Murder trial jury watch Snapchat video allegedly showing bloodied victim
The jury in the trial of two men accused of beating another man to death have viewed a Snapchat video allegedly showing the victim lying bloodied on the ground.
Viorel Doroscan (23), of Bay Meadows Square, Hollystown, West Dublin, and Otniel Richardo Clejan (24), with a former address at Verdemont in Blanchardstown in Dublin 15, have pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mahamud Ilyas on December 9th, 2022.
Advertisement
Mr Ilyas was allegedly beaten to death after a row over a stolen bag of cannabis, sustaining depressed fractures to his head which a State pathologist said were 'typical of hammer blows'.
At the Central Criminal Court on Monday, trial judge Mr Justice Tony Hunt briefed the jury before they watched the Snapchat video, saying that they must approach the evidence in an 'unemotional and dispassionate' manner, despite its potentially upsetting contents.
The video showed a man lying on the ground, face up, with visible blood on his face and a large blood stain on the wall behind him.
The short clip showed the video-taker moving in closer to the head of the man on the floor and the shoe of the video-taker can be seen briefly.
Advertisement
Detective Inspector Liam Donoghue, of Blanchardstown Garda Station, told prosecution counsel Eoin Lawlor SC that he contacted Snapchat's office in the United States to request that they preserve data in regards to Mr Doroscan, Mr Ilyas and Mr Clejan. He said he believed Mr Doroscan had possession of a video relating to Mr Ilyas.
The witness proceeded to show a comparison of the shoe in the video and CCTV footage of Mr Doroscan on the same day, wearing shoes that Det Insp Donoghue said visually matched those in the video.
He said the video, which was posted as a 'Memory' on the Snapchat app, was confirmed to have come from Mr Doroscan's account and metadata provided by Snapchat said that the clip had been taken on 2.51pm on December 9th, 2022 in the area of the Verdemont estate in Blanchardstown.
Assistant State pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster previously told Mr Lawlor SC that the cause of Mr Ilyas' death was blunt force trauma to the head.
Advertisement
She said the application of force to the head was from a blunt object such as a hammer, blows, and kicks.
Last week, witness Abdi-Aziz Mohamed testified that he met Mr Doroscan on December 9th, 2022, where the accused allegedly told him that 'we hit Mo with a hammer' - meaning the deceased Mahamud Ilyas - during a fight before leaving him 'on a field'.
At the opening of the trial Mr Lawlor said the prosecution intended to show that Mr Doroscan and Mr Clejan were involved in the sale and supply of drugs.
On December 8th, 2022, counsel said, a house at Verdemont in Blanchardstown, Dublin 15 was being used to store cannabis. That evening Mr Ilyas called to the house and was seen leaving carrying a shopping bag containing cannabis. Mr Lawlor said Mr Ilyas 'wasn't supposed to' take the cannabis and then tried to sell it to others.
Advertisement
The following afternoon, Mr Lawlor said Mr Doroscan made contact with Mr Ilyas and told him he wished to speak to him urgently. Mr Ilyas went into the house at Verdemont at about 2.41pm.
Witness Vlady Ndosimau previously told the trial that he was at the bottom of the steps when Mr Ilyas went inside but ran up and barged through the door after hearing a loud banging noise.
Inside, he said he witnessed Mr Ilyas sitting on the floor, with his back against a radiator, looking as if he had been beaten and with blood coming from his nose. His hands and feet were tied using a rope or a zip tie and he was moaning while Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan shouted at him, the witness said.
Mr Doroscan, holding a fruit knife, stood between Mr Ilyas's legs while Mr Clejan stood close to his head with a hammer in his hand, the witness said. Mr Doroscan, he said, kept on shouting "where is the stuff" while Mr Ilyas responded by "groaning and groaning".
Advertisement
The trial continues on Tuesday before Mr Justice Tony Hunt and a jury of five women and seven men.
