5 days ago
Two charged year after Ransom student killed while wakeboarding in Biscayne Bay
Two boaters were charged with misdemeanor careless boating charges in the May 2024 death of a Ransom Everglades School student who was struck by a boat while she and a friend were wakeboarding behind a yacht in Biscayne Bay.
Ella Adler, 15, and another girl were being towed by a 42-foot yacht off Nixon Beach in Key Biscayne on May 11, 2024, when she was hit by a 42-foot Boston Whaler driven by 79-year-old Carlos Guillermo Alonso, whose attorneys maintained he never knew he hit Ella.
He drove his boat back to his Coral Gables home after striking Adler.
The tragedy made international headlines because Ella was the granddaughter of Michael Adler, then the U.S. ambassador to Belgium. Adler was formerly president of the Greater Miami Jewish Federation and vice chair of the Florida International University Board of Trustees.
Prosecutors charged Alonso with two counts of careless boating on May 20, court records show. Despite several records requests from the Herald, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission hasn't provided the Herald a copy of its final report, which is usually completed before charges are recommended.
Edmund Richard Hartley, 31, the yacht captain towing Adler and another girl, was charged with four counts of careless boating, including one count for not having a lookout to keep an eye on the girls.
The 2017 Hanse Fjord yacht Hartley captained is owned by Jonathan Rothberg, a biotech multimillionaire who bought a $23.5-million home on the Venetian Causeway in 2021.
Alonso and Hartley pleaded not guilty on May 21. A trial is set for June 30.
Attorneys for both Alonso and Hartley did not immediately respond to requests for comment from the Herald.
This is a developing story and will be updated.
