Repeat of Grenfell fire warning issued as ministers 'left marking own homework'
Ministers must not be 'left marking their own homework' over the Grenfell Tower tragedy, MPs have warned.
The Commons' housing committee has written to Housing Secretary and Deputy PM Angela Rayner calling for an independent body to be introduced to oversee the Government's response to public inquiries.
In their letter, MPs said it is 'completely unacceptable' that survivors and bereaved families of the 2017 Grenfell Tower disaster 'are still awaiting justice for that terrible day'.
They welcomed the Government's decision to accept the recommendations from the Grenfell Inquiry's final report but said there must be an independent mechanism to hold it to account for implementing them. It warned there are 'significant risks of these recommendations not being implemented effectively if independent oversight is lacking'.
READ MORE: Sadiq Khan urged to block high rise building that skirts Grenfell building rule by 30cm
The committee called for a national oversight mechanism to be included in the upcoming Hillsborough Bill. It demanded a new system be in place before the tenth anniversary of the deadly Grenfell Tower fire on June 14, 2027.
The letter said an oversight mechanism will "reduce the risk future governments repeating the catastrophic mistakes which have historically led to state-related deaths, from Hillsborough, to the infected blood scandal, to the Grenfell Tower fire itself'.
Campaigners on a range of scandals, including the Grenfell fire and infected blood victims, have previously called for a national oversight mechanism - an independent public body - to be put in place, responsible for collating, analysing and following up on recommendations from public inquiries.
They have argued that, without such a body in place, governments can delay the implementation of, or even ignore entirely, recommendations from public inquiries.
Elsewhere, the letter raised fire safety concerns in care homes after London's Fire Commissioner Andy Roe told the committee earlier this year that it 'keeps me awake at night'. MPs called on the Government to 'urgently review' its decision to mandate sprinklers in new care homes, but not existing ones.
Florence Eshalomi, the committee's chair, said: 'How can the loved ones of the Grenfell victims be asked to trust the Government to mark their own homework when they have spent nearly eight years fighting for answers as to why people were denied the most basic level of safety?'
She continued: 'The Grenfell fire highlighted the toxic stigma too often faced by those living in social housing, where resident concerns were cruelly dismissed, neglected and ignored.
'As a Committee, we are determined to shine a light on this issue and to hold the Government to account for their role in addressing the systematic failings in building safety, product standards and testing, and fire safety exposed by the tragedy at Grenfell. Never again must people be left without such basic levels of safety in their own home.'
A Government spokesperson said: "The Grenfell Tower tragedy claimed 72 innocent lives in a disaster that should never have happened. We are acting on all of the Inquiry's findings, working closely with industry, local authorities and the bereaved, survivors and residents, and have committed to updating on progress regularly.
"We have also committed to introducing a more robust system to improve the transparency, accessibility and scrutiny of inquiry recommendations received by government."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
30 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Britain is ‘poster child' for bad decision-making, bond investor claims
Britain has become the 'poster child' for bad decision-making, a leading bond investor has warned. A string of poor policy choices have pushed up government debt costs and left the UK more exposed to 'tantrums' in the market, said Jason Borbora-Sheen, a portfolio manager at Ninety One. Mr Borbora-Sheen pointed to the bond market reaction to Liz Truss's mini-Budget and Donald Trump's tariff onslaught as examples of how Britain's debt had a greater 'magnitude and likelihood' of what he called 'pinch points'. Borrowing costs surged in both cases, bringing down the Truss government and blowing a hole in Rachel Reeves's Budget. 'I'd almost see the UK as the poster child for poor historical monetary and fiscal policymaking,' he said. 'The way the UK is set up leaves it exposed to tantrums occurring more frequently and of the worst magnitude that you would typically feel comfortable with in a developed world sovereign bond market. That's what leaves us thinking that it's not particularly compelling.' Mr Borbora-Sheen said a failure to properly contain inflation, address high public debt and boost growth was to blame for the situation. Borrowing costs climbed earlier this year after a Labour backbench rebellion over reforms to disability benefits meant to cut spending and boost growth. Bond yields also jumped in January amid concerns that the Chancellor had not left herself enough fiscal headroom in her October Budget, despite raising taxes by £40bn. Mr Borbora-Sheen said ministers need to be prepared to make some 'hard choices' if they want to improve Britain's position in international debt markets. 'You would need to have a hit to growth and be willing to accept less politically-favourable policymaking in order to get your financial position back to something more compelling,' said Mr Borbora-Sheen. 'If you don't do that, you do get this quite unattractive cycle occurring of high yields, making decision-making around Budgets difficult, giving you little room to make more strident choices and that becoming re-enforcing. 'You're not getting your fiscal house in order and it's causing problems for your bond market again and again.' Ninety One, which manages £139.7bn in assets, was formed as Investec Asset Management in South Africa in 1991 before demerging and listing on the FTSE 250 in 2020. Long-term UK government borrowing costs have edged towards their highest level since 1997 as Britain grapples with a toxic combination of high inflation, high government spending and narrow fiscal headroom. The yield on 30-year UK gilts has climbed from 5.13pc at the turn of the year to 5.55pc today. Bonds usually become more attractive when yields – the return an issuer promises to a buyer of its debt – rise. Greater investor interest helps to limit or push down borrowing costs. However, Mr Borbora-Sheen said Britain's bond market was unattractive despite the high yields on offer as investors were unsettled by inflation, which rose to 3.6pc in June. He said: 'The reason you have higher rates in the UK is that inflation is sticky. So if you compare the UK's 10-year bond yield to the US's, it's 0.4pc higher. 'It sounds small but in the scheme of things is actually quite meaningful, particularly when you have a high interest rate burden too, as the UK does, with the need to keep financing those bonds. 'So [Britain] is not being given a lot of credit by those fixed-income markets.' Money markets suggest that the Bank of England is unlikely to come to the Chancellor's rescue. Traders on Monday reduced bets on another interest rate cut this year, with no action now seen as the most likely outcome for the rest of the year. The Bank of England cut interest rates to 4pc earlier this month – the fifth reduction in rates since August last year. However, inflation has been creeping up, with the next official data published on Wednesday. Anita Wright, of Ribble Wealth Management, said: 'Markets don't believe the UK has its long-term finances under control. 'Despite four rate cuts in the past year, the 30-year yield hasn't come down. Why? Because investors are worried about two things: inflation sticking around and the Government's addiction to borrowing.'
