Relatives of lost N.S. fishers say lives at risk without mandatory vessel stability checks
Lori Cogswell-Phillips crouches alongside a monument on May 10, 2022, in Delap's Cove, N.S., remembering her son Aaron Phillips and other members of the crew of the Chief William Saulis. She and a group of friends installed it near the site of where the boat sank on Dec. 15, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Lori Cogswell-Phillips **MANDATORY CREDIT**
HALIFAX — Relatives of Nova Scotia fishers who died in a 2020 sinking say it's disheartening that little progress has been made on a key safety recommendation requiring assessments of vessel stability.
Lori Cogswell-Phillips, the mother of fisher Aaron Cogswell, said in an interview Friday the federal government and the fishing industry are putting crews at risk by not acting more quickly on the recommendation by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada.
'They're just playing with peoples' lives,' she said.
Since a 2015 capsizing of a fishing vessel killed three people, the safety board has been calling for Transport Canada to mandate stability assessments, which would permit crews to load catch and gear in a way that helps prevent vessels from flipping over.
Cogswell-Phillips said having naval architects test fishing boat stability is crucial because it would mean fishers have a more dependable workplace in one of the country's most hazardous jobs.
'There's already so many things that can go wrong in terms of rough weather when fishing, at least (with a stability test) you know you're in a dependable vessel that's going to get you through what you have to get through,' she said.
In its 2023 report on the sinking of the Chief William Saulis in the Bay of Fundy -- which resulted in the deaths of Cogswell and five other fishers -- the safety agency concluded the boat had not undergone a stability test after it was modified.
missing scallop fishermen
Pictured from top left to bottom right: Michael Drake, Leonard Gabriel, Aaron Cogswell, Eugene Francis, Dan Forbes, and Charles Roberts -- the crew of the Chief William Saulis, a scallop dragger that sank in the Bay of Fundy on Dec. 15, 2020.
Michelle Thibault, whose ex-husband Daniel Forbes died in the sinking, said in an interview Friday that it's hard to keep revisiting the tragedy without seeing recommended reforms completed.
'You want to give up because it's really not a fight that I can win. It's between the government and the fishermen and the fishermen don't want to pay for it (stability assessments) and neither does the government,' she said.
'What it really comes down to is money. How many people need to die before somebody's going to put the money out to pay for this?'
The board noted this week in its annual assessment of recommendations that Transport Canada's response to the decade-old stability recommendation remains 'unsatisfactory.' It said it is making efforts to 'expand awareness' of vessel stability in the fishing industry but added that a voluntary approach won't be sufficient.
'The safety board continues to strongly believe that until Transport Canada ensures that all small fishing vessels undergo a stability assessment appropriate to their size the underlying risk will remain for a large portion of the fishing fleet,' the agency said.
In an interview Friday, board chair Yoan Marier noted that there are other recommendations aimed at promoting boat stability that remain incomplete. The safety board would like Transport Canada to bring in 'additional oversight over (fishing vessel) modifications.'
'At this point, we have a feeling that we are starting to repeat ourselves. We have had a number of accidents that we've investigated in the past few years and they're all significant accidents where (vessel) stability was a factor,' he said.
'We'd like the Transport Department to put additional efforts into resolving this safety deficiency.'
The Chief William Saulis should have been tested for stability after its owners added a heavy, A-frame structure for scallop dragging, a protective plate to the boat's stern, and covers to close drainage holes, the safety board said in its 2023 report.
On Dec. 15, 2020, the modified vessel capsized in the Bay of Fundy during a gale as it returned to its home port in Digby, N.S.
In its report, the board made clear that it had long urged a stricter law on stability assessments and that Transport Canada had not complied. Kathy Fox, chair of the board at the time, said during the report's release that a stability assessment and guidelines prepared by a naval architect are 'the only way the crew on these vessels will know the safe operating limits.'
Crew on the Chief William Saulis followed the industry practice of heavily loading the vessel with catch during the return crossing to the wharf in Digby. Due to the rough weather, the crew had left about half the scallops on the deck with the shells still on, which allowed them to slide about, the report said. About 2,700 kilograms of scallops were stacked almost two-metres high on the boat's deck, likely contributing to the boat's instability and potentially blocking its ability to drain water.
