20-05-2025
Mass. DCF seeks to block names of lawyers, others in Harmony Montgomery custody hearing
A Massachusetts agency aimed at keeping children safe from abuse and neglect has asked for a 'minor amendment' in the decision by that state's highest court to allow a documentary filmmaker access to audio recordings of a hearing after which Harmony Montgomery ended up in the custody of her father.
The requested amendment is to require the redaction of all names, including those of lawyers, social workers and court personnel, 'due to safety concerns,' according to court documents obtained by the Union Leader. Several documents have been impounded.
Harmony's father, Adam Montgomery, was convicted last year of beating the little girl to death about 10 months after he gained custody in February 2019.
SJC Montgomery request
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court granted journalist Bill Lichtenstein of LC Media access to the audio of these hearings from February 2019, but the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families has since requested the court amend its order to redact the names.
The court's original order only called for redaction of the names of other children, according to the ruling.
Lichtenstein is working on a documentary called 'Broken,' a feature-length documentary on the failed child welfare, foster care and family court systems in Massachusetts and nationally.
Limited information on what happened in the hearing, held in Essex Juvenile Court, has been released in multiple reports. The hearing focused on Adam Montgomery's fitness as a parent, the ruling read.
Montgomery had a violent past and was incarcerated at the time of Harmony's birth.
In her request for further redactions, Kristin Braithwaite, assistant general counsel for the Mass. DCF, said interest in the case had presented itself 'in the form of anger and threats,' and the key participants did not willingly accept publicity.
'The juvenile court judge who presided over the hearing in question has attested to receiving multiple threats upon his identity being learned of by the public,' she said.
The Committee for Public Counsel Services has filed a similar request, which is impounded.
Braithwaite argued the release of the names will not provide information to help prevent a future tragedy.
'Impounding these names will not limit the impact or efficacy of this court's order,' Braithwaite said
Lichtenstein's attorney, Jennifer Lamanna, said the request should have been 'briefed and argued as part of earlier filings and oral arguments."
'With regard to the redaction of the names of counsel, attorneys and judges in high profile cases are regularly named in the press and, of course, in non-impounded proceedings, identifiable from the court's public records,' Lamanna said in opposition.
The court ruled Lichtenstein 'met the standard for relief from impoundment as to all information contained in the audio,' except the privacy interest of other children.
Lamanna called any threat 'speculative and remote,' in her filing.
Adam Montgomery was convicted in February 2024 of second-degree murder, abuse of a corpse and other charges related to Harmony's death. He was sentenced to 56 years to life to be served on top of a minimum 32-year sentence for prior firearms convictions.
Harmony's remains have yet to be found.
jphelps@
