21-05-2025
- Business
- New Indian Express
‘Not every Neha can be yours': HC in trademark tussle case
The legal battle was between Sahni Cosmetics (plaintiff), which claimed it had been selling face creams under the 'NEHA' brand since 1990, and Neha Herbals (defendant), which said it had been doing mehendi and herbal stuff since 1992. Sahni sought to cancel Neha Herbals' trademark rights altogether. But the court wasn't buying it, as Sahni couldn't provide proper evidence, no invoices, no steady trademark records, and not even a nostalgic '90s TV ad to prove their point.
'Trademark rights do not arise in the abstract... rather, those rights accrue through tangible trading and commercial activities that identify the origin of products or services to the consumers,' read the order.
'While plaintiffs' goodwill in the trademark 'NEHA' is established, it remains confined to the domain of mehendi and herbal hair-care preparations. There is insufficient evidence to suggest that such goodwill extended to creams or general cosmetics before the institution of the suit,' the court said.
The court said the defendant has failed to discharge the burden of proving prior use in terms of the products for which the plaintiff has registration or any statutory ground under Sections 47 or 57 of the Trade Marks Act to warrant cancellation.
