Adams libel trial ‘retraumatising' for Denis Donaldson's family, lawyer says
Solicitor Enda McGarrity said the family had to sit through the high-profile five-week case at Dublin High Court when their own efforts to pursue legal remedies have been 'stonewalled at every turn'.
Mr Adams was awarded 100,000 euros (£84,000) by a jury over a 2016 BBC programme which alleged he had sanctioned the murder of Mr Donaldson, a former Sinn Fein member who had been exposed as a British agent. Mr Adams had described the allegation as a 'grievous smear'.
Mr Donaldson was shot dead in Co Donegal in 2006.
In 2009, the dissident republican group the Real IRA claimed responsibility for the killing and a Garda investigation into the matter remains ongoing.
Mr McGarrity told the RTE This Week programme the Donaldson family had been initially 'ambivalent' as to the outcome of the case.
He said: 'The case was seen as a sideshow in that the family was aware it wasn't the type of case which would assist them in their long and tortuous search for answers and accountability.
'But of course as the trial played out it became difficult to ignore and retraumatising in many ways.
'The family had to listen along as private and sensitive information was tossed around with little regard to the Donaldson family.
'Probably the most galling part for the family is that they've had to sit through five weeks of hearings in a case which concerned the murder of their loved one Denis Donaldson, and yet when they've tried to pursue their own legal remedies, they've been stonewalled at every turn.
'The process has been an extremely difficult one for the family.'
Now that the libel case has concluded, Mr McGarrity said focus should turn to seeking answers for the Donaldson family.
He said: 'It has been a tortuous 19-year search for justice and the family acknowledge this case was ostensibly about Gerry Adams' reputation, not about uncovering the circumstances surrounding the murder of Denis Donaldson.
'However, what this case does do is shine a light on the wider, and clearly more important issue of the circumstances around Denis Donaldson's murder.'
'The fact that the family have never had anything resembling an effective investigation into this murder highlights an uncomfortable truth for authorities on both sides of the border, particularly where legacy cases are concerned.'
The lawyer said the current Garda investigation was limited to who carried out the murder, not the wider circumstances.
He said: 'When we look to mechanisms which could explore those you have things like coroners' inquests, one of the practical difficulties is that the inquest has been adjourned 27 times, quite an unprecedented delay.
'It begs the question, how is justice to be delivered to the Donaldson family if the Garda investigation is only looking at a limited aspect of the murder and the coroner's inquest won't begin until that process finishes.
'That has led the family to call for a commission of investigation to properly investigate these issues.'
Mr McGarrity said there was a 'unique cross-border element' to the death of Mr Donaldson.
He added: 'Who was behind it and who pulled the trigger isn't the only question. The circumstances leading up to that, how Denis Donaldson came to be exposed, how his location came to be known in Donegal, there are lots of ancillary questions.
'All of which I think the family are aware we may not get full unvarnished answers to every aspect, but at this point they haven't even got close to the truth and they deserve answers and accountability.'
He said the Donaldson family would now be seeking a meeting with Irish Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan.
'This family are 19 years down the line and they are no further forward.
'There needs to be a discussion and we would certainly welcome prompt engagement with the minister.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
31 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Madeleine McCann: Fresh police searches start in Portugal
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info New searches by German police investigating the disappearance of Madeleine McCann have begun in Portugal today (Tuesday). Madeleine, who was aged three at the time, disappeared in 2007 while on holiday with her family in the resort of Praia da Luz after her parents went out to dinner and left her sleeping in a room with her toddler twin siblings, reports PA According to The Sun, the new searches will involve radar equipment which can scan beneath the ground, with the focus being on trenches near where the McCann family was staying at the resort. A spokeswoman for the Metropolitan Police said: "We are aware of the searches being carried by the BKA (German federal police) in Portugal as part of their investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann. "The Metropolitan Police Service is not present at the search, we will support our international colleagues where necessary." Around 30 German police officers, including forensic experts, will be starting the search on Tuesday, with Portuguese police also on the ground, according to reports. On Monday, Portuguese police reportedly closed off dirt roads in the area where searches will be taking place while tents have been set up in the nearby Atalaia area, near a cottage once lived in by Christian Brueckner, who German prosecutors say is the prime suspect in Madeleine's disappearance. Brueckner, who is currently serving a seven-year prison sentence in Germany for the rape of an elderly woman at her home in Praia da Luz in 2005, has denied any involvement. (Image: PA Archive/PA Images) German authorities said they are receiving support from Portuguese law enforcement while the Portuguese police said that searches will be carried out between June 2 and 6 in the municipality of Lagos, in accordance with