15 hours ago
Weeks after being sued, city of Miami repeals anti-panhandling law
Miami city commissioners on Tuesday repealed a city ordinance that criminalized aggressive panhandling.
The repeal comes a few weeks after the Florida Justice Institute filed a lawsuit against the city, arguing that the ordinance violated the First Amendment and did not apply to other forms of speech, like a political candidate asking for support or a church member proselytizing, the Miami Herald previously reported.
The city enacted the ordinance prohibiting 'aggressive' or 'obstructive' panhandling in 2000, according to the lawsuit. Violators could be fined $100 or jailed for up to 30 days for a first offense, or fined $200 and jailed up to 60 days for subsequent offenses.
Miami police officers had arrested nearly 400 people for 'aggressively' panhandling in city limits within the last two years, the lawsuit noted.
'Requesting donations is speech protected by the First Amendment,' Ray Taseff, lead attorney with the Florida Justice Institute, said in a news release last month. 'The City cannot single out panhandling for differential treatment because it deems that speech unpleasant. Arresting poor people because they ask others for help is morally wrong, bad policy, and accomplishes nothing except wasting valuable police resources.'
Miami repealed a previous panhandling ordinance in 2024 after it was sued by the Florida Justice Institute in 2023. The plaintiff in that case, Willie White, who was 65 at the time of the 2023 lawsuit, had been arrested twice for panhandling in the span of a month. The city eventually settled with White for $45,000.
