice and dedication to serving the community uniquely position me to be an effective addition to the bench. Throughout my career, I have gained extensive experience across many areas of law, including criminal defense, civil litigation, family law and juvenile matters. This broad perspective has given me a well-rounded understanding of the legal system and its profound impact on individuals and families. As a public defender, I have advocated for people who are often marginalized and voiceless, and I have witnessed firsthand how deeply the justice system affects lives and futures. I believe one of the most important roles a judge plays that of the "what-happens-next" person in someone's life. When I chose to become a lawyer, especially an indigent defense attorney, it was with the hope of making a meaningful difference in the lives of others. As a judge, the opportunity to guide individuals through the next steps —whether in criminal, juvenile, civil or family law matters — is an incredible responsibility. Describe the case that has had the most impact on you as a lawyer. As a new public defender, I was assigned to handle an appeal in a high-profile case. I was already familiar with the matter from news reports and, like many, had formed preconceived notions about the client and their actions. However, as I worked through the case, I quickly realized that my personal feelings about my client and their conduct could not influence my advocacy. This experience taught me a fundamental lesson: Not everyone views the world through the same lens. People's actions are shaped by a multitude of factors, including their experiences and perspectives. Whether their actions were right or wrong, I came away from that case with a deeper understanding of the importance of meeting people where they are, listening without judgment and striving to understand the challenges that brought them into the courtroom. With that newfound perspective, I was able to advocate more effectively for my clients and appreciate the human aspects of their cases. As Erie County's next judge, I bring the recognition and understanding that those who appear before the court are not merely case numbers, but individuals whose lives — and futures — can be profoundly impacted by the court's decisions. Describe any changes or innovations that you would like to bring to Common Pleas Court. The eight Common Pleas judges currently serving in Erie County strive to make a significant and meaningful impact on our community. Having been in the courtroom nearly every day of my practice, I have seen, firsthand, the impact the legal system has on individuals and families. If given the opportunity, I would seek to complement their efforts with a strong commitment to improving public understanding of court operations and enhancing the accessibility and transparency of court proceedings.I believe that a fair and effective judiciary requires not only legal expertise but also a connection to the community it serves. Judges must be approachable and engaged, ensuring that the people who come before the court feel seen, heard and understood. Ongoing community involvement not only promotes transparency but also provides valuable insight into the real world challenges facing individuals and families in Erie County. I am actively involved with organizations that broaden my perspective on the needs of our community. I currently serve on the boards of Erie Homes for Children and Adults and the Mercy Center for Women, among others. It is this unique combination of professional experience and community engagement that I would bring to the bench. Contact Ed Palattella at epalattella@ or 814-870-1813. This article originally appeared on Erie Times-News: Erie County judge race: Emily Mosco Merski cites community service
Yahoo
12-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
A public defender, a prosecutor and a solicitor: 3 candidates vie for Erie County judge
The three lawyers have different practices areas and levels of experience. But they are all aiming for the same job — a judge on the nine-member Erie County Court of Common Pleas. Emily Mosco Merski, 42, a Democrat, is a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County who also in private practice. Jeremy Lightner, 39, a Democrat, is a chief deputy district attorney for Erie County. Leigh Ann Orton, 53, a Republican, is the first assistant solicitor for Erie County who is also in private practice. All three candidates have cross-filed on the Democratic and Republican ballots, meaning the race will be narrowed to at least two candidates in the municipal primary on May 20. Voters could pick a Democratic and a Republican nominee. Or a candidate could lock up both nominations. Then the sole nominee on both tickets would be all but guaranteed victory on Nov. 4 to a 10-year-term as judge, with a retention vote not until 2035. Candidate controversy: Nomination petitions were challenged in Erie County judge race. The case quickly unraveled The annual salary, as set by law, is currently $227,411. The mandatory retirement age is 75. The winner in November will fill a seat that has been vacant since the retirement of Judge Elizabeth K. Kelly in April 2024. Of the three candidates this year, only Orton has run for office before. She lost in a race for Erie County judge two years ago. Judicial candidates in Pennsylvania are prohibited from commenting on how they would rule on specific cases. The limitation puts the focus on the candidates' backgrounds and experience. In the case of judges in Erie County, lawyers with the Erie County Bar Association weigh in on who they think are most qualified. The association's members gave Merski the only "recommended" rating in a poll released in late April. Another marquee race: Democrats Devlin, Schember spar over city of Erie's finances as mayor's race heats up The Erie Times-News asked each of the candidates about their qualifications and experience and why they want to be a judge. The candidates are listed in alphabetical order. Read their responses here: Emily Mosco Merski cites community service Jeremy Lightner touts work as prosecutor Leigh Ann Orton focuses on family law in run For more information, the Erie County Bar Association's website includes the judges' resumes and their answers to the association's questions. The results of the lawyers' poll are also on the site. Contact Ed Palattella at epalattella@ or 814-870-1813. This article originally appeared on Erie Times-News: Three candidates make their arguments in race for Erie County judge
