U.S. short-seller Viceroy Research makes scathing claims on Vedanta Group
Viceroy Research, which has a short position on VRL's debt stack, said the Vedanta group structure was 'financially unsustainable, operationally compromised' and was a 'severe, under-appreciated risk to creditors'.
'VRL is a 'parasite' holding company with no significant operations of its own, propped up entirely by cash extracted from its dying 'host': VEDL,' it said.
VRL and its web of intermediate holding companies held no material operating assets and carried about $4.9 billion in gross interest-bearing liabilities as of FY25, said the report. The survival of VRL depends on its ability to extract cash from publicly listed VEDL, which holds stakes in group companies including Hindustan Zinc and BALCO, it said.
The upstreaming process was inefficient because a significant portion of dividends issued leaks to minority shareholders, as VRL holds only 56% of Vedanta and 62% of Hindustan Zinc. Among other allegations, the report said VRL has extracted $338 million as 'brand fee' annually from VEDL and its subsidiaries in FY24 alone.
VRL used loans from VEDL subsidiaries to purchase VEDL stock on-market, but over $122 million of VEDL loans were 'written off' in a blatant violation of the Companies Act, it said.
The 87-page Viceroy Research report accused VRL of draining VEDL, forcing it to take on more debt and deplete its cash reserves, impaired creditors' ability to recover their principal, a situation that resembled a 'Ponzi scheme', it said. VEDL promoted capital-intensive projects that it could not afford to raise fresh capital, which was paid out to VRL, it alleged.
Other allegations included inflated asset values of VEDL's subsidiaries, capex fraud, expenses being kept off-balance sheet, and governance failure.
Shares of Vedanta and Hindustan Zinc slipped 3% each to ₹441 and ₹425 on Wednesday.
Vedanta denies
Vedanta Group dismissed Viceroy Research report as 'a malicious combination of selective misinformation and baseless allegations to discredit the group'.
The release of the Viceroy report came just a day before VEDL's annual general meeting (AGM).
Terming the report 'false propaganda', the company said, 'The timing of the report is suspect and could be to undermine the forthcoming corporate initiatives. Our stakeholders are discerning enough to understand such tactics.'
The group further noted that the report's authors had included extensive disclaimers stating that the content was educational and opinion-based, and not factual, it said.
The Viceroy Research is the second attack on the Vedanta Group. In 2018, VRL was delisted from the LSE amid protests outside its final annual general meeting.
(The writer is with The Hindu businessline)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
I-Day boost: Discounts drive 8-10% sales growth; executives eye stronger festive season
Independence Day discounts gave India's retail sector a much-needed boost, with footfalls and sales rising by 8-10% year-on-year across key shopping destinations. Industry executives say the revival in entry-to-mid segment demand has raised hopes of a strong festive season ahead. Electronics, particularly in affordable categories, along with groceries and apparel have seen healthy growth. Restaurants, too, are reporting higher sales as malls draw more visitors, helped by new film releases and a surge in in-home dining orders. 'After several months, there is good demand for entry to mid-segment products,' Nilesh Gupta, director at electronic retail chain Vijay Sales told ET. 'Walk-ins are good and there is over 8% jump in sales value over last year, which is better than last year,' he added. Electronics makers and grocery retailers ran promotional offers around Independence Day eve, one of the biggest consumption periods outside the festive and Republic Day seasons. At Reliance Retail, sales grew in double digits, according to an executive. Haier India president Satish NS told ET that the electronics manufacturer's Independence Day sales were up more than 20% over last year, with 'most categories driving sales.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Luxury 3 & 4 BHKs with 25+ World-Class Amenities Evara Thane Buy Now Undo On the ecommerce front, Tata-owned BigBasket reported a 42% on-year jump in patriotic merchandise sales on Friday, alongside strong demand for electronics, including the new iPhone 16. Malls also recorded a surge in traffic during the long weekend. Theatres are seeing back-to-back housefull shows for the first time since the pandemic, powered by Rajinikanth's Coolie and Hrithik Roshan's War 2. 'The crowd that comes for the movie adds at least 10% of the revenue for fashion brands, food and beverages,' said Harsh V Bansal, cofounder of Unity Group, which operates more than six malls in Delhi and Punjab. 'The next few days also look good in terms of footfall and sales,' he added. International labels have also drawn shoppers, with discounts prompting customers to buy at lower price points. 'International brands have contributed to the growth with consumers using the lower price point during the sale to buy products,' said Muhammad Ali, chief executive, retail, at Prestige Group, which operates five malls in South India. Those malls have reported a 15% year-on-year rise in sales. 'One segment which has not done well is Indian women's wear, which is a cause of worry,' he told ET. Revival hopes Retailers and brands have been under pressure for nine to ten quarters as low-to-middle-income households grappled with high inflation and weak earnings growth. Higher spending on travel and tourism further dented retail demand. Executives, however, are forecasting a turnaround in the second half of the fiscal, supported by low inflation, soft loan rates, reduced income-tax slabs this year and good monsoon rains. 'While middle class discretionary spending was under pressure, some consumption has started and with the festival tail wind, the outlook is much better,' Anjan Chatterjee, managing director of Speciality Restaurants told ET. He said that Independence Day demand trends have been 'reassuring, with a 15-18% year-on-year growth.' The government on Friday also said GST rates will be rationalised by Diwali to boost consumption, improve affordability and make essential as well as aspirational goods more accessible to a wider base of consumers—moves expected to spur further demand. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays , public holidays , current gold rate and silver price .
