4 days ago
Retrial ordered for corrections officer Nadia Khalil for alleged abuse of juveniles
An appeals court has quashed the conviction of a former New South Wales juvenile corrections officer and ordered she face a retrial for allegedly abusing five boys in her care.
In 2021, Nadia Khalil was sentenced to 12 years in jail with a non-parole period of more than seven years for sexually assaulting five boys at Reiby Juvenile Justice Centre near Campbelltown on the outskirts of Sydney.
She appealed against the decision, alleging a forensic psychologist gave evidence outside his area of expertise.
In the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal hearing on March 3, Ms Khalil's barrister Phillip Boulten SC argued that allowing a report by clinical and forensic psychologist Christopher Lennings to be admitted as evidence was a miscarriage of justice.
Dr Lennings's website said his areas of research interest include violent and sexually violent young offenders, youth suicide and child protection.
The court heard the doctor was asked to review literature regarding young males being sexually victimised by staff in detention centres.
"We say his evidence was not based on specialised knowledge of youth detention guards," Mr Boulten told the hearing.
Appellant justices Peter Garling, Dina Yehia and Belinda Rigg handed down their restricted decision today.
Information is limited in the restricted judgement, but it does say that the justices considered whether "the opinion about youth workers was irrelevant and highly prejudicial".
The three appellant judges today ordered the convictions and sentence be quashed, ruling that the appeal be allowed.
The trio also made an order that there be a retrial of the appellant.
They also ordered the case be sent back to the District Court for mention on June 6.
Reiby houses children up to 15 years of age and the state's youngest detainees have been incarcerated there.
The appeals court was told she held a position of trust and authority.
Ms Khalil's alleged offending occurred between 1997 and 2005.
