29-01-2025
Bemidji school board approves Pledge of Allegiance with 4-2 vote
Jan. 28—BEMIDJI — Two years after being voted down, the Pledge of Allegiance will have a place in
Bemidji Area Schools
Board of Education meetings.
During its first regular meeting of 2025 on Monday, the board secured a 4-2 vote to add the pledge's recitation to the beginning of each meeting.
A similar measure was proposed in January 2023
but was voted down with a 3-3 vote.
Board chair Dave Wall presented the proposal, laying out the protocol and reasons behind it.
"There was a day in America that the Pledge of Allegiance was recited in many sectors of our society by all citizens. Political affiliation, ethnicity or religious persuasion were not a concern," Wall said. "Citizens of this great country came together with their differences and recited the pledge to show that they were committed in unity to the United States of America.
"The unity of our nation is the strength of our nation. Unity guarantees value to each citizen and accommodates diversity."
The protocol notes that those who wish to participate in the pledge's recitation would stand and face the flag, place their hand on their hearts and follow the lead of the board chair. Those who don't wish to participate are free to do so without judgement or consternation, Wall added.
Following the introduction of the motion by board members Anna Manecke and Jack Aakhus, member Ann Long Voelkner expressed her opposition to adding the pledge to meetings, consistent with her stance from two years ago.
"I have sworn, as everybody else has, the oath of office to serve our country and students as a public school board member," Long Voelkner said. "The oath specifically says 'I support the Constitution of the United States and the state of Minnesota.' ... I believe this oath speaks specifically to our role as board members to provide quality education for our students in a safe setting for teachers, staff and students. The Pledge of Allegiance does not speak to that role."
Long Voelkner pointed to the addition of "under God" in the pledge in 1954 following Congressional approval.
"That addition to the pledge ties religion to civil government matters in opposition to our Constitution," she added. "My choice is not to recite the pledge, which reflects our separation of church and state within the Constitution, and also reflects the oath of office I have sworn to."
Board member Jenny Frenzel remained steadfast in her opposition to adding the pledge, a position met with its own opposition in 2023.
"I received personal threats on my life. I received personal threats against my children, against my family, against my business," Frenzel said regarding the aftermath of her no vote. "I had to make a police report and a restraining order just because I shared my opinion."
Frenzel also shared correspondence with then-non-member Todd Haugen, who confirmed that he would've voted down the pledge when the measure was first proposed.
"I admire someone who's willing to take a difficult vote, and I've always been a bit ambivalent about the Pledge of Allegiance," Haugen said, "but I was really impressed, as I ran for the board this past fall, how many people asked me about the pledge. It's an issue to them. ... The message I got loud and clear during the campaign was that people want us to do this."
Aakhus condemned all forms of threats and harassment while emphasizing his view that the motion was to allow a choice in whether a board member wants to recite the pledge.
"Have many Americans been denied liberty and justice? Yes. Are some still denied it today? Yes. Are liberty and justice still ideals worth honoring and committing ourselves to today? Yes," Aakhus said. "This is why we say the pledge."
There is no statutory requirement for school boards to recite the pledge, but many boards add it to meetings if members so choose.
Minnesota State Statute 121A.11,
subdivision 3a, dictates that all public and charter school students shall recite the Pledge of Allegiance one or more times each week. Subdivision 3b of the same statute allows students to decline the recitation.
Student representative Mckenzie Edevold brought up issues related to the pledge in schools particularly for students who decline its recitation.
"Kids definitely get made fun of if they sit during the pledge. I've seen teachers say something to them and tell them to get up," Edevold said. "It's kind of robotic the way the pledge is said, and I don't know if it has any meaning saying it during school."
After more discussion, the board passed the measure with Aakhus, Haugen, Wall and Manecke voting for it and Frenzel and Long Voelkner voting against.
In other business, the board unanimously approved a tentative agreement with the Bemidji Education Support Professionals bargaining group for 2023-2025.
The group, which represents secretarial-clerical employees and paraprofessionals,
has advocated for a more equitable contract and increased salaries at prior board meetings.
The agreement includes a 2% increase in the salary schedule for 2023-2024 and a $1 per hour increase for 2024-2025. District health insurance contributions remain unchanged at $845 a month, but as of July 2024, the district will contribute an additional $165 per month for those with family health insurance coverage.
Among other adjustments, the agreement's two-year cost totals roughly $1 million.
The full meeting can be viewed on the
Bemidji Area Schools YouTube channel.
The next regular board meeting is scheduled for 6:30 p.m. on Monday, Feb. 24, in the district board room.