Leader Live
an hour ago
- Leader Live
Government working ‘at pace' to bring Gazan children to UK for medical care
Sir Keir Starmer's official spokesperson said a cross-government task force is 'up and running', but warned that it is a 'sensitive and complex process'. His comments come after the BBC reported that the first group of critically ill and injured Gazan children, said to be between 30 and 50 patients, will be arriving 'in the coming weeks'. It is understood that the children will come from hospital with family members via a third country, where biometric data will be collected, and that some may enter the asylum system after completing treatment. The Number 10 spokesperson said: 'We're not going to get into a running commentary on numbers or the exact process. 'Exact numbers are going to depend on clinical need and various factors.' He added: 'We continue to take all those plans to evacuate more children from Gaza, who require urgent medical care in the UK and specialist treatment. 'Obviously, it's sensitive and it's a complex process, and the wellbeing of patients and their families is our top priority. 'There's a cross-government task force working together to deliver this new scheme and we'll obviously provide an update as and when we've got them.' The spokesperson continued: 'There's a task force up and running to deliver this (as soon) as possible. 'Patients will obviously be assessed on a case-by-case basis, some will be brought to the UK if that's the best option for their care. 'We obviously continue to provide significant support in the region as well, for evacuations within the region, to support people desperately in need of care. 'And that is on top of the significant aid that we're providing to the region to address the ongoing humanitarian crisis.' He said the Government will give updates on the plans 'as and when we can', but said: 'We are working at pace to deliver it.' More than 50,000 children are estimated to have been killed or injured in Gaza since October 2023, according to Unicef. A small number of children have so far been brought to the UK for specialist medical care via an initiative by Project Pure Hope, and they are being treated privately. The Government's plans, coordinated the Foreign Office, Home Office and Department of Health, is set to see children treated by the NHS. Last month, a cross-party group of 96 MPs wrote a letter to the government urging them to bring sick and injured children from Gaza to the UK, warning that they are at risk of imminent death due to the 'decimation' of the healthcare system. Labour MP Rachael Maskell, who signed that letter, has insisted that there must be 'no delay'. She told the PA news agency: 'There should be no delay in getting children from Gaza the healthcare they need. 'I have met regularly with clinicians on their return from Gaza, who have shared the most distressing stories of the challenges of providing services to children without the equipment and medication that is needed, and in inadequate facilities where they are daily having to make life and death decisions, when in the UK, they know that they would be able to treat and save so many more lives. 'It is vital that we do everything to provide healthcare at scale and more so, do everything to stop the killing in Gaza.'
ITV News
an hour ago
- ITV News
By-election to be called after death of Senedd member
A by-election will take place following the sudden death of Labour Senedd member Hefin David last weekThe Senedd's speaker has formally declared the Caerphilly constituency seat vacant, meaning a date for a by-election will be confirmed following discussions with the constituency's returning officer. Elin Jones, the speaker or Llywydd, issued a statement declaring the seat vacant from August 12 in line with the Government of Wales Act 2006 and the Senedd's rules. A by-election must be held within three months of the vacancy occurring which would make Tuesday, November 11 the last possible date. By-elections will become a thing of the past from May 2026 when the Senedd expands to 96 members and adopts a fully proportional electoral system. Mr David, a 47-year-old father of two, was first elected as an MS for Caerphilly in 2016 and re-elected in 2021. His partner Vikki Howells is the MS for Cynon Valley and minister for further and higher education in the Welsh Government. Gwent Police said they were called to a medical emergency just before 7pm on Tuesday 12th August where a 47-year-old man was found unresponsive. Paramedics attended and confirmed the man had died. His death is not being treated as suspicious. In a statement, Welsh Labour leader and First Minister Eluned Morgan paid tribute, saying the party is "extremely saddened by the sudden death of Hefin." The First Minister continued: "Our thoughts are with his family at this terrible time. 'Hefin was a much-loved member of the Labour family. He served Caerphilly as a councillor and a Member of the Senedd with pride and passion. 'He was an outstanding politician, warm and enthusiastic and a great communicator – especially on behalf of his constituents. He will be greatly missed.' Prime Minister Keir Starmer also paid tribute, describing Hefin David as "a powerful voice for the people of Wales and a committed public servant" and said many are grieving his dedication "to making sure every person and community in Wales had the opportunities and support they deserve." Senedd members are expected to hold a tribute session to Dr David at the start of the next term in mid-September following the summer recess. A book of condolence is available in the Neuadd, the hall at the front of the Senedd building, for anyone who would like to add a message.
