06-05-2025
- Politics
- The Herald Scotland
FM faces backlash over 'disappointing' plans on affordable homes
Delivering his programme for government, Mr Swinney told MSPs his plans would include 'investment in thousands of new homes', however, both Shelter Scotland and the Scottish Federation Of Housing Associations have said there is an 'urgent need' for quicker and bolder action.
The legislative plans include more rights and stronger protections for tenants as well as a re-announced promise to deliver more than 8,000 affordable homes, including for social and mid-market rent. They also promise to remove barriers on stalled building sites 'with the potential to deliver up to 20,000 new homes'.
However, Shelter Scotland believes the plans are not sufficient to tackle Scotland's national housing emergency which was declared a year ago.
Shelter Scotland Director Alison Watson said: 'It is disappointing to hear the Programme for Government today, which lacked crucial detail about how the Scottish Government plans to tackle the housing emergency.
'While we welcome the continuation of the plans which have already been announced, this is simply not enough.
'We are coming up to a year since a national housing emergency was declared. The situation is deteriorating across the country with a record high number of children trapped in temporary accommodation.
'There are still no significant increases in plans for social home building, extra budgets or investment in housing services to prevent more people becoming homeless.'
Read more:
Scotland housing charities urge Swinney commit to homebuilding pledge
Ms Watson added: 'Shelter Scotland wanted a programme for secure homes, but all we have is a programme for homelessness.'
In a debate after the FM delivered a statement on his legislative plans to the parliament, Scottish Labour's Mark Griffin claimed the government has so far failed to get Scotland 'anywhere near' their target of building 110,000 affordable homes by 2032.
His comments after The Herald reported that Scottish housing charities had written to the First Minister urging him to make a pledge to build more homes in his programme for government which he did not commit to.
The MSP added: 'The 8,000 re-announced in the programme for government won't be enough to get that target back on track which I isn't a surprise given that the huge housing budget cut was only partially restored this year.
'Can I ask the First Minister, in line with pleas made by Shelter and Homes for Scotland, to pledge to build the homes we all need or will the 110,000 affordable homes target be another broken promise.'
The First Minister responded to Mr Griffin, stating that the housing budget is 'higher than it was' in the previous year, adding that they have 'remedied that particular issue'.
Mr Swinney said: 'I would just encourage the Labour party to accept the facts and move on, find something else to talk about, find something else to moan given that we've addressed the issue about the budget that we've put in place.
'In Scotland, we have delivered more affordable houses per head of population than in England or in Wales in the face of austerity.
The legislative agenda also included a pledge to deliver the Heating in Buildings aimed at reducing carbon emissions by installing clean heating systems by 2045 - a move welcomed by the SFHA. However, they believe the government could be delivering much bolder action overall.
Responding to the First Minister's plans, SFHA Chief Executive Sally Thomas said: 'The First Minister is right to acknowledge the concern of people unable to find affordable housing: this is an issue that is rapidly rising up the public agenda.
"With nearly a quarter of a million people across Scotland currently on a waiting list for a social home, and a housing emergency declared almost a year ago, it was vital that today's Programme for Government set out coherent action to increase the provision of affordable rented homes.
"The measures announced today are welcome, but don't go far enough to tackle Scotland's dire situation on housing.
'A decent, stable home is the foundation of the fairer, greener and more prosperous Scotland the First Minister wants to build. So we are glad to see continued ambition to build 110,000 affordable homes by 2032. But for this to have any chance of becoming a reality, the Scottish Government must quickly set out multi-year funding commitments, so that our members can plan with confidence to build much-needed homes.
'We are disappointed that there is still no commitment to exempt Mid Market Rent homes from private rented sector rent controls. This type of housing is highly valued by younger people and professionals in particular, but it may become unviable unless the government amends the Housing Bill.
'It is reassuring to see commitment to a Heat in Buildings Bill. But we need certainty on the targets our members will need to meet, as well as a fair and equal approach to the standards required of every housing tenure, including home ownership and private rent. And we had urged government to provide a clear pathway to funding on removing unsafe cladding: we can't allow this burden to fall on social tenants.
'A warm, secure, affordable home is the foundation of all our lives, and while this Programme for Government recognises that, there is an urgent need for quicker, bolder action if we are to end the national housing emergency.'