Co-accused Lorenzo Cantaragiu (21), of Castlegrange Park, Blanchardstown, faces various charges of impeding the prosecution or apprehension of Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan, by committing various acts while knowing or believing them to have committed the offence of causing serious harm to Mr Ilyas. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
12 hours ago
- Metro
Husband 'tracked down fleeing wife and killed her as she walked with their baby'
Kulsuma Akter was due to be rehoused just two days before her windpipe and left jugular vein were slashed (Picture: Family Handout/PA Wire) A 'jealous' husband stabbed his wife to death after tracking her down to a refuge she had gone to escape him, a court has heard. Habibur Masum, 26, allegedly launched a 'ferocious' knife attack on Kulsuma Akter, 27, while she pushed their baby's pram in Bradford, West Yorkshire. The mum had fled to a hostel in Bradford 'to escape' her husband's 'violence, jealousyand controlling behaviour', Bradford Crown Court heard. She was due to be rehoused just two days before her windpipe and left jugular vein were slashed. Masum had been on bail conditions which ordered him to keep away from his wife, jurors were told (Picture: West Yorkshire Police/PA Wire) Sign up for all of the latest stories Start your day informed with Metro's News Updates newsletter or get Breaking News alerts the moment it happens. Masum had been on bail conditions which ordered him to keep away from Akter, but in March that year, Akter allegedly told her social worker that her husband had contacted her He had sent her a Snapchat with a threat to kill her brothers if she did not go back to him and the next day he sent another Snapchat video saying he had 'come to her town', jurors were told. He then sent her a photo of the refuge where she was staying, adding: 'I know that you are living in this place. I knew from the first day you moved here. 'If I had any wish to kill you, I could have from the first day. You do not know what you have lost, but one day you will understand. Nobody will love you like I do.' On the day of her death on April 6 last year, however, Akter 'felt safe to leave the refuge' because she had heard from Masum's relatives that he was in Spain, jurors were told. The mum was out walking her seven-month-old son in a pram with a friend when Masum walked with her into a shop. Masum had tracked down his wife in Bradford in the days leading up to the attack and had tried to lure her out of the hostel by pretending to be from a GP's surgery, the prosecution also said in court. Akter and Masum at their wedding Footage seen in court showed Masum then walking with his wife before he spun her and her pram around. He then pulled out a knife from his jacket and began violently attacking Akter, the court heard. Prosecutor Steven Wood KC said: 'He grabs Kulsuma and pushes her into a wall, stabbing her to the body. You will see that Kulsuma then goes to the ground only for the defendant to launch a ferocious and deadly attack. 'When the defendant had finished stabbing her, as a final act of sheer gratuitous violence, he kicks Kulsuma before moving away, but not before ensuring that he disposed of the knife. 'The [prosecution] say this was cold-blooded, calculated, pre-meditated murder. 'Why would the defendant take a knife with him to meet his estranged wife unless he planned to use it?' Akter had escaped previous threats on her life from her partner, who had been married for 18 months in November 2023, the court heard. Mr Wood said: 'Generally, the relationship had been good, but there were already warning signs. Habibur Masum is accused of a 'cold-blooded, calculated, premeditated murder' (Credits: Elizabeth Cook/PA Wire) 'There were previous incidents of his making threats to kill her and in July 2023, she was staying with family members because of his controlling behaviour.' Jurors were told a 'completely innocuous' message from a male colleague to Akter, Masum became violent by slapping her and pulling her hair. The court also heard 'a chilling prediction' made Masum, when he told his wife: 'I am going to murder you, and the police will be taking me'. The next day, he allegedly put a knife to her throat in their bedroom and threatened her over her relationship with the colleague. Masum was arrested that night after a female family member called the police. After denying using violence in a police interview, he was then charged with two offences of assault by beating and one offence of making a threat to kill. Masum denies murdering Ms Akter but has pleaded guilty to manslaughter and possession of a knife. He also denies two charges of assault, one count of making threats to kill and one charge of stalking. The trial continues. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. Arrow MORE: Plastic surgeon who stabbed rival doctor and tried to burn down his home jailed Arrow MORE: Couple find their stolen car and take it back after getting fed up with police Arrow MORE: Boy's alleged killer 'was flat Earth conspiracy theorist inspired by Elon Musk'