a European investigation order. Any evidence seized by the Policia Judiciaria will be passed to the German federal police. They last carried out searches in the country in 2023 near the Barragem do Arade reservoir, about 30 miles from Praia da Luz. Brueckner, who spent time in the area between 2000 and 2017, had photographs and videos of himself near the reservoir. It had previously been searched in 2008, when Portuguese lawyer Marcos Aragao Correia paid for specialist divers to search it after he claimed to have been tipped off by criminal contacts that Madeleine's body was there. British police were later given permission to examine scrubland near where she vanished in 2014. Last month, Madeleine's family marked the 18th anniversary of her disappearance, describing her as "beautiful and unique" before her 22nd birthday, and expressing their determination to keep searching. A statement from her parents Kate and Gerry McCann and the family said: "The years appear to be passing even more quickly and whilst we have no significant news to share, our determination to 'leave no stone unturned' is unwavering. We will do our utmost to achieve this." In April, ministers approved more than £100,000 in additional funding for Scotland Yard detectives investigating Madeleine's disappearance. Sign up for the North Wales Live newsletter sent twice daily to your inbox Find out what's happening near you
BBC News
31 minutes ago
- BBC News
'I know say I dey between life and death each time I enta labour room for Nigeria'
At di age of 24, Nafisa Salahu dey in danger of becoming just anoda number for Nigeria, wia woman dey die wen dem give birth evri seven minutes, on average. Going into labour during doctors strike mean say, despite say you dey hospital, no expert go fit help on hand once complication start. Her baby head hook and dem just tell am make she just lie down during labour, wey last for three days. Eventually dem recommend Caesarean and dem prepare one doctor make im carry am out. "I thank God becos I almost die. I no get any strength again, I no get anytin," Ms Salahu tell di BBC from Kano state for di north of di kontri. She survive, but tragically her baby die. Eleven years on, she don go back to hospital to give birth several times and take e dey depressing. "I know [each time] I dey between life and death but I no dey fear again," she tok. Ms Salahu experience na normal tin. Nigeria na di world most dangerous nation to give birth. According to di most recent UN estimates for di kontri, wey dem compile from 2023 figures, one in 100 women dey die in labour or in di following days. Dis put am at di top league table of kontris wey dey di data. In 2023, Nigeria account for well ova one quarter - 29% - of all maternal deaths worldwide. Dat estimate total of 75,000 women wey dey die in childbirth in one year, wey make am one death every seven minutes. Warning: Dis article contain foto of new born pikin . Di frustration for many be say large number of di deaths – nafrom things like bleeding afta childbirth (wey pipo sabi as postpartum haemorrhage) – e dey preventable. Chinenye Nweze bleed to death at age 36 for one hospital in di south-eastern town of Onitsha five years ago. "Di doctors need blood," her broda Henry Edeh tok. "Di blood wey dem get no dey enof and dem dey run around. Losing my sister and my friend na sometin wey no go wish on my enemy. Di pain dey unbearable." Among di oda common causes of maternal deaths na obstructed labour, high blood pressure and unsafe abortions. Nigeria "very high" maternal mortality rate na di result of a combined number of factors, according to Martin Dohlsten from di Nigeria office of di United Nations children organisation, Unicef. Among dem, e tok say, na poor health infrastructure, shortage of medics, costly treatment wey many no fit afford, cultural practices wey fit lead to some distrusting medical professionals and insecurity. "No woman deserve to die while she dey give birth to her child," Mabel Onwuemena, national co-ordinator of di Women of Purpose Development Foundation. She explain say some women, especially for rural areas, believe "say visiting hospitals na total waste of time" and choose "traditional remedies instead of seeking medical help, and e fit delay life-saving care". For some, dem no fit reach hospital or clinic on time becos of lack of transport, but Ms Onwuemena believe say even if dem manage to, dia problems no go finish. "Many healthcare facilities lack di basic equipment, supplies and trained personnel, e make am difficult to provide quality service." Nigeria federal goment currently spend only 5% of dia budget on health – well short of di15% target wey di kontri commit to in 2001 African Union treaty. For 2021, na 121,000 midwives dey for population of 218 million and less dan half of all births na im skilled health worker dey involve. Di kontri need estimate of 700,000 more nurses and midwives to meet di World Health Organization recommended ratio. Also dem dey experience lack of doctors. Di shortage of staff and facilities put some off seeking professional help. "I honestly no trust hospitals much, we get many stories of negligence, especially in public hospitals," Jamila Ishaq tok. "For example, wen I born my fourth child, complications dey during labour. Di local birth attendant advise us make we go to di hospital, but wen we get dia, no healthcare worker dey available to help me. I go back home, and na dia I eventually give birth," she explain. Di 28-year-old from Kano state dey expect her fifth pikin. She add say she go consider going to private clinic but di cost dey high. Chinwendu Obiejesi, wey dey expect her third pikin, fit pay for private health care for hospital and " she no go consider to give birth anywia else". She tok say among her friends and family, maternal deaths dey rare, whereas she don dey hear