Yahoo
12-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
'Well-rounded understanding': Q&A with public defender Emily Mosco Merski in judge's race
Emily Mosco Merski is a part-time assistant public defender for Erie County who has handled a range of other matters, including in civil and family court. Merski said her "diverse legal background" is among her qualifications to be the next judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas. Merski is running in the May 20 municipal primary against Jeremy Lightner, a chief district attorney for Erie County; and Leigh Ann Orton, the first assistant solicitor for Erie County. Party registration: Democrat. Merski is cross-filed as a Democrat and a Republican. Age: 42 Residence: City of Erie Experience: Solo practice at Vendetti & Vendetti law firm in Erie for past 13 years. Part-time assistant public defender for Erie County, specializing in appeals, since 2012. Started career as an associate at Knox Law Firm in Erie. Education: Mercyhurst College; law degree from Penn State Dickinson Law. Admitted to the Pennsylvania bar in 2011. Personal: Married to state Rep. Bob Merski, a Democrat who represents the 2nd District in the Pennsylvania House; two children Social media: Erie County Bar Association poll: Recommended Question: Why do you want to be a judge on the Erie County Court of Common Pleas? Answer: I believe my diverse legal background, commitment to justice and dedication to serving the community uniquely position me to be an effective addition to the bench. Throughout my career, I have gained extensive experience across many areas of law, including criminal defense, civil litigation, family law and juvenile matters. This broad perspective has given me a well-rounded understanding of the legal system and its profound impact on individuals and families. As a public defender, I have advocated for people who are often marginalized and voiceless, and I have witnessed firsthand how deeply the justice system affects lives and futures. I believe one of the most important roles a judge plays that of the "what-happens-next" person in someone's life. When I chose to become a lawyer, especially an indigent defense attorney, it was with the hope of making a meaningful difference in the lives of others. As a judge, the opportunity to guide individuals through the next steps —whether in criminal, juvenile, civil or family law matters — is an incredible responsibility. Describe the case that has had the most impact on you as a lawyer. As a new public defender, I was assigned to handle an appeal in a high-profile case. I was already familiar with the matter from news reports and, like many, had formed preconceived notions about the client and their actions. However, as I worked through the case, I quickly realized that my personal feelings about my client and their conduct could not influence my advocacy. This experience taught me a fundamental lesson: Not everyone views the world through the same lens. People's actions are shaped by a multitude of factors, including their experiences and perspectives. Whether their actions were right or wrong, I came away from that case with a deeper understanding of the importance of meeting people where they are, listening without judgment and striving to understand the challenges that brought them into the courtroom. With that newfound perspective, I was able to advocate more effectively for my clients and appreciate the human aspects of their cases. As Erie County's next judge, I bring the recognition and understanding that those who appear before the court are not merely case numbers, but individuals whose lives — and futures — can be profoundly impacted by the court's decisions. Describe any changes or innovations that you would like to bring to Common Pleas Court. The eight Common Pleas judges currently serving in Erie County strive to make a significant and meaningful impact on our community. Having been in the courtroom nearly every day of my practice, I have seen, firsthand, the impact the legal system has on individuals and families. If given the opportunity, I would seek to complement their efforts with a strong commitment to improving public understanding of court operations and enhancing the accessibility and transparency of court proceedings.I believe that a fair and effective judiciary requires not only legal expertise but also a connection to the community it serves. Judges must be approachable and engaged, ensuring that the people who come before the court feel seen, heard and understood. Ongoing community involvement not only promotes transparency but also provides valuable insight into the real world challenges facing individuals and families in Erie County. I am actively involved with organizations that broaden my perspective on the needs of our community. I currently serve on the boards of Erie Homes for Children and Adults and the Mercy Center for Women, among others. It is this unique combination of professional experience and community engagement that I would bring to the bench. Contact Ed Palattella at epalattella@ or 814-870-1813. This article originally appeared on Erie Times-News: Erie County judge race: Emily Mosco Merski cites community service
