Women not in combat, hence separate SSBs: Centre to SC
Live Events
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The Centre has told Supreme Court that men and women are recruited to the Judge Advocate General (JAG or legal) department in the Army through separate service selection boards ( SSBs ) because women officers are not readied for combat roles, while male officers get mandatorily attached to artillery units as part of induction.A woman had contested the practice of holding separate SSBs and maintaining distinct merit lists for male and female officers in the department. The Supreme Court had reserved its judgment on the matter and directed the Centre to submit its response.Govt said operational readiness determines vacancies in the Army, and as a policy, women officers aren't meant for frontline combat deployment where contact with enemies is likely. They aren't deployed for counter-insurgency or counter-terror forces, such as Rashtriya Rifles & Assam Rifles, it cited.Countering the petitioner's argument before a bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Manmohan that JAG officers do not have combat roles, the Centre said not only do the male officers get attached to artillery units but are also expected to discharge the role of combatants in case of armed conflicts. It cited their deployment in Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) in Sri Lanka and Kargil operations.Additional solicitor general Aishwarya Bhati said on behalf of the Centre, "Due to the prevailing operational scenario, Indian Army has a standing operational deployment unlike modern western armies. India is surrounded by states inimical to our interests along the immediate neighbourhood. This implies that our Army is mandated to maintain operational readiness to undertake conventional operations along northern and Western borders."Without referring to Operation Sindoor, govt said, "No one can predict when the next conflict arises, in which or both borders, at what force level, and whether as a full-scale war or limited operations. Depending on the operational need and force strength, combatant personnel deployed in peacetime duties get mobilised irrespective of their arm/service to boost the operational necessities of the regular Army."Arguing against judicial interference based on gender parity without considering its impact on operational readiness of armed forces, the Centre said, "Gender integration in the defence services is an evolving process and is calibrated to the operational needs and is subjected to periodic review and studies. The intake policies (for JAG) have evolved progressively from 70:30 ratio to 50:50 from this year.(With TOI inputs)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
6 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Bilawal Bhutto's mother was assassinated': Shashi Tharoor hits out at Pakistan in US; invokes Hillary Clinton's 'vipers' rebuke
NEW DELHI: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor , who is leading a parliamentary delegation to the United States in a diplomatic outreach to highlight India's firm stance against terrorism, launched a scathing attack and called out the nation's long-standing policy of harbouring terrorism. Taking aim at Pakistan's parallel delegation led by former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto , Tharoor invoked Hillary Clinton's famous rebuke: "How can you breed vipers in your backyard and expect them to bite only your neighbours?" The diplomatic face-off in Washington comes in the wake of Operation Sindoor , following the Pahalgam terror attack. While India has deployed seven delegations across 33 countries, Pakistan's smaller diplomatic initiative covers just five capitals - Washington, New York, Brussels, London, and Moscow. Tharoor's delegation has embarked on a comprehensive outreach program in Washington, including appearances at the National Press Club, meetings with diaspora media, and a reception hosted by the ambassador. "The message must be spread as widely as possible — through media, diaspora, and direct government outreach," he said. 'Indeed, I know that Bilawal Bhutto's mother was killed and one sympathise with the young man for the loss of his mother to terrorism,' he added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Memperdagangkan CFD Emas dengan salah satu spread terendah? IC Markets Undo Addressing Pakistan's diplomatic efforts, Tharoor remarked, "They can come with their narratives... But anybody who has followed this issue beyond official headlines will have absolutely no doubt as to what the Pakistani denials are worth — which is not very much." Pakistan's mission seeks international mediation and the revival of the Indus Waters Treaty , which India suspended on April 23 in response to the Pahalgam attack which claimed lives of 26 people. Speaking about India's suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty, Tharoor had earlier stated in Colombia, "The time for acting on the basis of goodwill unilaterally is frankly no longer with us." Despite India's strong stance, Tharoor highlighted the country's balanced approach, noting, "We sympathise with victims of terror wherever they may be. I remember Parliament once passed a resolution condemning a terrorist attack that killed 40 schoolchildren in Pakistan. But it's very difficult to sympathise with the Pakistani authorities who have unfortunately created this phenomenon."
Time of India
6 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Sindoor Ka Badla Khoon': Shashi Tharoor Defends Op Sindoor
/ Jun 05, 2025, 10:12AM IST Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, speaking at the National Press Club in Washington D.C., passionately defended Operation Sindoor, India's powerful counter-terror military response to the brutal Pahalgam attack. Tharoor called the operation's name 'brilliantly chosen' and 'emotionally potent,' symbolizing the pain of 26 Indian women whose sindoor was wiped off by terrorists. 'There's a Hindi saying — sindoor ka badla khoon,' Tharoor declared, explaining how India's mission was not just military retaliation but a moral reckoning with terror. As part of India's all-party diplomatic offensive across world capitals, Tharoor also revealed key military achievements — 11 Pakistani airfields struck, command centers destroyed, and satellite imagery confirming runway craters from Hyderabad to Peshawar.#shashitharoor #operationsindoor #sindoorkabadlakhoon #shashitharoorspeech #shashitharoorinus #pahalgamattack #indiapakconflict #indiafirst #indianmilitarystrike #terrorismresponse #tharoorspeech #nationalpressclub #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews
New Indian Express
8 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Busted Pakistani propaganda among OIC nations: Shrikant Shinde
NEW DELHI: India succeeded in busting the Pakistani narrative on Operation Sindoor, particularly among the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC) member nations, where Islamabad sought succour after carrying out terror activities across the border, Shiv Sena leader Shrikant Shinde said. Shinde, who led a multi-party delegation to the UAE and West African countries as part of the government's global outreach efforts after Operation Sindoor, said the unique initiative provided an opportunity to convey India's message of zero tolerance for terrorism forcefully in nations that have a distinct voice in multilateral fora such as the OIC and the United Nations Security Council. The delegation led by Shinde visited the UAE, Sierra Leone, Liberia and Congo and interacted with senior representatives of the government, parliaments of the respective nations, think tanks and the Indian diaspora during its 14-day visit. "I think the propaganda Pakistan tried to sell to these nations, we were able to bust it. It was Pakistan that sent terrorists across the border into India to carry out attacks. We provided all facts and evidence. It was a very successful outreach programme," Shinde, who represents Kalyan parliamentary seat in suburban Mumbai in the Lok Sabha, told PTI Videos. The delegation led by Shinde comprised Bansuri Swaraj (BJP), E T Mohammad Basheer (IUML), Atul Garg (BJP), Sasmit Patra (BJD), Manan Kumar Mishra (BJP), former union Minister S S Ahluwalia and former diplomat Sujan Chinoy.
