02-06-2025
Erin Patterson speaks at murder trial
Samantha Donovan: In a development that surprised some observers, accused triple murderer Erin Paterson has been called to give evidence at her Supreme Court trial in regional Victoria. Ms Patterson is accused of deliberately poisoning her husband's parents, uncle and aunt with a meal of beef wellington containing death cap mushrooms. Only one of her lunch guests survived. Ms Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three charges of murder and one of attempted murder. Our reporter Kathleen O'Connor is at the trial in Morwell. Kathleen, the defence I understand began by asking Ms Patterson a series of questions about her relationship with her now estranged husband Simon Paterson. What did the court hear?
Kathleen O'Connor: Yeah, that's right, Sam. Aside from the text messages read to the court and the police interview played to the jury last week, this is the first time we're actually hearing from Erin Patterson. She began by telling the jury about the relationship between her and her estranged husband Simon and the relationship he has with his children. She went into how they first met at the council in the Melbourne area and how they travelled a lot, but after a while she wanted to lay down roots somewhere and start a family. Erin Patterson says when her and Simon first met she was originally an atheist and after going to church with Simon and his family she converted to Christianity. Later on in their relationship she described her dealings with Simon Paterson as functional. Erin Patterson telling the court when the pair separated a number of times throughout their relationship she said even though our relationship was struggling it was really important for both of us to cooperate because our child was the priority. Erin Patterson described to the jury that if her and Simon had any problems at all it was that they couldn't communicate well and when they disagreed with something they both just felt hurt and they didn't know how to resolve it.
Samantha Donovan: Her barrister then asked Erin Patterson about her relationship with her in-laws Don and Gail Patterson. What did she tell the jury?
Kathleen O'Connor: Erin Patterson talked about how she had a good relationship with Simon's parents in the beginning and she used to visit them regularly. She told the court she was often invited for a meal with them and her husband Simon Paterson and sometimes he wasn't even there. She explained to the jury that her mother-in-law Gail Paterson was really supportive, gentle and patient with her particularly after the birth of her first child. She was very close with his family often coming to visit the couple when they were living in Perth temporarily. Ian Wilkinson's son and Simon's cousin even walking her down the aisle at her wedding. However in 2023, the same year when the lunch took place, she told the court I'd felt for some months that her relationship between the wider Patterson family was more distant particularly with Simon's parents Don and Gail. She became concerned that Simon didn't want her to be involved in the family as much and she said she wasn't invited to as many things.
Samantha Donovan: And Kathleen, what was Erin Patterson's attitude, her demeanour like when she was giving evidence today?
Kathleen O'Connor: She became quite emotional Sam at times particularly talking about the birth of her child when responding to her defence lawyer Colin Mandy SC's questions. Her eyes were locked on him the entire time. She only paused a few times when questions were being asked just really taking her time to answer each question.
Samantha Donovan: And the lead investigator from the Victoria Police Homicide Squad also wrapped up his evidence today. What did he tell the court that was of significance this morning?
Kathleen O'Connor: Detective leading senior constable from the Homicide Squad Stephen Eppingstall was questioned for most of the morning as the prosecution's final witness. This morning defence lawyer Colin Mandy SC questioned him about Erin Paterson's use of mobile phones after the prosecution alleges a number of factory resets were made on that phone that was seized by police on the day that they searched her property in Leongatha. And that phone and SIM card she actually gave to police to help with their investigation wasn't the main phone that Ms Patterson used to regularly contact her family and friends. Barrister Colin Mandy SC presented a diagram to the jury to demonstrate that it was regular practice that the SIM cards she used were shifted into several different phones in the years before the lunch. And the factory reset may not have been done intentionally. The prosecution has formally closed its case now Sam.
Samantha Donovan: Our reporter Kathleen O'Connor at the Erin Patterson trial in Morwell in Victoria.