about dem quite frequently. She dey live in wealthy suburb of Abuja, wia hospitals dey easier to reach, good roads dey, and emergency services dey work. More women in di city also dey educated and know di importance of going to di hospital. "I always attend antenatal care… E allow me to speak wit doctors regularly, do important tests and scans, and keep track of both my health and di baby," Ms Obiejesi tell di BBC. "For instance, during my second pregnancy, di doctors dey expect say I fit bleed heavily, so dem prepare extra blood in case we need transfusion. Thankfully, I no need am, and evritin go well." However, one of her family friend no dey lucky. During her second labour, "di birth attendant no fit deliver di baby and try to force am out. Di baby die. By di time dem rush am to di hospital, e don late. She still undergo surgery to deliver di baby's body. e dey heart-breaking." Dr Nana Sandah-Abubakar, director of community health services at di kontri National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA), acknowledge say di situation bad, but e tok say new plan dey in place to address some of di issues. Last November, di Nigerian goment launch di pilot phase of di Maternal Mortality Reduction Innovation Initiative (Mamii). Eventually dis go target 172 local goment areas across 33 states, wey account for more dan half of all childbirth-related deaths in di kontri. "We identify each pregnant woman, know wia she dey live, and support her through pregnancy, childbirth and beyond," Dr Sandah-Abubakar tok. So far, 400,000 pregnant women in six states wey don find house-to-house survey, "wit details of weda dem dey attend ante-natal [classes] or not". "Di plan na to start to link dem to services to ensure say dem get di care [dem need] and dem go deliver safely." Mamii aim to work wit local transport networks to try and get more women to clinics and also encourage pipo make dem sign up to low-cost public health insurance. E dey too early to say weda this get any impact, but di authorities hope say di kontri fit eventually follow di trend of di rest of di world. Globally, maternal deaths don drop by 40% since 2000, thank to di expanded access to healthcare. Di numbers also don improve in Nigeria ova di same period - but only by 13%. Despite Mamii, and oda programmes, being welcome initiatives, some experts believe say dem need to do more – including greater investment. "Dia success depend on sustained funding, effective implementation and continuous monitoring to ensure say di intended outcomes dey achievable," Unicef Oga Dohlsten tok. In di meantime, di loss of each mother in Nigeria - 200 every day - go continue to be tragedy for di families wey dey involved. For Oga Edeh, di grief ova di loss of im sister still dey fresh. "She step up to become our anchor and backbone becos we lost our parents wen we dey grow up," e tok. "In my lone time, wen she cross my mind. I dey cry bitterly."
North Wales Chronicle
an hour ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Second indyref not a ‘priority' during my time as Prime Minister
The Labour leader said First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney had not raised the issue with him during their recent talks. Scots voted in an independence referendum in 2014, with the No side securing 55% of the vote. Since then, successive UK governments have denied the SNP's pleas for a second referendum. The Prime Minister was speaking to the BBC's Good Morning Scotland programme on Tuesday, a day after launching the strategic defence review in Glasgow. He was asked if there would be another independence referendum if a nationalist majority emerges after next year's Holyrood election. Sir Keir said: 'I think it's really important to focus on the priorities that matter most. 'We got a big election win last year on the basis that we would stabilise the economy and ensure that on that foundation we build a stronger Scotland in a stronger United Kingdom, and that's what I intend to do.' He was then asked if he could imagine another independence referendum during his time as Prime Minister. Sir Keir said: 'No, and nobody's raising that with me as their first priority. 'Certainly, in the discussions I'm having with the First Minister, that is not – we're talking about jobs, energy, security, and dealing with the cost-of-living crisis.' Last month Mr Swinney said a 'democratic majority' of pro-independence MSPs following the next Scottish Parliament election should result in another referendum. The Prime Minister said whatever the outcome next May, an independence referendum is 'not a priority'. Speaking to Good Morning Scotland, Sir Keir also discussed the defence sector in said there are around 25,000 defence jobs in Scotland and the strategic defence review announcements would 'build on that'. The Prime Minister said: 'I would like to see many, many jobs in Scotland. 'Scotland has an incredible heritage and skilled work people in Scotland. 'We've just been looking at some of the frigates which have been built and are being built in Scotland.' He insisted the SNP is 'wrong' in its opposition to nuclear weapons and said 'we're entering a new era on defence and security'. SNP MP Stephen Gethins responded to Sir Keir's points on the BBC radio programme later on Tuesday, saying: 'I have to say it's a bit disappointing and maybe a bit arrogant of the Prime Minister to think he can speak for everybody. 'This shouldn't be an issue that's decided by one person at Downing Street or elsewhere. This should be a matter for the people of Scotland. 'I would have thought that given Keir Starmer's troubles he would have learned something.' Mr Gethins said he is not privy to private conversations between Mr Swinney and the Prime Minister. Discussing the defence review, he said the policy of 'running down the Army' in recent years has been wrong.
