Icos Co Op Chairs to Travel to Brussels Amid Nitrates Frustration
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) revealed on Monday, July 7, that the European Commission has told Ireland it 'must demonstrate compliance' with the Habitats Directive when granting farmers a nitrates derogation.
There are 600 sites in Ireland designated under the Habitats Directive and the Birds Directive. Sites range in size from 1ha up to 76,000ha.
These sites are designated as either Special Conservation Areas (SAC) and or Special Protection Areas (SPA) and are generally referred to as Natura 2000 sites.
Under the Habitats Directive any plan or project 'likely to have a significant effect on a designated site or species' must be subject to Appropriate Assessment of its implications for the site.
The European Court of Justice has ruled that the 'grazing of cattle and or the application of fertilisers on the surface of land or below its surface' in the vicinity of Natura 2000 sites may be classified as a project.
ICOS has outlined its concern in a letter sent today (Friday, July 11) to Jessika Roswall, EU Commissioner for Environment, Water Resilience and a Competitive Circular Economy.
Addressing Commissioner Roswall on behalf of Irish dairy cooperatives and their farmer members, ICOS president Edward Carr stated:
'This is a very significant and unexpected departure that adds a new and potentially onerous layer of compliance to the nitrates derogation that was never envisaged when the Nitrates Directive and Habitats Directive came into force in Ireland in the early 1990s.
'Farmers and their cooperatives have embraced their responsibilities in terms of adopting environmental best practice.
"We have seen very positive outcomes with nitrate concentrations in Irish rivers declining significantly in 2024.
"This new development related to the Habitats Directive is deeply frustrating given the ongoing national movement to improve water quality led by farmers, dairy co-ops, the meat and tillage sectors, Teagasc and LAWPRO [Local Authority Waters Programme]," he added.
The Irish Government is currently preparing a response to the European Commission.
However, ICOS maintains that before any process is agreed to with the commission, the implications for farm families and the food industry need to be outlined.
ICOS has confirmed that a delegation of co-op chairpersons will travel to Brussels on July 15-16 to meet with Irish MEPs and the European Commission on the matter, including Commissioner Roswall's head of cabinet, Paulina Dejmek Hack.
Edward Carr commented: 'We will strongly impress on the European Commission our deep concerns that this development will have for business certainty at farm and processing level and for generational renewal in the sector.
'We will use the opportunity to reinforce to the commission the benefits of Ireland's unique grass-based system and the strong momentum building in Ireland on water quality and the verifiable improvement in water quality, as well as other environmental metrics such as climate and ammonia.
'The dairy co-op sector has a strong track record of delivering pioneering initiatives on sustainability to support our members and family farms and a strong track record of collaboration and working together.
"We will continue with these efforts to protect the environment and to ensure the future of Ireland's grass-based system of production that depends on a workable nitrates derogation,' Carr added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Signpost: A guide to successful re-seeding
The main advantage of re-seeding grassland is that it increases both the quantity and quality of grass grown. Estimates vary, but new re-seeds should grow in the region of 20-40% more grass and importantly, a lot of this extra growth will occur in the spring and autumn. Increased animal performance, improved responsiveness to nitrogen and a great opportunity to establish clover are all additional benefits of reseeding. However, at roughly €400/acre it represents a significant investment, while also been without the field for between 5-8 weeks. Thus, the importance of a successful re-seed is vital. Drainage Before spending money on re-seeding any drainage issues must be addressed first. Drains should be cleaned and if shores are required, they should be installed. Ploughing can help with drainage and levelling badly damaged fields, but be aware that the 'good soil' with the high fertility is being buried and this may take some years to be built back up again. Grass varieties Use the Pasture Profit Index, PPI, to select suitable grass/clover varieties. These varieties have been tested under Irish conditions for important traits to Irish farmers, like spring/ autumn growth, herbage quality & grazing utilisation. In short, if the variety is not on the PPI list, it should not be used. Take some time to select varieties that are best suited to what you want the new sward to do, grazing, silage or a mix. Timing In general, the rule is, the earlier in the growing season re-seeding is done the better. The reason for this is that post-seeding management, grazing off the sward and post-spraying, can be difficult once we get into later into the year. Also, successful clover establishment is a lot easier with April or May re-seeding. Spraying A young grass/clover plant is not very strong and will struggle badly with competition from weeds. Thus, it is essential to spray off the old sward. Any of the glyphosate products are effective, but rates need to be carefully checked as they can differ a lot. Most of the products need 7+ days to fully absorb the chemical. After the plant is dead the sward can be cut for silage or grazed. Fertility Ensuring adequate Phosphorus (P), Potassium (K) and Lime is essential for successful re-seeding. The most accurate way to judge a soil's requirement for these is to do a soil test, but this can take three weeks to get results back, so plan in advance. If the soil is not being ploughed and a min-till method is been used, i.e. discing or power harrowing, lime will need to be applied, 2t/ac, to counteract the acid that will be produced as the old sward decays. As a general rule of thumb, three bags of 10:10:20 per acre are required for re-seeding but this will depend on the soil test results and if a farm is allowed to buy in Phosphorus. FYM or slurry can both be used to reduce or replace bag fertiliser. Fine and firm seedbed There is sometimes a lot of debate about ploughing or using min-till. The decision will depend on a number of factors including cost, stoniness of ground, equipment available etc. All the methods can give excellent results, but the basic requirement does not change, which is a fine firm seedbed. After sowing, the field should be rolled to ensure good soil-to-seed contact and preserve the moisture in the soil. If clover is important make sure this is on the surface. Post spraying Thistles, nettles, red shank and docks commonly emerge after sowing. These should be sprayed, preferably with a clover-safe spray, five to six weeks after sowing, or when grass is at the two to three leaf stage. Pests like fruit fly and leather jackets can attack re-seeds and should be sprayed early if present. These tend to be more of a problem when there is a lot of trash left on the surface. Clover In more recent years, clover has become an increasingly important way to help agriculture to meet its environmental obligations. By supplying N to the sward that otherwise would be supplied by artificial N. Also, clover improves the mid-season digestibility of the sward, this helps to improve animal performance. If clover is to be targeted to be active in the new sward, particular care must be taken with post-emergence spray, soil fertility has to be high, and the sward has to be well grazed frequently with a low pre-grazing cover (less than 1,000kg/ha). Post-reseed grazing As a guide, graze the re-seed once the plants do not pull out of the ground. If weather allows, swards should be grazed by cows, as they will graze it off very quickly. However, if conditions are poor calves or sheep can be used, but try to get the field grazed as quickly as possible. It is very important that autumn reseeds are grazed before the first winter, to help ensure clover survival and avoid a very heavy cover the following spring. Re-seeding is an expensive investment, but in general, offers an excellent return on investment. However, for the investment to succeed attention to the above detail is vital, thus giving the young delicate grass/clover plant every chance to establish.
