6 days ago
Federal court in Florida halts DeSantis-backed youth social media ban, cites free speech
A federal judge in Tallahassee has temporarily blocked part of a Florida law restricting minors' access to social media, finding it "likely unconstitutional."
Chief U.S. District Judge Mark E. Walker on June 3 said he recognized First Amendment protections to prevent the state from "substantially burdening speech unless (it) can show that doing so is necessary to achieve its significant interests."
The law (HB 3), passed in 2024, was supposed to go into effect this Jan. 1, but the state attorney general's office agreed not to enforce it until the judge ruled on a request for what's known as a preliminary injunction. Such orders are issued early in a lawsuit to temporarily stop something, like enforcement of a law, until the case is fully decided.
Initial Rulings: Florida social media minor restriction won't be immediately enforced against top platforms
The judge's 58-page order only blocks the portion of the state law that the associations who filed the lawsuit are focused on. It prohibits anyone under 16 from using some social media platforms, excluding 14- and 15-year-olds who obtain their parent's permission.
Walker also wrote that he "does not doubt that parents and legislators in the state have sincere concerns about the effects that social media use may have on youth, nor does it render parents or the state powerless to address those concerns."
NetChoice and the Computer & Communications Industry Association — trade associations representing social media platforms like Meta, Google, Youtube and Snapchat — first filed suit against the law in October, citing First Amendment concerns.
The law, which was signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis, also required age verification to access pornographic websites in Florida, but the lawsuit is only focused on the social media provisions.
Governor's approval: DeSantis signs social media restrictions for kids, age verification for porn sites
'This ruling vindicates our argument that Florida's statute violates the First Amendment by blocking and restricting minors – and likely adults as well – from using certain (social media) websites to view lawful content," said Matt Schruers, president of Computer & Communications Industry Association in a statement.
Attorney General James Uthmeier's office said it disagrees with the judge's decision and plans to appeal, according to spokesperson Jeremy Redfern.
"Florida parents voted through their elected representatives for a law protecting kids from the harmful and sometimes lifelong tragic impacts of social media," Redfern said in a statement. "These platforms do not have a constitutional right to addict kids to their products."
In an interview with the USA TODAY Network – Florida, Schruers said the case on minors' use of social media platforms was an example of how lawmakers revisited a 2021 law on social media concerns.
That 2021 law is still pending a challenge in court by the same two trade associations. It was lauded by DeSantis at the time in reaction to social media platforms "shadowbanning" or outright suspending political candidates. (Shadowbanning is when a user's content on a platform is hidden or made less visible without their knowledge.)
The law also enabled Floridians to sue these social media platforms if they proved an unjustified ban.
The groups wrote at the time that Florida was free to criticize websites for their decisions on what to moderate or restrict, but argued that the First Amendment prevented them from overriding editorial judgments.
The case even made it to the U.S. Supreme Court, which sent the case back to federal court in Florida. That matter still has a jury trial scheduled for March 9.
Brought back to Florida: Both sides claim victory as US Supreme Court punts on Florida social media case
This reporting content is supported by a partnership with Freedom Forum and Journalism Funding Partners. USA Today Network-Florida First Amendment reporter Stephany Matat is based in Tallahassee, Fla. She can be reached at SMatat@ On X: @stephanymatat.
This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: DeSantis-backed youth social media ban paused amid free speech issues
