2 days ago
HC prods govt to nix FYJC quotas in minority colleges
Mumbai: Bombay HC Wednesday asked the state to consider removing a clause in its May 6 GR that introduced social quotas (such as SC/ST/OBC/SEBC) for FYJC admissions in minority institutions.
"It can be a bona fide mistake. Issue a corrigendum. If not, we are here," said Justices Makarand Karnik & Nitin Borkar, while hearing two petitions challenging the clause. The institutions learnt about it only after their seat matrices were put up on the admission portal. The colleges argued that social quotas do not apply to minority institutions in terms of Article 15 (5) of the Constitution.
As govt pleader Neha Bhide said the GR was meant to bring uniformity in FYJC admissions, Justice Karnik questioned: "Why do you bring in minority institutions?" The judges said a similar GR was withdrawn in 2019.
Bhide said the "clause can be removed". The judges asked her to take instructions and inform them Thursday. "Every time you do not need orders from us. You can do it yourself," said Justice Karnik.
Govt pleader Neha Bhide informed Bombay high court on Wednesday that withdrawing the May 6 government resolution (GR) on FYJC admissions was not possible, but "clause 11 can be removed". Clause 11 of the GR mentions that social and parallel reservations will apply to vacancies after filling minority seats in minority institutions.
To this, Justice Makarand Karnik said: "Solve the problem." And Bhide replied: "I will come with a solution.
"
Justices Karnik and Nitin Borkar asked Bhide to di-scuss with the state advocate general and senior officials.
The judges were hearing two petitions challenging the contentious clause. The first petition was filed by Solapur's Shri APD Jain Pathashala, a trust that runs Walchand College of Arts and Science and Hirachand Nemchand College of Commerce.
The second was a joint petition by south Mumbai colleges, including St Xavier's, KC, HR, Jai Hind and Maharashtra College, along with the Maharashtra Association of Minority Educational Institutions.
On being informed by advocate S C Naidu, for the Solapur colleges, that finalisation of merit list is scheduled for Wednesday, the judges on Tuesday had directed that it will be subject to the outcome of the petitions.
Senior advocate Milind Sathe, for the Mumbai colleges, argued that social reservations do not apply to minority institutions.
About the GR, Bhide said: "For the first time, FYJC admissions are taken up online for the entire state."
The petitioners said their right under Article 30 to establish and administer educational institutions has been reiterated in SC and HC judgments "which have held that minority educational institutions are not subject to any social reservations".
