09-03-2025
State budget a primary concern at Third House meeting
GOSHEN — Elkhart County residents say they're concerned about proposed tax cuts by the Indiana State Legislature. They brought those questions to the Goshen Chamber of Commerce's Third House meeting on Friday.
Local legislators Sen. Blake Doriot, R-Goshen, State Rep. Doug Miller, R-Elkhart, Rep. Joanna King, R-Middlebury, and State Rep. Dave Abbott, R-Rome City, attended one of the chamber's three scheduled Third House meetings this legislative session.
Third House meetings are an opportunity for community members to visit with elected officials representing them at the Indiana General Assembly, learn which bills legislators are working on, and discuss concerns or interests with leaders.
Residents who attended Friday's Third House were most concerned about tax cuts and services and supports that could be lost in the shuffle.
'We as citizens of the United States have to step up and figure out how we can be more responsible and expect less from the government and expect more from ourselves,' Miller said.
Goshen High School student Isaac Moore called the situation with the Department of Education an 'inevitable dismantling,' and asked about the state's plan to ensure schools like his are adequately funded for diverse learning needs currently supported by Title I.
'I don't know what's going to happen out in D.C. I have no control over what happens in D.C. What I do hope is that locally we have a little bit more autonomy to make decisions that are best for our kids,' King said. 'I don't know that many decisions that are made at the federal level, I don't know that those decisions can't be made — and be made better — here at the state level.'
King said she hopes that if the Department of Education is shuttered, the money will still be sent to the states to figure out what to do with it like they do in other areas with federal funding such as medicaid.
Moore asked if they had a plan for if the money wasn't sent to the states. King said when she was a school board member at Middlebury Community Schools, it wasn't a lot.
Both Goshen Community Schools Superintendent Jim DuBois and Concord Community Schools Superintendent Dan Funston were in attendance at the meeting.
'It is significant for Goshen,' DuBois said, and Funston said it was 4% of Concord's budget.
In addition, Funston shared his district's budget, explaining that 114% of Concord's operating budget funded by property taxes goes to property casualty insurance, transportation and utilities. He said since 2020, property casualty insurance premiums have increased 22%, transportation costs are up 64% — in large part because the cost of a bus has doubled — and utility costs have gone up 32%.
Former educator Tom Holtzinger said he's concerned about Medicaid funding.
'I feel like we're balancing the budget on the backs of the poor again,' he said.
Doriot explained that Medicaid is the fastest growing portion of the state's budget.
'I believe it may be pushing 18% if this keeps on, very quickly, and there's only one place we have big enough to get that money and that's the schools,' Doriot said. 'The schools are 50%, higher ed's another 10 to 12%, and we have to rein it in and get it back to where it is.
'We've been looking at waste and all that but that peak drive from COVID … COVID's over and people are able to get back out and there are some very able-bodied that have figured out a way to say on it and we've got to work through that and I'm sorry but there are going to be cuts on it. We can't increase without a massive tax increase and very few people in this room like those words—tax increase— we're going to do our best, but it's going to get streamlined.'
Aaron Stickel accused legislators of 'streamlining at the cost of people's health care.'
'You're proposing to cut 250,000 people in Indiana alone,' he said.
King said during COVID, people weren't denied Medicaid and since then, those people have continued to use it.
'We have people that desperately need it and I want to make sure that we have the funds to help those that do need that help,' King said. 'One of the things that we're going to have to do is go back to the drawing board and say 'What are the guardrails to make sure that the people that are getting this service are meeting so that we can have people that are able-bodied, that could be working, that should be working, that are using this system, gaming this system, are not doing that anymore?''
King said since 2020, Medicaid has almost doubled.
'It's about responsible governance,' King said. 'It's going to be painful for some people, but I would argue that the people that it's probably going to be painful for are those that have been gaming the system.
'I'm all ears,' she continued. 'If you have any ideas on how to solve this challenge, I am all ears. We are right in that process, but we have to figure out a way to get to a healthier place.'
One commenter proposed that people aren't able to go back to work and earn a wage that would allow them to leave Medicaid and asked what legislators could do ensure people could make enough money to finance their own health insurance.
Abbott said every business owner he's spoken to said they couldn't find employees to fill positions. Caleb Miller, president of Viewrail, said that's not the case for him. All 375 of his employees make at minimum $25 per hour and Miller said his company also does workforce training.
'I think a lot of this does come down to an ability to offer living wages,' Miller said. 'People aren't going to come back if they aren't going to get a living wage.'
Stickel asked why legislators are talking about tax cuts at all if Medicaid and education are underfunded.
'We all want less taxes personally, but it's your responsibility to make the hard decisions,' Stickel said. 'Why are we talking about tax cuts if we're talking about this critical infrastructure — our kids, people that need health care — those things are underfunded.'
Abbott noted that it's not about income taxes — which are lowering slightly — but property taxes and it's because residential property taxes pick up such a high amount of that cost.
'People are getting priced out of their homes,' he said. 'The cuts, at least as far as property taxes, are trying to balance it so it's fair. You have businesses, you have caps, you have TIF districts, a lot of those things play into how we generate our revenue for the local communities. We're not targeting the state so much as we're targeting the local.'
Miller reminded those in attendance that the federal deficit is $37 trillion.
'We're all in the same ship and that ship is causing a myriad of problems for states and local government,' he said. 'We have now a very active leadership that's doing a lot of things and we're all very, very nervous about that. And for us at the state level that's been a trickle-down effect. We are sandwiched between the federal government and what they're pushing down the pipeline and have traditionally and programs they've put in place.'
Miller said the extra COVID money from the federal government allowed for many opportunities and when the money was gone, the state legislature has been expected to maintain those opportunities without it.
'It's straining us and it's strangling states,' he said. 'Our budget is hugely impacted and it affects every Hoosier.'
Clerk-Treasurer Richard Aguirre argued that the state proposing local tax cuts was no different than the federal government cutting state funding.
'As much as I've heard legislators for decades when I was a reporter complain about the federal government taking away the state's ability to do things, I'd ask you to continue to consider that issue and when you're doing things like requiring local police to enforce immigration law,' he said. 'When you're limiting our income, the state is not cutting its state taxes and then having to deal with that impact.
'I've told all of you: the greatest gift you could give local government is just leave us alone for one session.'
HEART OF THE HOOSIER
King also presented Vince Turner with the Heart of the Hoosier Award, saying she'd been waiting to present it since a teen at the Statehouse told her that he wanted to be 'just like Vince Turner.'
'I realized Vince has impacted many lives,' she said.
The award comes from King's office and is given to people in the community she represents who have impacted the area.
