Farmers Need Clarity From Minister on New Derogation Assessments Sinn Fein
The Sinn Féin spokesperson on agriculture, Martin Kenny, said the new requirement from the European Commission, is a "very concerning development for those farmers who require the derogation".
The TD for Sligo-Leitrim also believes the direction from the European Commission "will have a serious impact on many farms throughout the country and could potentially in some cases prevent some famers from getting a derogation".
There are 600 sites in Ireland designated under the Habitats Directive and the Birds Directive. Sites range in size from 1ha up to 76,000ha.
These sites are designated as either Special Conservation Areas (SAC) and/or Special Protection Areas (SPA). They are generally referred to as Natura 2000 sites.
Under the Habitats Directive, any plan or project 'likely to have a significant effect on a designated site or species' must be subject to Appropriate Assessment of its implications for the site.
The European Court of Justice has ruled that the 'grazing of cattle and or the application of fertilisers on the surface of land or below its surface' in the vicinity of Natura 2000 sites may be classified as a project.
According to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM), the granting of nitrates derogations is considered by the commission to be 'authorisation of a project' and is therefore subject to the assessment requirements of the Habitat's Directive.
The DAFM has confirmed that the first stage in the Appropriate Assessment process is screening, which determines if a project 'is likely to have a significant effect on a designated site'.
If the project is likely to have an effect – or if it is unclear what the effect might be – then the project must be subject to an Appropriate Assessment, which is a detailed impact assessment of the implications of the project on the 'integrity of a Natura 2000 designated site'.
DAFM plans to carry out any screening and Appropriate Assessments at a 'catchment and sub-catchment' scale to deal with the nitrates derogation compliance requirement.
There are 46 catchments in Ireland. These catchments are further divided into 583 sub-catchments.
According to Deputy Kenny, Minister Heydon needs to provide clarity "on what these assessments involve, how long they will take and what it will mean for farmers.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
2 hours ago
- Agriland
DAFM seeks public's views on horse traceability
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) has launched a public consultation on the issue of horse traceability. In June 2024, RTÉ Investigates broadcast a documentary exposing evidence of systemic flaws in the traceability of horses and how this was threatening the human food chain across Europe. Operations at Ireland's only horse abattoir, Shannonside Foods were also suspended last summer by the then agriculture minister, Charlie McConalogue, following the programme. Following the broadcast, the department commissioned Prof. Patrick Wall to carry out "a root and branch review of the whole traceability system" for horses. The scope of the review included all aspects relating to identification, registration, and traceability of equines in Ireland with a view to enhancing the integrity and security of the overall system. Prof. Wall - who is a veterinarian as well as a medical doctor, is knowledgeable in the equine sector and a food safety expert - presented his report to the department in March. Among the recommendations in the report were grant aid and oversight for a new equine slaughter facility, as well as making the central database the authoritative source of horse data in Ireland. DAFM said that improving equine traceability has been a priority for the department "over the last number of years". The department added that "incremental improvements have been made, including the introduction of an equine census and online microchip checker". DAFM has now launched a consultation to "gather ideas on how best to deliver the recommendations of Prof. Wall's report". "The engagement of key stakeholders and the wider public will be critical to the successful development, finalisation, and implementation of this system. "We are inviting any interested individuals, groups, or organisations to share their views on equine traceability in Ireland by completing the online survey," the department said. The survey, which should take no more than 15 minutes to complete, is hosted on EUSurvey, a survey platform that is supported by the European Commission. Participants will have an opportunity to expand on any issues of particular concern to them in the last question. The closing date to complete the survey is 5:00p.m on September 8, 2025. DAFM said that the information provided by respondents will inform the development of a national equine traceability system.
