Latest news with #unemploymenttax
The Guardian
5 days ago
- Business
- The Guardian
US supreme court backs Catholic charity group in unemployment taxes case
The US supreme court has sided with a Catholic charity group in a case that tested whether the charity and other religious groups should be exempt from unemployment taxes. In Catholic Charities Bureau Inc v Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission, Catholic Charities argued it should not be required to pay unemployment taxes because it is a religious organization. The unanimous ruling from the nine-member bench on Thursday overturned a lower court's decision that had rejected the tax exemption bid by the Catholic Charities Bureau - a non-profit corporation operating as the social ministry arm of the Catholic diocese in the city of Superior - and four entities that the bureau oversees. Wisconsin, like other states, requires employers to pay into its unemployment system, though religious organizations are exempt. But, a state commission decided and the state supreme court then confirmed, Catholic Charities was not doing 'distinctively religious' activities; it helps people with housing and job training, though its mission is religious. Catholic Charities has argued this violates the first amendment's freedom of religion protections. The organization should not need to engage in specific practices, like worship or proselytizing, to meet the standard for an exemption, it said. The justices, on the whole, had seemed to side with this idea during oral arguments at the end of March. 'I thought it was pretty fundamental that we don't treat some religions better than other religions. And we certainly don't do it based on the content of the religious doctrine that those religions preach,' liberal justice Elena Kagan said during the March arguments. The case served as another test of the current court's views on religion in governance. The court, led by conservatives, has been weighing in on test cases that explore the boundaries of the separation of church and state. A recent ruling on the potential first religious charter school in the country concluded the school could not open as a public charter because the decision was tied, four votes to four, with Justice Amy Coney Barrett recusing herself because of a connection to the case.
The Independent
5 days ago
- Business
- The Independent
Supreme Court sides with Catholic Charities in religious-rights case over unemployment taxes
The Supreme Court decided Thursday that a Catholic charity doesn't have to pay Wisconsin unemployment taxes, one of a set of religious-rights cases the justices are considering this term. The ruling comes in a case filed by the Catholic Charities Bureau, which says the state violated the First Amendment's religious freedom guarantee when it required the organization to pay the tax while exempting other faith groups. Wisconsin argues the organization has paid the tax for over 50 years and doesn't qualify for an exemption because its day-to-day work doesn't involve religious teachings. Much of the groups' funding is from public money, and neither employees nor people receiving services have to belong to any faith, according to court papers. Catholic Charities, though, says it qualifies because its disability services are motivated by religious beliefs and the state shouldn't be making determinations about what work qualifies as religious. It appealed to the Supreme Court after Wisconsin's highest court ruled against it. President Donald Trump 's administration weighed in on behalf of Catholic Charites. Wisconsin has said that a decision in favor of the charity could open the door to big employers like religiously affiliated hospitals pulling out of the state unemployment system as well.
