Latest news with #policeState
Telegraph
21-05-2025
- Politics
- Telegraph
Starmer defends jailing of mother over Southport tweet
Sir Keir Starmer has defended Lucy Connolly's jail sentence amid fears Britain is becoming a 'police state' under his leadership. The Prime Minister said he would 'always support' the UK's courts when asked if he thought the decision to put the young mother behind bars was an 'efficient or fair use' of prison. Connolly, a former childminder and the wife of a Tory councillor, was jailed in October for a tweet about last year's Southport attacks, which saw three young girls killed at a Taylor Swift-themed holiday club. An attempt to get her 31-month sentence reduced was thrown out by three Court of Appeal judges on Tuesday morning, meaning she will not be released before August. Her treatment has provoked a backlash from senior political figures including Boris Johnson, the former prime minister, and Kemi Badenoch, the Tory leader. Rupert Lowe, the former Reform UK MP, challenged Sir Keir on Connolly's sentence at Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday. He said: 'Does the Prime Minister agree that imprisoning Lucy Connolly, a young mother with a 12-year-old daughter for one foolish social media post, soon deleted, is clearly not an efficient or fair use of prison?' Sir Keir responded: 'Sentencing is a matter for our courts, and I celebrate the fact that we have independent courts in this country. 'I am strongly in favour of free speech, we've had free speech in this country for a very long time and we protect it fiercely. 'But I am equally against incitement to violence against other people. I will always support the action taken by our police and courts to keep our streets and people safe.' Mr Lowe, who has been a vocal campaigner for Connolly's release, has tabled a motion in Parliament raising concerns about her imprisonment and calling for an urgent review of the UK's sentencing practices. It was initially backed by Jeremy Corbyn, the former Labour leader, who was re-elected as an independent MP last year after his expulsion from the party. However, The Telegraph understands this was an 'administrative error', and his name has since been removed. The motion has also been signed by Sir Gavin Williamson, the former Tory Cabinet minister. It states that the House of Commons 'notes with concern the continued imprisonment of Lucy Connolly, a young mother, for a non-violent offence' and argues that 'prison should be reserved for those who pose a serious risk to the public'. It also says the House 'recognises that the UK's prison system is facing unprecedented overcrowding' and 'further notes that the use of custodial sentences for non-violent offenders, particularly primary carers, undermines family stability, disproportionately affects children, and is often counterproductive in reducing reoffending'. It concludes by calling on the Government to 'urgently review sentencing practices, expand the use of community-based alternatives, and ensure that limited prison space is prioritised for dangerous and violent offenders, not young mothers like Lucy Connolly'. It comes after Mr Johnson warned Britain is becoming a ' police state ' under Sir Keir's leadership following the ruling on Connolly's appeal. The former prime minister told the Daily Mail: 'Starmer's Britain is losing its reputation for free speech and turning into a police state, where we must all learn to fear the knock on the door simply for something we say. 'The UK police are now making over 10,000 arrests every year for online comment, more than the police in Russia itself, and this judgment is yet another propaganda gift for Vladimir Putin.' Earlier, Ray Connolly said he was 'heartbroken' that his wife's appeal was not upheld, adding: 'I think the system wanted to make an example of Lucy so other people would be scared to say things about immigration.' Connolly's lawyers had argued that she had not fully understood what she was pleading guilty to, and also that the original judge had failed to give enough weight to various mitigating factors including the welfare of her 12-year-old daughter.
