Jury selection to begin in murder trial of suspect in suburban Chicago July 4 parade
Authorities allege a gunman perched on a roof shot at crowds assembled for a Fourth of July parade in downtown Highland Park, an upscale suburb 30 miles (50 kilometers) from Chicago.
Seven people were killed in the 2022 shooting, including both parents of a toddler. Dozens more were wounded. They ranged in age from their 80s down to a then- 8-year-old boy who was left partially paralyzed.
Witnesses described confusion as shots rang out, followed by terror as families abandoned the parade route, leaving behind lawn chairs and strollers to find safety inside homes and businesses.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
City leaders canceled the parade the following year but reinstated it in 2024 with a memorial for the victims.
Advertisement
Mayor Nancy Rotering has said the city doesn't want to be defined by the mass shooting. This month, she announced the parade will return in July, but without fireworks, partly because of 'community trauma.'
'This year's parade theme reminds us that teams bring people together in support of a common goal, and that we are most resilient when we support each other,' Rotering said.
Killed in the shooting were: Katherine Goldstein, 64; Jacquelyn Sundheim, 63; Stephen Straus, 88; Nicolas Toledo-Zaragoza, 78; Eduardo Uvaldo, 69; and married couple Kevin McCarthy, 37, and Irina McCarthy, 35.
The case
Crimo faces 21 counts of first-degree murder — three counts for each person killed — as well as 48 counts of attempted murder and 48 counts of aggravated battery.
Prosecutors have turned over about 10,000 pages of evidence, as well as hours of a video-taped interrogation during which police say Crimo confessed to the shooting. But the 24-year-old Crimo has since pleaded not guilty and rejected a plea deal.
Court proceedings have made parts of the interrogation public, and defense attorneys tried unsuccessfully to have the videos thrown out, alleging Crimo's rights were being violated.
Advertisement
Videos show officers repeatedly asking Crimo if he understood his Miranda rights, which include the right to remain silent and have an attorney present.
'I've heard them a million times,' Crimo said at one point.
Prosecutors also have shown footage of a person dressed in women's clothing and identified by police as Crimo headed toward the parade route on the morning of July 4, 2022.
Something that could also hurt the defense is Crimo's unpredictable behavior in court.
He didn't show up to two previous court hearings, refusing to leave his Lake County jail cell. And in June 2024, when he was expected to accept a plea deal and give victims and relatives a chance to address him publicly, he showed up to court in a wheelchair and rejected the deal, surprising even his lawyers. He also fired his public defenders and said he would represent himself, then abruptly reversed himself.
'Anything could happen at this point,' said Eric Johnson, a law professor at the University of Illinois.
Crimo's defense attorneys and Lake County prosecutors have repeatedly declined comment ahead of the trial.
The family
Crimo's father, Robert Crimo Jr., pleaded guilty in 2023 to seven misdemeanor counts of reckless conduct. The charges focused on how his son obtained a gun license.
In 2019, at age 19, Crimo III was only allowed to apply for a gun license with the sponsorship of a parent or guardian. His father agreed, even though a relative had reported to police that his son had a collection of knives and had threatened to 'kill everyone.'
Crimo Jr., a onetime mayoral candidate and former owner of a now-closed deli, has attended his son's court hearings, making eye contact with him during hearings. He declined to discuss the case in detail.
Advertisement
'As a parent, I love my son very much and Bobby loves this country more than anyone would ever know,' he said during a phone interview. 'I have no further comment.'
The jury
Potential jurors are due at the courthouse in Waukegan on Monday for what attorneys expect to be a monthlong trial. But the high-profile case could complicate efforts to find a jury.
Survivors and their families have filed multiple lawsuits, including against the maker of the semiautomatic rifle used in the shooting and against authorities they accuse of negligence.
Those who have spoken out declined interviews ahead of the trial. Some are expected to testify, along with police and a former school resource officer who encountered Crimo during middle and high school.
Experts say attorneys will have to approach juror selection with extra care.