BreakingNews.ie
13 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Jozef Puska's brother withheld information to protect himself, court told
Jozef Puska's brother, Marek, was protecting himself, not Jozef, when he withheld information from gardaí who were investigating the murder of Ashling Murphy, a lawyer has told the Central Criminal Court. Defence counsel Karl Finnegan SC told a jury that Marek Puska (36) was entitled to remain silent to avoid incriminating himself. Mr Finnegan said there was a real risk that the information his client had could implicate him in an offence of assisting his brother after the murder. Advertisement Mr Finnegan said the jury might not like the defence put forward but, he said, it is a legitimate legal defence and they must apply the law. Mr Finnegan also asked the jury to consider the possibility that Marek did not believe his brother had stabbed Ashling Murphy to death when he spoke to gardaí two days after the murder. Prosecutor Anne Marie Lawlor SC told the jury that Marek knew what Jozef had done shortly after 9.30pm on the night of the murder because Jozef told him. Despite this, Ms Lawlor said Marek and another brother, Lubomir Jnr (38), failed to disclose vital information when they spoke to gardaí. Their wives, Jozefina Grundzova (32) and Viera Gaziova (40), burned Jozef's clothes to impede his arrest or prosecution, she said. Advertisement Ms Gaziova and Ms Grundzova are charged with impeding the apprehension or prosecution of Jozef Puska by burning his clothes. Lubomir jnr and Marek are charged with withholding information. All the accused were living with Jozef Puska, his wife Lucia, and 14 children at Lynally Grove, Mucklagh, Co Offaly when the offences are alleged to have occurred in January 2022. All accused have pleaded not guilty to all charges. Jozef Puska murdered Ashling Murphy, a 23-year-old schoolteacher, by stabbing and slashing her neck after attacking her while she exercised along the canal towpath outside Tullamore on the afternoon of January 12th, 2022. A jury later convicted him of that murder and he is serving a life sentence. Advertisement Delivering her closing speech on Monday, Ms Lawlor told the jury of seven men and five women that there is an onus to provide information about serious offences such as murder. Marek and Lubomir Jnr each had information about the murder, she said, including that Jozef had confessed that he "killed a girl". She asked the jury what possible reasonable excuse either brother could have for failing to tell gardaí what they knew when they gave voluntary statements on January 14th. Common sense, she said, would indicate that their reason for not telling gardai was that they didn't want their brother to be arrested or prosecuted. Advertisement The information they had was vital to gardaí, Ms Lawlor said, to power the investigation into the murder of a 23-year-old woman who was found "dead in a ditch in inexplicable circumstances". She said it is "patently obvious" that the information they had was material to the investigation. When Viera and Jozefina burned Jozef's clothes, "they knew why they were doing it," Ms Lawlor said, and acted without any reasonable excuse. They both admitted to burning Jozef's clothes and they knew through their husbands that Jozef had admitted to "stabbing or killing a girl". "As night follows day," Ms Lawlor said the burning of the clothes is linked to their knowledge of what Jozef had done. She urged the jury to use their common sense and return guilty verdicts. Advertisement Mr Finnegan was the only one of the defence counsels to give a speech today. He said the legislation regarding withholding information was introduced following the Omagh bombing to force people with knowledge of that atrocity to come forward. However, Mr Finnegan said, the legislation does not remove a person's right to remain silent if they believe that they could incriminate themselves. At the time, Mr Finnegan said, there was a real risk that his client would be arrested for assisting Puska after the murder by arranging to get him out of Tullamore or because he knew of the plan to burn Jozef's clothes. This was a "reasonable excuse" for his failure to disclose information, counsel said, and is a legitimate defence in law. Marek's statements were an attempt to distance himself from Jozef Puska, Mr Finnegan said, adding: "He was distancing himself from culpability or knowledge of what Jozef Puska was doing that day." Mr Finnegan continued: "There are elements of this defence that you might not like, but you are here to do a job and I am asking you to apply the law to the evidence." Closing speeches for the other three accused will begin on Tuesday.