By Michael Tutton
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 6, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
‘The road is long': Syrian refugee engineering a fresh start in Montreal
Jad Albasha poses for a photo at the Polytechnique Montreal, in Montreal on June 3, 2025. (Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press) When Jad Albasha arrived in Quebec in 2016 as a 21-year-old fleeing his war-torn home of Syria, he landed in a snow-covered world that spoke French, a language in which he did not understand a single word. But now it rolls off the tongue as if Albasha has lived here all of his life. When he graduates on Saturday with a master's degree in civil engineering from Polytechnique Montréal, it will mark yet another milestone that shows how far he's come. He went from being a third-year civil engineering student in Syria, just six months away from earning a degree, to wondering if he would be stuck working at a grocery store in Laval, north of Montreal, forever. 'The road is long. I sometimes wondered 'am I going to get there?' ' Albasha said in an interview. 'Nine years later, we see that it's possible to take steps.' 'A new start' Albasha decided he would immerse himself in French upon arrival. First with a francization course to learn the basics starting in March 2016 and lasting about nine months. The goal was to speak French with the least amount of errors. Then, Albasha enrolled in a junior college program that would allow him to eventually resume his university career. However, his transcripts and missing paperwork from Syria led him to be rejected by almost every local university due to incomplete applications. With the exception of one: Polytechnique Montréal. The engineering school, which is affiliated with the Université de Montréal, has a large cohort of international students. Nine years later, his French is fluent. Enough so that he's able to work as a teaching assistant at Polytechnique. 'Merci, Bonjour, Bonsoir,' that was the limit of his French in January 2016, Albasha recalled in an interview. 'I remember before I started my French courses I was working at a grocery store and I wasn't even a cashier, I was a bag boy because I couldn't speak to clients,' Albasha said. 'It was difficult, every time someone asked me a question in French, I'd have to ask a colleague.' In January 2013, bombings at the Aleppo University killed 78 people and convinced the family it was time to leave the only home they'd known. His family — including a twin brother, an older brother and his parents — spent some time briefly in Lebanon before Justin Trudeau's Liberal government expedited Syrian refugee claims allowing them to come to Canada over a period of a few months. Even today, Montreal snow reminds him of his arrival to the country. He associates the fresh flakes with a renewal of sorts. 'It's a symbol of happiness for me, a new chance, a new start,' Albasha said. He works at AtkinsRéalis Group Inc., where he specializes in hydroelectric dams, a priority for Quebec's economic future, according to the current provincial government. He doesn't see his family returning to Aleppo. All of his friends have either spread across the globe or have died in the war. Montreal is where the family's foundation has been laid. International student cap Polytechnique Montreal's president Maud Cohen said Albasha demonstrates an important need for Quebec to bring in more engineers amid an aging population and a demographic deficit. 'The engineers really are building Quebec, they're responsible for innovation, creativity, everything that's happening in tech, in high-tech,' Cohen said. 'So might as well bring in students like this that have been trained somewhere else that have the potential of bringing a contribution to the economy faster, that have the potential to be trained here. 'We need more people like Jad ... and it's not to diminish the role of people that are already living here.' Last December, Quebec adopted a law that put a cap on international student applications, with the ultimate aim of reducing overall immigration. At a time when international students are facing a ban brought by the U.S. government and Canadian institutions look to capitalize on a brain drain due to funding cuts in the U.S., Cohen has a message for the government: 'Help us help you.' 'We recruit high-level students so how can we work together to make sure that we help you provide what the economy needs and to help us in the same way with either funding, or help us (by having) higher quotas to recruit.' Albasha is a mentor for others. He's the resource for many attempting to start anew. 'Sadly, I didn't have a chance to meet someone who'd lived through the same things as me, so I didn't have that example,' he said. But everyone deserves a chance regardless of where they come from. While recently presenting a paper in Winnipeg, Albasha went to the Canadian Museum for Human Rights. Inscribed on the wall was a quote: 'All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.' 'I found this to be profound and true,' he said. 'Sometimes we're not lucky, but we can't forget that if we persevere, we can get there in most cases.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 7, 2025. Sidhartha Banerjee, The Canadian Press
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Indigenous storyteller Chris Bose shares his poem, Counting, for National Indigenous History Month
The Vancouver Public Library's Indigenous Storyteller in Residence Chris Bose, a member of the Nlaka'pamux and Secwepemc Nations, reads one of his poems.
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
19-year-old newcomer to Canada graduates from University of Windsor after starting degree at 15
As post-secondary educational institutions in southwestern Ontario hold their spring convocation ceremonies, one student is celebrating a particularly significant achievement. At just 19 years old, Richard Nonso has graduated from the University of Windsor with an honours degree in computer science and a gold medallion in the university's LEAD Medallion Scholars Program, which honours leadership, engagement, research and internship and co-op work outside the classroom. He enrolled in the university when he was 15 after emigrating to Canada from Nigeria with his family. "It feels great," he told Amy Dodge on CBC's Windsor Morning. "I'm very excited to finally walk across the stage. There's been a lot of sacrifice and effort and support from people around me like my dad, my mom, friends, family. So I feel very accomplished knowing that the people around me are proud of what I've accomplished." Nonso is one of hundreds of students who are walking across stages to collect their degrees and diplomas this month. The University of Windsor wraps up its ceremonies on Friday, according to its website. Lambton College holds its convocation on June 17, and St. Clair College is holding a series of ceremonies through June 18. Nonso's father called himself a "proud dad" and said his eldest son serves as an example for his younger siblings. While at school, Nonso began working on a project to expose young members of underrepresented groups to careers in technology, he said. Now he's living in Toronto, working for a media technology company, and planning to continue his studies this fall by pursuing a master's degree at the University of Toronto. He says it may sound like a cliché but he hopes that people who hear his story will learn that anything is possible as long as they put their minds to it. "As long as you're interested and put in the work, it's possible to achieve a high fit," he said. This year's convocation ceremonies at the University of Windsor were notable for another reason too: there was a different chancellor shaking the hands of the graduates. Mary Jo Haddad passed the torch to Dwight Duncan earlier this week after becoming the first female chancellor at the school six years ago. "I am absolutely enjoying my moment," she told CBC Windsor Morning. The chancellor role is ceremonial and involves overseeing convocation, spending time with students and trying to inspire the next generation, Haddad said. But everyone tries to make a difference in their own way. "For me, I tried to spend a lot of my time advocating for leadership, supporting leadership development of students and engaging them in what's potentially possible, in that role," she said. Haddad said it's a thrill to be on stage with each graduating student, knowing that many of them have overcome adversity to make it to that place. "There was an international student who was at her own convocation, by herself, no family there," she said. "She came up, she was anxious, she looked at me, she was teary-eyed, and she just said, 'Thank you so much for inviting me to Canada. Thank you so much for having me, can I hug you?'" Asked if she had any advice for new Chancellor Duncan, Haddad said she hopes the school will continue to invest in leadership for the future.
