18-04-2025
Lawsuit claims Marion County Schools lack of safe environment led to student's sexual assault
FAIRMONT — The Marion County Board of Education faces allegations it failed to provide a safe environment on a Marion County school bus after an elementary school student was sexually assaulted by two older students.
The parent of the student filed a lawsuit against the Board of Education last year in May. A motion hearing between the Board and the plaintiff is scheduled for next week. The lawsuit alleges the assault took place in 2023 and states the bus driver did not intervene or take any action to stop the assault. It also states students of the victim's age are required to sit in the first three rows, however, the bus driver did not direct the child to do so. The Marion County Sheriff's Department opened an investigation into the incident.
'When Plaintiff and her partner contacted the Principal of Blackshere Elementary to inquire about the results of the investigation, they were simply told that minor [redacted] 'wouldn't have to see them [the students who attacked him] anymore,' the civil complaint states.
The complaint goes on to state the plaintiff and her partner were prohibited from knowing the names of the two perpetrators, and the school didn't divulge any information as to whether they were disciplined after the assault.
The lawsuit states the Board of Education owed the student a duty of care to keep him free of harassment, assault and intimidation while on a school bus. The suit accuses the board of failing to properly train its staff to appropriately supervise the students of Marion County Schools. The complaint states the child has suffered permanent psychological injury as a result of the attack. The plaintiff seeks compensatory damages from the board.
The Board of Education filed its answer to the complaint in August of last year. The Board's answer states the plaintiff's complaint didn't properly make a claim upon which relief can be granted. The board denied the bus driver was aware of the conduct and denied the plaintiff's characterization of the incident. However, the board admits that something did occur. The board also responded to the claims the plaintiff made about not receiving information from the school about the attackers.
'Defendant Board of Education admits it did not provide confidential student information to the parents as alleged in paragraph 26 of the complaint,' the document states. 'But the Board of Education has fully cooperated with law enforcement.'
The board also argued that the damages the child suffered, if any, were caused by persons other than the Board of Education. It denied all other allegations and argued it acted at all times in good faith and on the basis of reasonable and legitimate factors. The board also claimed immunity against claims of any alleged failure to enact a policy or rule under the West Virginia Governmental Tort Claims and Insurance Reform Act. The attorney for the board also argued that the plaintiff was not entitled to an award of damages because the alleged damages are speculative.
'[The minor's] alleged damages, if any, were caused by superseding, intervening causes over which Defendant Board of Education had no control and for which Defendant Board of Education cannot be liable,' the Board stated in its response to the filing.
The Board of Education is represented by Attorney Susan Deniker of Steptoe & Johnson, which has an office in Bridgeport. The plaintiff is represented by Charleston-based Attorney Robert Wagner of Warner Law Offices. School Superintendent Donna Heston said the bus driver is deceased, but declined to comment if the board took any action regarding her employment before she passed. Heston said Marion County Schools cannot comment on pending litigation.
Wagner did not return a phone call by press time.
The board is asking for the lawsuit to be dismissed, while the plaintiff demands trial by jury.
EDITOR'S NOTE: The name of the plaintiff has been withheld in order to protect the victim.
