Latest news with #YellowFlagLaw
Yahoo
07-03-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Red flag law citizen initiative officially valid to appear on November ballot
A portrait of Margaret Chase Smith in the background as proponents of gun safety rally in the halls of the State House on Jan. 3, 2024. (Jim Neuger/Maine Morning Star) A citizen-led initiative to strengthen Maine's gun safety laws is headed to the ballot this November, after the Secretary of State's Office confirmed Friday that enough valid signatures had been collected. Maine could join 21 other states that have passed red flag laws, officially called an Extreme Risk Protection Order, which would make it easier to temporarily confiscate one's guns if they are deemed to be a threat by law enforcement or their family members. Both gun safety advocates and owners in Maine have emphasized the need for such a law, according to Nacole Palmer, executive director of the Maine Gun Safety Coalition, which spearheaded the initiative. Red flag laws have been proven effective in reducing incidents of suicide – the leading cause of firearm death in Maine, especially among men. Maine is currently the only state to have a yellow flag law, a weaker provision that allows law enforcement officials to take away guns from someone considered a safety risk to themselves or others after an evaluation from a mental health professional. The red flag law, if passed, would authorize family members to directly petition courts to take someone's guns away if they pose a threat. After a failed legislative attempt to pass the red flag law last year, the coalition collected more than 80,000 signatures in about two months in support of passing the initiative. Of those, 74,888 were found to be valid, according to a release by the Secretary of State's Office, still exceeding the number required for a valid petition (which is 67,822, or 10% of the total votes cast in the most recent gubernatorial election). The initiative will now go to the Legislature for consideration, and lawmakers can choose to enact the bill as written or refer it to a statewide vote in November 2025. In her State of the Budget address in late January, Gov. Janet Mills defended Maine's yellow flag law, which she helped craft in 2020. Use of the yellow flag law has increased since the deadly Lewiston mass shooting in 2023, although some law enforcement agencies rely on it more than others. The independent commission tasked with investigating the events that led to the shooting determined, among other things, that the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office had sufficient cause to take the shooter into protective custody under Maine's Yellow Flag Law, but failed to do so. In a press statement, Palmer said that with the Secretary of State's validation, the coalition can start its campaign. 'This was the final hurdle in a process that began in the aftermath of Lewiston, as people across Maine and family members of those lost asked how we prevent this from ever happening again,' she said. 'This is a proven, commonsense tool for families that's been effective in many other states in saving countless lives and preventing tragedies like Lewiston.' Palmer said the gun lobby has already started 'spreading misinformation and scare tactics' about red flag laws, which have been upheld as constitutional and proven effective in states where they've passed. 'Maine is a strong gun rights state, where many of us hunt and shoot recreationally, but we're also a state that believes in gun responsibility,' said David McCrea, former state legislator and retired educator from Fort Fairfield and a volunteer for the Maine Gun Safety Coalition in a statement. 'As a gun owner myself, I'm proud to support this commonsense measure that will give family members tools to get help for their loved ones when they're in need, before a crisis becomes a preventable tragedy.' SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Yahoo
13-02-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Use of Maine's yellow flag law continues to be consistently high
Guns are shown at Caso's Gun-A-Rama in Jersey City, New Jersey, which has been open since 1967. (Photo by Aristide Economopoulos/NJ Monitor) Maine's yellow flag law, which has been under scrutiny since the mass shooting in Lewiston, has already been used more times this year by law enforcement agencies across the state than in the first three years after it became law in 2020. In the past six weeks, the law has been used 58 times by police departments and sheriff's offices to confiscate weapons from people with a mental health diagnosis who pose risks to their own and others' safety. That's more than the number of times law enforcement used the same law in 2020, 2021 and 2022 combined. The use of the law skyrocketed after the deadly shooting in October 2023, and remains consistently high, although some agencies rely on it more than others, according to data from the Maine Attorney General's Office. Overall, the law, formally known as a weapons restriction order, has been used 689 times to confiscate weapons. In the vast majority of cases, people who had guns taken away had threatened to kill themselves, often also threatening family members, partners and in some cases, coworkers or the general public, according to the state data. Most were also described as having mental health challenges, with a small number explicitly described as paranoid, schizophrenic or experiencing hallucinations. About a dozen people shot themselves before police intervened, and a dozen more hurt themselves using other weapons. On Wednesday, Daniel Wathen, the former chief justice of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court who headed the independent commission that studied the Lewiston shooting, presented some of the investigation's key findings to members of the Legislature's Criminal Justice and Public Safety Committee. Among the conclusions, the commission determined that the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office had sufficient cause to take shooter Robert Card II into protective custody under Maine's Yellow Flag Law and to begin the process to confiscate any firearms in his possession. The yellow flag law, which was crafted by Governor Janet Mills and the Sportsman's Alliance of Maine, was passed in 2020, making Maine the only state with such a law. It allows law enforcement to temporarily confiscate firearms from people who are determined to be a danger to themselves or others. But it's been described as cumbersome by law enforcement, according to the commission report, because police have to take the person into protective custody, bring them to a facility where their mental health can be evaluated and then seek a court order to temporarily take firearms away. Even though the law has been in effect since 2020, it had been used just over 80 times prior to the shooting. Since then, more than 90 law enforcement agencies have utilized it more than 600 times. Maine State Police have used it most frequently, with 61 orders since 2020. The Sanford Police Department had the second highest number of uses. Sgt. Everett Allen said that might be because the department considers it a useful tool and has a mental health expert on staff. Androscoggin County Sheriff's Office and the Lewiston Police Department have each used the law 25 and 24 times, respectively. 'We have a mental health unit here and the ability to have that and have a clinician working with officers to help, I know that is helpful for us,' Allen said. 'Every time we've used [the yellow flag law], it's been helpful because we're removing weapons from a house or someplace that would prevent a serious likelihood of harm from someone.' The Maine Legislature passed several gun safety laws in the wake of the shooting last year, including a bill from the governor that, among other things, modified the yellow flag law by allowing police to get protective custody warrants to use at their discretion to take dangerous people into custody and remove their weapons. That law took effect in August. Another bill, which became law without the governor's signature, established a 72-hour waiting period for certain gun purchases. On Thursday a federal judge paused that rule in response to a lawsuit from local gun stores and owners that argued it was unconstitutional. In a statement in response to the ruling, Nacole Palmer, executive director for the Maine Gun Safety Coalition, argued the law would help prevent suicides in Maine. 'Three-day waiting period laws provide a brief cooling off period so someone in crisis who may be buying a gun to take their own life has time to reconsider and get help,' Palmer said. 'These laws have been upheld as constitutional in countless other states where they exist, some up to 10 days. Once again, Maine is an outlier and this ruling is an exception to established law, and it's an exception that will cost lives and cause Maine families heartbreak and loss.' The coalition is already mounting a campaign to put a stronger gun law on the ballot. Last month, the groups delivered more than 80,000 signatures to put a red flag law, which allows family members to directly appeal to courts to take firearms away from people considered to be a danger to themselves or others, on the ballot this November. During her state of the budget address, Mills criticized the initiative, citing the frequent use of the yellow flag law. Mills addressed the criticisms of the current law, including the requirement of a mental health assessment to take one's guns away. 'This law is not a burden. These are folks who are in crisis and who, thanks to the mental health assessment, are also now being connected — perhaps for the first time — to Maine's mental health system,' Mills said. 'I also don't believe a private citizen should have to navigate what can be a complex and confusing court procedure by themselves, especially in the middle of already difficult circumstances. It is the government's responsibility, not that of a private citizen, to protect the public from gun violence.' SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
