Singapore's HDB corridors compared with South China Sea row? US embassy slammed over video
The 90-second clip, posted by US Chargé d'Affaires Casey Mace and reshared across the official embassy channels on Monday, opens with a scene familiar to many Singaporeans – the façade of a Housing and Development Board (HDB) flat – and a narrator intoning: 'Our homes are our sanctuaries. And when we live together, it's important to respect each other's space and our common space.'
Viewers are then asked to 'imagine coming home one day and to find this', as the screen flashes images of shared areas blocked by household clutter, alongside headlines about disputes over corridor hoarding. 'A neighbour has decided that the space in front of your door is theirs,' the narrator says, before asking: 'Does this remind you of anything else?'
The video then pivots to the South China Sea conflict, showing news headlines about Philippine and Vietnamese officials accusing China of aggression, military build-ups and harassment of fishermen. 'This happens right outside Singapore's doorstep, too,' the narrator says.
The video notes that in 2016, a UN tribunal ruled in favour of the Philippines in a case against Beijing's sweeping claims in the South China Sea, saying China's 'nine-dash line' had no legal basis. China has consistently rejected the ruling, stating that it has historic rights over the disputed waters.
The rest of the video draws out the HDB analogy, likening China's territorial claims and assertive actions in the disputed waterway to HDB residents refusing to remove their things from public areas even after town councils have ruled against them. The video ends with the narrator saying: 'It's important to remember: we all have to use this corridor. We have to live together peacefully.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
How Beijing and other South China Sea claimants can see eye to eye
Few disputes in Asia are as enduring – and as polarising – as those over the South China Sea . For more than a decade, two sharply opposed narratives have dominated. In one, Beijing is seen as using force, or the threat of force, to change the status quo, undermining peace and stability. In the other, China is portrayed as exercising restraint, acting within its rights and working to safeguard regional stability. These perspectives are not merely different; they are mutually exclusive. One side's defensive action is interpreted as aggressive by the other, reinforcing mistrust and escalation. Measures to enhance one party's security inevitably diminish the sense of security for others. This makes de-escalation difficult and drives the dispute beyond legal or territorial boundaries into the realm of identity, national pride and historical grievance. Without narrowing this gulf, a peaceful resolution remains remote. At its core, the divergence stems from conflicting national interests. Yet the roots run deeper, in the incomplete territorial arrangements left after the second world war. The rapid onset of the Cold War froze parts of the post-war settlement in ambiguity. Treaties such as the 1951 San Francisco Peace Treaty and 1952 Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty required Japan to renounce the Spratly and Paracel Islands but did not specify their new sovereign owner. Beijing maintains these territories are historically Chinese, before Japan's wartime seizure. Other claimants read the record differently. Some argue Japan's renunciation did not automatically transfer sovereignty to China, rendering the islands terra nullius – open to lawful occupation.
South China Morning Post
7 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Is Prabowo's big budget for Indonesia achievable or overly ambitious?
Indonesia 's President Prabowo Subianto has unveiled an ambitious draft budget for 2026 that seeks to boost growth and expand social spending while maintaining financial discipline, but economists caution the plan may be based on optimistic revenue projections and risks undercutting social safety nets. Advertisement On Friday, Prabowo announced a gross domestic product (GDP) growth target of 5.4 per cent under the draft budget. Total spending is projected to reach 3.79 quadrillion rupiah (US$233.92 billion), a 7.3 per cent rise from this year, while total revenues are targeted at 3.147 quadrillion rupiah (US$194.04 billion), a nearly 10 per cent increase from 2025. Prabowo's administration aims to cap next year's deficit at around US$39 billion, or 2.48 per cent of GDP – within the country's legal requirement for a deficit of under 3 per cent of GDP. 'We will continue to implement efficiency measures so that we can minimise this deficit as much as possible,' Prabowo told parliament on Friday, signalling that his austerity measures would be kept in place across ministries and other government institutions. 'And it is my hope that one day, whether in 2027 or 2028, I want to stand before this assembly, at this podium, and declare that we have succeeded in having a state budget with no deficit whatsoever.' Advertisement Prabowo's first budget as president reflects his campaign pledge to invest in long-term human development. His flagship free meals programme – aimed at curbing child stunting and malnutrition – will receive 335 trillion rupiah (US$20.6 billion), nearly five times more than this year's allocation. The initiative targets over 82 million children, toddlers and pregnant women.
South China Morning Post
8 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Philippines reports Chinese ship surge at Scarborough Shoal after ‘embarrassing' collision
The Philippine government has reported a marked increase in Chinese maritime activity near Scarborough Shoal, intensifying a stand-off over the disputed South China Sea atoll. Officials in Manila have characterised the build-up as an attempt by Beijing to reassert control after two Chinese ships collided last week during a chase involving a Philippine vessel. On Sunday, the National Maritime Council cited the Philippine Navy's latest assessment, reporting that as of Thursday, seven Chinese coastguard vessels and 13 maritime militia ships were deployed near Scarborough Shoal. The Philippines, by contrast, had a single ship in the area: the BRP Teresa Magbanua. The council did not provide figures for previous deployments but described the current numbers as a clear escalation. 'Maybe this is one of their ways to twist what happened because that was very embarrassing for them, and they want to project again that they're in control to cover up the issue,' said Alexander Lopez, a spokesman for the council. 03:09 Chinese ships collide during clash with Philippine coastguard in contested South China Sea Chinese ships collide during clash with Philippine coastguard in contested South China Sea Despite being heavily outnumbered, Lopez insisted that Manila would maintain its measured approach in the West Philippine Sea – the Philippine term for areas of the South China Sea within its exclusive economic zone – and would refrain from deploying navy warships to Scarborough Shoal to avoid further provocation.