Daily Mail
20-05-2025
- Politics
- Daily Mail
Boris Johnson warns that Starmer's Britain is 'turning into a police state' after mother who tweeted about Southport murders fails in her bid to have lengthy jail term slashed
Britain is becoming a police state under Labour, Boris Johnson warned last night. He spoke as a sentencing row erupted after a mother locked up for a tweet after the Southport murders failed in a bid to reduce her lengthy jail term. Lucy Connolly posted a vile message about migrants – but supporters point out that criminals found guilty of far more serious offences have been handed substantially shorter sentences. And former prime minister Mr Johnson warned that the country is 'losing its reputation for free speech' as a growing number of online rants draw the attention of police. Connolly, 42, had asked the Court of Appeal to free her early from a 31-month sentence for inciting racial hatred, imposed after she posted a tweet urging people to 'set fire to the hotels' on the day of the triple murder last summer. She posted it at a time of swirling misinformation online, including a claim that the knifeman who killed three girls was a small boat migrant – a false claim that would lead to weeks of race riots. Connolly's 'heartbroken' husband, Northampton Tory councillor Ray, insisted his wife was 'a good person... not a far-Right thug' as judges yesterday dismissed her appeal against her jail term. He condemned the system as 'two-tier justice' and said it was 'not the British way'. Mr Johnson blasted the 'crazy and inhuman judgment', warning: 'Starmer's Britain is losing its reputation for free speech and turning into a police state, where we must all learn to fear the knock on the door simply for something we say. 'The UK police are now making over 10,000 arrests every year for online comment, more than the police in Russia itself, and this judgment is yet another propaganda gift for Vladimir Putin.' Mother-of-one Connolly is currently at HMP Drake Hall, Staffordshire, for her post on X, formerly Twitter, which read: 'Mass deportation now, set fire to all the f****** hotels full of the b******* for all I that makes me racist so be it.' She is unlikely to be released until August. Her imprisonment led to protests by campaigners carrying placards declaring 'police our streets, not our tweets'. Supporters said her sickening tweet – posted hours after Cardiff-born killer Axel Rudakubana murdered three girls at a dance class on July 29 – was a 'stupid mistake' but compared her 'rotting in jail' with many violent thugs handed lighter prison terms. Connolly claimed she had no idea what she was admitting to when she pleaded guilty last October, an argument three senior judges found was unlikely. Last night Tory justice spokesman Robert Jenrick said: 'In recent months shoplifters with hundreds of prior convictions have avoided prison. 'A domestic abuser with 52 prior offences got off with a suspended sentence, as did a paedophile with 110,000 indecent images of children. Connolly's 'heartbroken' husband, Northampton Tory councillor Ray, pictured, insisted his wife was 'a good person... not a far-Right thug' as judges yesterday dismissed her appeal against her jail term. 'And yet Lucy Connolly has received a 31-month prison sentence for an appalling – albeit hastily deleted – message on social media. 'How on earth can you spend longer in prison for a tweet than violent crime? 'This crazy disparity will only fuel perception that we have a two-tier justice system where the law is enforced selectively.' Among the vile thugs who have received shorter sentences than Connolly was actual rioter Haris Ghaffar, who was given 20 months for the storming of a Birmingham pub. Speaking to The Telegraph yesterday, Connolly said from HMP Drake Hall: 'Shame on them. 'Those three judges that were sitting there in court should be ashamed of themselves, they are cruel.' After yesterday's ruling, Mr Connolly said: 'My wife Lucy is a good person and not a racist. Lucy got more time in jail for one tweet than some paedophiles and domestic abusers get. My wife has paid a very high price for making a mistake and today the court has shown no mercy'. He added: 'The 284 days of separation have been very hard, particularly on our 12-year-old girl. Lucy posted one nasty tweet when she was upset and angry about three little girls who were brutally murdered in Southport. 'She realised the tweet was wrong and deleted it within four hours. That did not mean Lucy was a 'far-Right thug' as Prime Minister Keir Starmer claimed. 'As a childminder, she took care of small children of African and Asian heritage; they loved Lucy as she loved them.' Mr Connolly said the system 'wanted to make an example of Lucy so others would be scared to say things about immigration'. Toby Young, the general secretary of the Free Speech Union, said: 'How can it be right for Lucy to have been condemned to spend more than two-and-a-half years in jail for a single tweet when members of grooming gangs who plead guilty to the sexual exploitation of children get lower sentences? 'Lucy should be at home with her daughter and husband, not rotting in jail.' The Free Speech Union said: 'No one disputes the tweet was offensive but the sentence of more than two-and-a-half years was plainly disproportionate.' Rupert Lowe, the former Reform MP now sitting as an Independent, called it 'morally repugnant to separate a mother from her children over one stupid social media post'. Writing to Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood, he said: 'Who is being served by having Lucy Connolly in prison? It is definitely not the public, who I believe would feel far safer if a violent criminal was incarcerated in that cell.' Asked by broadcasters if free speech was dead in the UK, Sir Keir said: 'Firstly, I'm strongly in favour of free speech… and we protect it fiercely. 'I'm equally, though, against incitement to violence. That has long been an offence in our country, and rightly so.' The Southport atrocity sparked nationwide rioting. The tweet by Connolly was viewed 310,000 times in three-and-a-half hours before she deleted it. She later admitted at Birmingham Crown Court to distributing material with the intention of stirring up racial hatred. Last week she appealed against the sentence, telling the Court of Appeal in London she had no idea the full extent of what she was admitting. But yesterday Lord Justice Holroyde, sitting with Mr Justice Goss and Mr Justice Sheldon, said she 'had willingly pleaded guilty'. They found Connolly was an 'intelligent and articulate' woman… 'well aware of what she was admitting'.