'There is information that's out there,' said Alan Tuerkheimer, who consults lawyers on jury strategy but isn't involved in the trial. 'This is the kind of thing that has affected people in the community.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
‘Me or him.' Tacoma man charged with fatally shooting 66-year-old stepfather
A Tacoma man is accused of intentionally killing his 66-year-old stepfather in their home Thursday afternoon. Prosecutors charged Jason Matthew Frederick, 45, with first-degree murder for the shooting. A plea of not guilty was entered on Frederick's behalf during his arraignment Friday. Pierce County Superior Court Judge Pro Tempore Meagan Foley set his bail at $1 million. The victim has not yet been identified, pending confirmation from the Pierce County Medical Examiner's Office. Officers were dispatched at 5:24 p.m. to a home in the 5800 block of Pacific Avenue after a woman reported her son, Frederick, just shot her husband. She said it was intentional and the victim was Frederick's stepfather, according to charging documents. Frederick walked down the stairs when officers arrived and complied with their demands, documents show. The victim was sitting in a recliner near a pool of blood. He appeared to have been shot in the back of the head and was dead, which was later confirmed by firefighters. A search of the home showed the shotgun used in the shooting was partially concealed in a case located in a basement bedroom, according to documents. Frederick's mother told officers that her son had been 'acting crazy lately' and her other son tried to stop the defendant from shooting the man, document show. After officers advised Frederick of his Miranda rights, he allegedly told police that his stepfather had been been starving him and that he 'prevented a bunch of bad things from happening.' When asked by an officer how he did that, Frederick allegedly said, 'I shot him ... I shot [the victim,]' according to charging documents. Frederick allegedly said he intended to shoot the victim with the shotgun. He allegedly told police, 'He's been married to my mom for a long time ... things just started getting more intense, you know. It got to feeling like it was gonna be me or him first,' documents show. His mother told detectives in an interview at Tacoma Police Department Headquarters that Frederick had been living in the home after he was injured in a car crash, documents show. His mother alleged Frederick had been 'abnormally paranoid' and focused on his stepfather, documents show. She said there had been arguments between the two but did not know of any physical altercations. She said before the shooting, she was making dinner and her husband was in his recliner in the living room, documents show. She saw Frederick allegedly carrying a shotgun when he walked towards his stepdad. She heard a gunshot and shouted, 'You just shot my husband.' Frederick allegedly responded with, 'Yeah, I shot him.' He then went upstairs until police arrived, according to his mother. Frederick made several allegations against the victim, at one point claiming he was a 'computer scammer' and that he was mentally abusive, documents show. Frederick told detectives that before the shooting he was stuck in the basement most of the day, documents show. He allegedly reiterated that 'it got to a point where I felt it was either me or him, documents show.' He said that he allegedly got the shotgun from its case, put one shell in and '...went upstairs... execution style,' documents show. Frederick allegedly described to detectives shooting his stepfather in the head and his mother's reaction. When his mother asked him why, Frederick allegedly replied, 'Well, I think you know why.' Court records show Frederick has previous convictions, including driving with a suspended license from 2007 in Gig Harbor and driving under the influence in 2005.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
‘Me or him.' Tacoma man charged with fatally shooting 66-year-old stepfather
A Tacoma man is accused of intentionally killing his 66-year-old stepfather in their home Thursday afternoon. Prosecutors charged Jason Matthew Frederick, 45, with first-degree murder for the shooting. A plea of not guilty was entered on Frederick's behalf during his arraignment Friday. Pierce County Superior Court Judge Pro Tempore Meagan Foley set his bail at $1 million. The victim has not yet been identified, pending confirmation from the Pierce County Medical Examiner's Office. Officers were dispatched at 5:24 p.m. to a home in the 5800 block of Pacific Avenue after a woman reported her son, Frederick, just shot her husband. She said it was intentional and the victim was Frederick's stepfather, according to charging documents. Frederick walked down the stairs when officers arrived and complied with their demands, documents show. The victim was sitting in a recliner near a pool of blood. He appeared to have been shot in the back of the head and was dead, which was later confirmed by firefighters. A search of the home showed the shotgun used in the shooting was partially concealed in a case located in a basement bedroom, according to documents. Frederick's mother told officers that her son had been 'acting crazy lately' and her other son tried to stop the defendant from shooting the man, document show. After officers advised Frederick of his Miranda rights, he allegedly told police that his stepfather had been been starving him and that he 'prevented a bunch of bad things from happening.' When asked by an officer how he did that, Frederick allegedly said, 'I shot him ... I shot [the victim,]' according to charging documents. Frederick allegedly said he intended to shoot the victim with the shotgun. He allegedly told police, 'He's been married to my mom for a long time ... things just started getting more intense, you know. It got to feeling like it was gonna be me or him first,' documents show. His mother told detectives in an interview at Tacoma Police Department Headquarters that Frederick had been living in the home after he was injured