The Hindu
8 hours ago
- The Hindu
Broader geopolitical environment made automotive industry move away from reaction mode to an anticipation mode, says Markus Helfrich of HARMAN Automotive, a Samsung company
Samsung Electronics-owned HARMAN Automotive's SVP, HR, Markus Helfrich said the broader environment comprising geopolitics, supply-chain issues, semi-conductor shortage, has heavily impacted the global automotive industry. However, ''These challenges have definitely made the industry more cautious, more resilient in sourcing and handling partner ecosystems, building location strategy, but also made the industry to be more strategic,'' he told The Hindu. Mr. Helfrich also said, the industry which was on a reaction mode, traditionally, has now entered an anticipation mode, because of the constantly changing market environment. 'We've had to build resilience, in sourcing, in partner ecosystems, in location strategy. And we're not just reacting now, but we're anticipating where the industry is heading and preparing well in advance. The challenges have definitely made the industry more cautious, but also more strategic,'' he added. According to Mr. Helfrich, the biggest impact on the industry so far has been, the change, that is getting more 'rapid'' and increasingly 'unpredictable.'' 'Things are coming without any notice today. If something happens with China or Taiwan tomorrow, we don't know. It is unpredictable. The tariff situation has a big impact. I mean we are all aware of things happening overnight. So, things can change quickly,'' he observed. Narrating a classic example of geopolitical tension faced by the industry recently, Krishna Kumar, Managing Director, HARMAN India said, the rare earth material shortage came up as a big issue globally; and neo magnets, or neodymium, a type of strong magnets made from alloys of rare earth elements, came only from China. 'It is difficult for anyone to make a speaker without neo magnets, the best-in-class magnets, used in speakers for high-quality sound effects. China decided to revoke the licences of all providers of these magnets and asked them to reapply. Our vendors were fortunate to receive approvals from China, and we were able to procure the neodymium magnets. For some time it was a big tension, and it was a 100% geopolitical issue,'' commented Mr. Kumar. Mr. Helfrich further said, earlier the industry had time to prepare and fix strategies, but now under constantly changing market dynamics, that mode was not feasible anymore. ``Today, what keeps you alive is a good network, global reach, international mindset, having a strong team that works together beyond any conflicts. To my understanding, that is the only thing which guarantees you to stay above any daily conflicts,'' concluded Mr. Helfrich, who was in Bengaluru as part of HARMAN Automotive's 14‑month global cultural transformation programme designed to reimagine how the company's automotive teams think, collaborate, lead and grow. Stamford-based Harman International was acquired by Samsung Electronics in 2017 for $8 billion. The acquisition was part of Samsung's strategy to expand into the automotive and connected car market and it gave the Korean electronic giant access to Harman's automotive and connected technologies, including brands like Harman Kardon, AKG, JBL, and others.
Mint
8 hours ago
- Mint
Elon Musk's SpaceX not paying federal taxes to Trump? Report claims...
Elon Musk's satellite and rocket internet company SpaceX has been receiving billions of dollars in federal investments over the two decades of its existence but has paid little to no federal taxes, a report has said. According to the report by The New York Times, the Musk-owned company has privately told its investors that SpaceX may not have to pay the federal taxes ever, thanks to a change in the law made by US President Donald Trump in 2017 during his first presidency. Documents reviewed by the newspaper reportedly showed SpaceX can legally make use of the tax benefit that allows it to use over $5 billion losses that it incurred by late 2021 and offset the payment of future taxable income. In 2017, Donald Trump had made a change in the law that did away with the tax benefit's expiration date for all companies. Trump signed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in 2017 that allowed companies to roll over their heavy losses indefinitely to avoid paying some federal taxes on their newer profits. This means that SpaceX can apply nearly $3 billion of its losses indefinitely against future taxable income, according to the report. As per latest figures, SpaceX incurred losses of around $5.4 billion. Those losses generated the tax benefit, known as a net operating loss carryforward. For a company like SpaceX, which relies heavily on US federal contracts to make profits, not paying federal taxes is quite unusual, as per experts cited by NYT. SpaceX was bleeding cash for its first two decades in existence since 2002, much like companies including Uber and Tesla. It had over $5 billion in losses till 2021, but turned profitable since 2022. Elon Musk in June had said that SpaceX may make profits over $15.5 billion this fiscal. However, it is not clear how much taxes it will pay back to the federal government because it can use the tax benefit even if its business thrives. According to the NYT, which reviewed documents including income statements and balance sheets covering 23 years, SpaceX apparently paid some income taxes over the year. However, it is unlikely that they have been paid to the federal government. Musk had in June revealed that SpaceX had achieved a milestone, as its 'commercial revenue from space will exceed the entire budget of @NASA next year.'
