27-05-2025
Herald endorsement: Miami City Commission District 4 special election
A special election to fill the District 4 seat left vacant after the death of Miami Commissioner Manolo Reyes has become a heated battle for the control of the majority of votes on the City Commission. The race has sparked a flurry of accusations between the candidates.
On June 3, voters will choose between Jose F. Regalado, a former assistant building director in the city with a family name well known in politics, and Ralph 'Rafael' Rosado, an urban planner and former city manager of North Bay Village who unsuccessfully ran against the late Reyes in 2017.
The winner, who will serve until 2027, may become the swing vote on high-stakes proposals before the November elections — among them, whether to move city elections to even-numbered years and whether to impose lifetime term limits on commissioners and the mayor.
Our choice is Regalado. He was Reyes' chief policy adviser from 2017 to 2019. He said he was asked to run by Reyes' widow.
Continuity has value, and upholding Reyes' legacy should be a key consideration in this contest. Reyes, who died in April at 80, was a calm, principled voice for transparency, strong constituent service and ethical government. Regalado pledged to keep Reyes' city commission staff. In a city often rocked by political instability, consistency matters.
Regalado comes from a well-known Cuban-American political family — his father, Tomás, is a former Miami mayor and the current county property appraiser. His sister, Raquel, is a Miami-Dade commissioner and his campaign manager. He's a lifelong resident of the district. He said he understands how to make city services work in District 4, a working-class area with a large elderly population. He named public safety and flood prevention as top issues; he was co-chair of the city's Sea Level Rise Committee.
'I originally started working in the city as a civil servant that understood politics, and now I'm running for for this seat hopefully to be an elected official that understands civil service,' he told the Editorial Board.
Regalado, who resigned to run, emphasized neighborhood-focused solutions: improving Miami police coverage and handling flooding and storm drainage in neighborhoods like Flagami. He said flood calculations need to be updated in the city, and that he would push for 'legislation to update and ensure that the infrastructure that is built today can last for tomorrow.'
This is Regalado's first race. He acknowledges he has room to grow; we agree he needs to catch up. His answers during the Board interview were sometimes vague — he wasn't sure if he would back an idea to expand the number of seats on the five-member commission. But we think he would bring knowledge of the city and, importantly, the right temperament to sometimes dysfunctional commission meetings.
Rosado, a longtime resident of Miami and former city manager of North Bay Village, was the more polished of the two. He said code enforcement needs to be improved, a jab at his opponent, and that the building department 'is failing the residents.'
Rosado has been linked to controversial Commissioner Joe Carollo, though Rosado downplayed that support in his interview. Carollo's PAC, Miami First, has been funding anti-Regalado mailers and ads.
Rosado also dismissed a video posted by the Political Cortadito blog that showed Carollo seemingly directing a campaign video for Rosado at a park, saying Carollo 'stopped by' and was not directing the video.
Rosado resigned as North Bay Village city manager in 2024. He blamed politics for his resignation, but the village commission discussed terminating his employment in April of 2024. Rosado resigned in August.
Regalado no doubt benefits greatly from his last name. That will not be enough if he wins; he will need to increase his engagement on important issues, such as whether to expand the number of seats on the city commission.
The race for District 4 isn't just about replacing a commissioner; it's about protecting the kind of leadership Reyes brought to the district.
In the special election to fill the Miami City Commission District 4 seat, the Miami Herald Editorial Board endorses JOSE F. REGALADO.