in a car crash, documents show. His mother alleged Frederick had been 'abnormally paranoid' and focused on his stepfather, documents show. She said there had been arguments between the two but did not know of any physical altercations. She said before the shooting, she was making dinner and her husband was in his recliner in the living room, documents show. She saw Frederick allegedly carrying a shotgun when he walked towards his stepdad. She heard a gunshot and shouted, 'You just shot my husband.' Frederick allegedly responded with, 'Yeah, I shot him.' He then went upstairs until police arrived, according to his mother. Frederick made several allegations against the victim, at one point claiming he was a 'computer scammer' and that he was mentally abusive, documents show. Frederick told detectives that before the shooting he was stuck in the basement most of the day, documents show. He allegedly reiterated that 'it got to a point where I felt it was either me or him, documents show.' He said that he allegedly got the shotgun from its case, put one shell in and '...went upstairs... execution style,' documents show. Frederick allegedly described to detectives shooting his stepfather in the head and his mother's reaction. When his mother asked him why, Frederick allegedly replied, 'Well, I think you know why.' Court records show Frederick has previous convictions, including driving with a suspended license from 2007 in Gig Harbor and driving under the influence in 2005.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Self-defense argument will be presented during downtown Grand Forks murder trial
Jun. 13—GRAND FORKS — A Grand Forks man's attorney plans to provide evidence at trial that suggests a July 4, 2024, fatal shooting was an act of self defense. Nicholas Jon Narveson, 27, is charged with Class AA felony murder, which has a maximum sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. He is also charged with two Class C felonies: terrorizing with a dangerous weapon and reckless endangerment showing extreme indifference — also with a dangerous weapon. A third Class C felony charge, criminal mischief, was dismissed during Narveson's Friday morning, June 13, status conference. On the Fourth of July in 2024, Grand Forks police were dispatched to Sledsters Food and Brew, located at 21 S. Fourth St., for a reported shooting, according to an affidavit of probable cause filed in the case. James Erwin Jorgenson, 53, was pronounced dead on scene. He sustained gunshot wounds; during court Friday, it was said that the fatal wound was to his neck. Narveson was located at a nearby business and taken into custody without incident, the affidavit said. During Friday's hearing, the prosecution and defense discussed matters with the judge such as jury instructions, jury selection, evidence and witnesses. The parties largely agreed on jury instructions, but used the time to iron out some specifics such as verbiage and when to introduce certain definitions — such as self defense. This discussion revealed it is the intention of Narveson's attorney, Sam Gereszek, to argue that the shooting was self defense rather than murder. Andrew Eyre, prosecutor in the case, said he does not believe self defense should be proposed in relation to the terrorizing and reckless endangerment charges, but he agreed it was appropriate to bring it up in relation to the murder charge. Sixty people will be brought in Tuesday morning, June 17, to go through the jury selection process, which is anticipated to continue into the afternoon hours. An additional dozen or so will be on standby for the afternoon, when they may be brought in if enough potential jurors are dismissed. Fourteen people will need to be selected — 12 jurors and two alternates. The trial is expected to last until at least Thursday, June 19, if not Friday, June 20, according to court statements. According to the state's exhibit list, the prosecution plans to present up to 65 exhibits at trial, including video footage from inside Sledsters, police body camera footage and video footage from the nearby business where Narveson allegedly fled to after the shooting. There will also be a number of photographs presented, of the bar, entrance, bullet fragments and bullet holes in Sledsters. There will also be photographs of the deceased and an autopsy report. The only piece of evidence Gereszek objected to being included in trial was a photo of the deceased that he said would evoke an emotional response by the jury, and therefore is unfairly prejudicial. "It's a photograph of the victim's face," Gereszek said. "... To show the face on the autopsy table, I think, is inflammatory." He argued the other photo the prosecution submitted would be sufficient, and more appropriate, as it only shows Jorgenson's neck, which is the location of the fatal wound. Eyre argued the photo was not unfairly prejudicial; he said it had no blood or gore. Gerezsek agreed the photo was not gory, but said his main concern was that the deceased has a "vacant death stare." Gereszek said he didn't believe the prosecution's intent was to evoke an emotional response, but he believed it was inevitable. Both parties cited decisions in previous cases to support their arguments. Judge Kristi Venhuizen, who is presiding over the case, said she was leaning toward allowing the photograph into evidence as it allows the deceased to be identified without being unduly gruesome, but would make an official determination later. Recordings of calls made to 911, as well as the corresponding transcripts, and calls made from within the jail are also on the state's exhibit list. Physical evidence likely to be presented at trial are the firearm, shell casings, bullet fragments, a magazine and ammunition. The state's witness list includes 17 people: eight police officers, a UND pathologist, one victim and seven witnesses. The pathologist is the prosecution's sole expert witness. The prosecution, defense and judge will meet one last time to address any final concerns Tuesday morning, June 17, before jury selection begins.