Agriland
20 hours ago
- Agriland
2 farms got '100% penalty' on BISS payments after refusing DAFM inspections
Two farms that refused Department of Agriculture, Food, and the Marine (DAFM) inspections last year received "a 100% penalty" on their Basic Income Support for Sustainability (BISS) payments according to a new report. DAFM carries out a variety of farm inspections each year including those conducted on behalf of the local authorities under the Good Agricultural Practice (GAP) for the Protection Waters Regulation. In 2024, DAFM carried out 621 farm inspections on behalf of local authorities, during which it detected "regulatory breaches" in 157 farms. These breaches led to penalties ranging from 1% to 25% of BISS payments for 116 farms and two farms that refused inspections received a 100% penalty on their BISS payments. According to a new report from the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) the non-compliance rate in 2024 reported by DAFM following these inspections was 25% - down from 30% in 2023. The EPA's National Agricultural Inspection Programme Summary Report for 2024 also highlights that most local authorities increased their farm inspection activity in 2024. Following these inspections a total of 1,621 "corrective actions" were requested by localauthorities last year, chief among these were requests to "provide control measures for farmyard manure (FYM) runoff, repair or replace gutters/ downpipes, control silage effluent or divert to suitable storage, divert soiled water to suitable storage and move FYM storage to suitable location". Further information was also requested by local authorities on 305 occasions - typically in relation to slurry collection and storage, control of soiled water, management of FYM and for discharges that could adversely impact water quality. Source: EPA The number of compliance letters issued to farm operators and landowners by local authorities rose sharply from 398 in 2023 to 1,484 in 2024. Three prosecutions were initiated and a further one was concluded by local authorities in 2024 similar to 2023 when five prosecutions were reported. According to the EPA Local authorities must "take a stronger enforcement approach to the implementation of the GAP Regulations". The agency said this includes taking "appropriate enforcement actions and follow-up inspections to restore compliance". It has also warned that "the EPA will continue to monitor how local authorities utilise their full range of enforcement powers".
Agriland
20 hours ago
- Agriland
Over 1000 Conditionality Inspections Took Place in 2024 Dafm
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) has reported that a total of 1,105 conditionality inspections took place on farms in 2024. Under Regulation (EU) 2021/2115 and Ireland's Common Agricultural Policy Strategic Plan, farmers must comply with 11 Statutory Management Requirements (SMRs) and nine Good Agricultural and Environmental Condition (GAEC) standards, relating to: Climate and the environment, including water, soil, and biodiversity; Public and plant health; Animal welfare. These requirements are monitored by mandatory inspections on a minimum of 1% of CAP beneficiaries annually. According to DAFM, these inspections act as an effective means of protecting the environment and ensuring that farmers comply with a wide range of public goods regulations concerned with food and animal welfare. The conditionality inspections in 2024 were carried out for all relevant SMRs and GAECs on the selected farms. In addition, DAFM carried out on behalf of local authorities 622 inspections in relation to SMR 2, Protection of Waters against Pollution caused by Nitrates. Other public bodies also cross-reported instances of non-compliance with a particular SMR or GAEC for consideration to DAFM. Separately, local authorities are also set to carry out a projected 4,513 farm inspections in 2025, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has confirmed. According to the agency, the inspections fall under the Good Agricultural Practice (GAP) for the Protection Waters Regulation. Allocation of farm inspection numbers to each local authority for 2024 and 2025 Source: EPA The EPA's latest published allocation of farm inspections (initial GAP) indicate that the local authority for Cork City & County is set to carry out the most farm inspections this year, with 587 projected. Next is the local authority for Tipperary with 350 farm inspections projected for 2025, followed by the local authority for Meath with 318 proposed. According to the EPA, the allocation for each local authority is based on risk assessment and impacts on water quality. In addition, the EPA's National Agricultural Inspection Programme (NAIP) Summary Report detailed that 149 farms were cross-reported to the agency for non-compliance, leading to penalties in Basic Income Support for Sustainability (BISS) payments. The EPA states that the top two reasons for non-compliance were the control of soiled water and management of farmyard manure. The EPA stressed that while it welcomes the increase in inspections, local authorities must take stronger enforcement actions and carry out more follow-up inspections to confirm compliance.