ITV News
15 hours ago
- ITV News
'Jealous' husband stabbed wife as she walked baby after stalking her, court told
A 'violent, jealous, controlling' husband stalked his estranged wife to a women's refuge before stabbing her to death as she pushed their baby in a pram, a court has heard. Habibur Masum, 26, launched a 'ferocious' knife attack on Kulsuma Akter, 27, after confronting her on a street in Bradford, Bradford Crown Court was told. The jury heard Ms Akter had fled her home in Oldham to a hostel in Bradford 'to escape his violence, jealousy and controlling behaviour'. Masum, from Burnley, had previously been arrested over claims he had threatened to kill Ms Akter and was banned from contacting her when he attacked her on 6 April last year. Opening the case on Monday, prosecutor Steven Wood KC said Masum had tracked Ms Akter to Bradford before trying to trick her into leaving the hostel by pretending to be from a GP's surgery and offering her fake appointments. The court heard he confronted Ms Akter as she walked with a friend while pushing the couple's seven-month-old son in a pram. Mr Wood said she was shocked Masum was there as she believed he was in Spain at the time. CCTV footage played in court showed Masum walking alongside Ms Akter before he stopped her, spun her and the pram around and pulled a knife from his jacket. He then stabbed her. Mr Wood said Masum launched a "ferocious and deadly attack" on his wife as she lay on the ground. 'When the defendant had finished stabbing her, as a final act of sheer gratuitous violence, he kicks Kulsuma before moving away, but not before ensuring that he disposed of the knife,' he said. The court heard Ms Akter suffered multiple stab wounds to her body and face, including a wound to the neck which partly cut her windpipe and severed her left jugular vein. Mr Wood told jurors: 'The [prosecution] say this was cold-blooded, calculated, pre-meditated murder. 'Why would the defendant take a knife with him to meet his estranged wife unless he planned to use it?' Previous threat to kill The court heard Masum had previously threatened to kill Ms Akter and in November 2023 attacked her over a 'completely innocuous' message she received from a male colleague. 'In what you may think was a chilling prediction of what he was to do in April of the following year, he told Kulsuma, 'I am going to murder you, and the police will be taking me',' Mr Wood said. The next day he threatened her with a knife, prompting a female family member to call the police. Masum was arrested that night, jurors heard. The court heard Masum was charged with two offences of assault and one of making a threat to kill. Jurors heard Ms Akter told a social worker from Oldham Council she 'believed that one day her husband would kill her', asking if her son could stay with her sister-in-law and brother 'when this day comes'. She was moved to accommodation in Bradford in January 2024, but the court heard Masum contacted her on Snapchat, threatening to kill her brothers. The jury was told the refuge contacted the police but Masum sent her a video the next day of Bradford railway station, with a message saying he had 'come to her town'. He later sent her a photo of the refuge with a message saying: 'I know that you are living in this place. I knew from the first day you moved here. 'If I had any wish to kill you, I could have from the first day. You do not know what you have lost but one day you will understand. Nobody will love you like I do.' Ms Akter's social worker arranged for her to be rehoused and she was due to move on 8 April but died two days before the transfer. After stabbing Ms Akter, Masum left her and his son at the scene and got on a bus, Mr Wood said. He later travelled almost 200 miles south to Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, and was arrested in the early hours of 9 April in a car park near Stoke Mandeville Hospital, where he had attended to be treated for 'lock jaw'. Masum denies murdering Ms Akter but has pleaded guilty to manslaughter and possession of a knife. He also denies two charges of assault, one count of making threats to kill and one charge of stalking. The trial continues.