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
National Museum of Ireland refurbishment a 'huge amount' of work
The Keeper of Natural History at the National Museum of Ireland, Paolo Viscardi, has said the refurbishment of the museum's site in Dublin city centre will be slow going. The museum has been closed since September of last year in order to facilitate major refurbishment works. The Natural History Museum was built in 1856 and is often referred to as a 'museum in a museum'. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Mr Viscardi said they have not got the building's plans as they may have been destroyed in the Customs House fire in during the War of Independence. The building, situated on Merrion Street, is almost 170 years old and needs "a huge amount" of work to make it fit for purpose into the future. "There's a huge amount that has to be done because it's never had any kind of major refurbishment before," Mr Viscardi said. He added: "It's a big job, doing the planning and understanding what we can do and what needs to be done, what the building requires because we don't know enough about it because we just don't have the information. "We're just about to undertake investigative works in the space so that'll be starting next week. "At the moment, it's not a great space for a museum. It's a wonderful, beautiful building, we love it, and historically it has huge, huge significance and we don't want to lose that," he said. While the Dead Zoo is undergoing the refurbishment, the Natural History Museum will be opening a 'Dead Zoo Lab' at the National Museum, at Collins Barracks. Mr Viscardi said the museum will be "experimenting" with its exhibits to see what appeals to visitors before the move back to Merrion Street. "We tried to get a good selection of the really popular objects from Merrion Street," he said. "So we have things like Spoticus the giraffe, we've got out giant Irish deer and we've even been able to get out some specimens that haven't been on display for quite some time."
Extra.ie
10 hours ago
- Extra.ie
'Dead zoo' finds a new haunt as beloved museum is brought back to life
Dublin's 'Dead Zoo' is being brought back to life with a temporary new home until 'extensive' repairs to the site are completed. The much-loved Natural History Museum is closed for 'conservation and refurbishment works', so a new Dead Zoo Lab is moving from its home on Merrion Street and opening in the National Museum at Collins Barracks today. The new exhibition space will feature favourite artefacts and exhibits such as Spoticus the Giraffe, the infamous eel choking on a frog, a giant Irish elk and a dodo skeleton. Dublin's 'Dead Zoo' is being brought back to life with a temporary new home until 'extensive' repairs to the site are completed. Pic: BOULENGER Xavier/Shutterstock The museum closed in September last year but no date has been given for when it will reopen as engineers are still assessing the work needed. However, it is expected the repairs could take several years because of the age of the building and the specialist structural work required. A spokesman for the museum explained: 'We estimate it will be several years before the displays are back open. During this time we will have the Dead Zoo Lab at our museum in Collins Barracks and visitors can sign up to our museum newsletter to receive regular updates.' The much-loved Natural History Museum is closed for 'conservation and refurbishment works', so a new Dead Zoo Lab is moving from its home on Merrion Street and opening in the National Museum at Collins Barracks today. Pic: BOULENGER Xavier/Shutterstock The closure is a double blow to visitors to the city as the Hugh Lane Gallery on Parnell Square is also to close for refurbishment at the end of next month, for at least three years. The Dead Zoo replacement has been created 'to ensure the public continues to have an opportunity to see some of the most popular specimens from the natural history collection, as well as some specimens that haven't been on display for many years', the spokesman said. They added: 'The nature of the display of the natural history collection at the Natural History Museum on Merrion Street has been largely unchanged since Victorian times, and the Dead Zoo Lab at Collins Barracks will be used by the National Museum to experiment with and test new methods of engaging the public. The new exhibition space will feature favourite artefacts and exhibits such as Spoticus the Giraffe, the infamous eel choking on a frog, a giant Irish elk and a dodo skeleton. Pic: BOULENGER Xavier/Shutterstock 'At any one time approximately 1,300 objects will be on display, spanning entomology, geology, mammals, birds, amphibians and reptiles, and a wide variety of marine life.' Paolo Viscardi, natural history keeper at the Dead Zoo, said: 'Lots of firm favourites will be on display… such as the dodo skeleton and hundreds of examples of animal species from around the world.' The museum is open seven days a week and admission is free. See
