05-03-2025
MS House lawmakers push school choice as Senate chairman kills proposals. Read details
Hours after the Senate Education Committee killed several House priorities for the year, the House Education Committee on Tuesday killed a flurry of Senate bills and revived an effort to allow students to more easily move between school districts.
On Tuesday, as a legislative deadline loomed, the House Education Committee amended and passed only one bill sent over from the Senate. By the time the deadline passed Tuesday evening, both committees had let education initiatives in both chambers die, citing lack of support for some and wanting to continue negotiations on others.
While it is typical of every session for committees not to advance bills that passed the other chamber, House Education Chairman Rob Roberson, R-Starkville, said this could be seen as a tactic to force negotiations for at least some school choice legislation either this year or next.
"There's lots of places to put other things in conference," House Education Chairman Rob Roberson, R-Starkville, said. "As we're developing (through the session), a lot of the bills were probably going to die anyway. Anything that dies this year, we're going to be coming back with next year."
The House Education Committee, after learning the Senate killed several bills dealing with school choice, charter school expansion and school district consolidation, paused its business to speak with House leadership.
School choice: School choice in MS House lives by in-house rule, not Democratic principle. See details
When the committee met three hours later, it amended a Senate bill to allow for public-to-public school district movement for students, leaving all others on the cutting room floor.
That piece of legislation would allow for students to move to another school district without the permission of the school district of origin. The state would also pay for any student transfers and fund the idea with $5 million if it passes, per the House proposal.
Rep. Jansen Owen, R-Poplarville, said this was an effort to continue discussions on giving parents some choice for the children's education.
When asked why he killed the original House bill dealing with portability, Senate Education Chairman Dennis Debar, R-Leakesville, said there were concerns about how student funding would flow between districts, whether student athletes would have an unfair advantage and a lack of support in the Senate.
School choice lacks support: Why universal school choice is unlikely to pass in 2025 MS Legislature? Read here
"Nothing will happen this year as far as requiring public-to-public (portability)," Debar said. "I still would like to have it studied, so that might come up later this year. I do not believe you'll see anything regarding portability being implemented this year.'
Lt. Gov. Delbert Hosemann in a written response to the Clarion Ledger, said portability, or public-to-public school transfers, was not popular among his senators.
"I have always supported public-to-public portability with capacity requirements and will continue to do so despite not currently having the votes,"
House Speaker Jason White, R-West, called out Hosemann for not driving for the legislation despite making it a legislative priority.
"He supported it, he talked about it on a political stump even this past year," White said to reporters. "That bill (now) languishes somewhere in a committee."
DeBar also said that he killed the other school choice bills because he wants to wait for studies to be produced and discussed on charter school expansion and on a statewide school district consolidation effort.
The portability bill is part of a much larger debate in the state Capitol regarding school choice, a loose term for legislation seeking to give parents more state-funded choices for the children's education.
Those debates typically run hot for some Mississippi Democrats, who in the House have equivocated portability, or public-to-public school transfer reform, as being akin to a path toward legalized segregation in public schools, while others have voiced concerns about student athletes taking advantage of the program to play at better performing schools.
School choice tax credits: This week in politics: School choice bills return for second round in MS House
What is school choice? How are Mississippi lawmakers advancing the school choice agenda in 2025? See here
"This is a bill that claims to expand educational opportunities, but in reality, it plans to weaken our public school systems," Rep. John Faulkner, D-Holly Springs, said of the House portability bill before it passed out of the House in February. "It provides no funding for transportation, making it a privilege for those who can afford it, while leaving behind students in struggling districts. Furthermore, it risks diverting critical funds from under resourced schools."
As for what school choice legislation is left to consider this session, the field is almost clear. White, who has for the second year in a row put education reform, including school choice, within his top legislative priorities, has repeatedly said the state should do something to give parents more options for education.
Other school choice bills dealing with a tax credit program, the Children's Promise Act, also await further consideration in the Senate.
Grant McLaughlin covers state government for the Clarion Ledger. He can be reached at gmclaughlin@ or 972-571-2335
This article originally appeared on Mississippi Clarion Ledger: MS House: School choice again a focal point
