Manitoba may be ‘feeder' province for sex trafficking on MMIWG: report
A new report examining a potential link between human trafficking and missing and murdered Indigenous women shows Manitoba as one of the hardest-hit provinces and may be a 'feeder province' for sex trafficking in other provinces.
'The two issues are overlapping and, in many ways, inseparable,' said the report released by Thomson Reuters, a global content and technology company. 'To be trafficked is to disappear, and many victims of trafficking are eventually victims of other forms of abuse and eventually homicide.'
The report, which was released Tuesday, analyzed 185 cases from 2010 to April 2024 and found Winnipeg was the city with the most disappearances, with 14 per cent. It was followed by the Edmonton metropolitan area with 10.5 per cent and the triangle between Prince Albert, Regina and Saskatoon with 10 per cent. The report noted that Winnipeg's large Indigenous population and robust reporting of missing women and girls may have an impact on the numbers.
When it came to provinces, Manitoba was in second place among MMIW cases with 21 per cent, behind Alberta, which has 25 per cent of the cases.
The report also looked at data involving sex ads listing Indigenous women and studied the potential connection between the two.
'While it is true that some events of MMIW may be unconnected to sex trafficking, or that an Indigenous woman featured in a sex ad was never officially considered missing, research and anecdotal evidence suggest a strong link between the two than many have considered,' the report reads.
The data showed that while Winnipeg had a high concentration of missing and murdered Indigenous women cases, the number of sex ads was relatively sparse compared to other cities, such as Edmonton. The report suggests the flourishing of oil drilling rigs and mining operations in Alberta is leading to increased trafficking to that province.
'This points to the possibility that Manitoba and Saskatchewan may act as more 'feeder' provinces for victims to be supplied to Alberta, with Edmonton being the closest major city to the oil fields in Northern Alberta,' the report states.
The Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs said the information in the report is something families and survivors have been saying for decades.
'Our women and girls are being targeted, trafficked and discarded—and Canada still has no comprehensive resourced plan to stop it,' AMC Grand Chief Kyra Wilson said in a statement. 'As Nations, we have to find solutions to keeping our families safe. Canada needs to work with First Nations leadership to understand the critical resources needed in the community.'
The report is calling for a national database for Indigenous disappearances to address the issue and to include databases for sex ads as a possible investigative space for missing women, saying it could lead to more women being found safe.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Northwestern Ontario receives funding boost to fight against human trafficking
Jaye Wesley says northwestern Ontario has seen a stark rise in human trafficking cases over the last five years. "The communities that surround Kenora are seeing a huge rise in luring and grooming the youth," said Wesley, who is the board chair for the Kenora Coalition Against Human Trafficking and the executive director of the Kenora Sexual Assault Centre, which provides a number of wraparound services. "It's being done online because a lot of these communities are isolated and the internet is obviously very well used by young people." To help curb these risks, the Ontario government is spending $6 million to launch a new Children at Risk of Exploitation (CARE) unit in the northwestern Ontario city. The new CARE unit will be led by Anishinaabe Abinoojii Family Services and Kenora-Rainy River Districts Child and Family Services. The launch, announced on Wednesday, is part of a broader announcement that the province is spending $345 million on the renewal of its Anti-Human Trafficking Strategy. In 2023, 570 human trafficking cases were reported to police across the country, according to Statistics Canada. That number represents a 395.7 percent increase in yearly cases since 2013. "Our strategy will continue to provide specialized supports to protect children and youth from sex trafficking," said Michael Parsa, Ontario's minister of children, community and social services at Wednesday's press conference. Ontario alone accounts for 58 per cent of reported human trafficking cases, according to the provincial government. Highway 401 in southern Ontario has become known as a hotspot for human traffickers, connecting major cities like London and Toronto to the U.S.-Canada border in Windsor. However, northwestern Ontario also finds itself susceptible to human trafficking, with its close proximity to major traffic arteries like Highway 11-17, Lake Superior, and provincial and international borders, said Wesley. It's being done online because a lot of these communities are isolated and the internet is obviously very well used by young people. - Jaye Wesley, board chair for the Kenora Coalition Against Human Trafficking and executive director of the Kenora Sexual Assault Centre She adds that Kenora's population tends to swell in the summer due to tourists, as well as people from remote First Nation communities coming to the city to access services. The Native Women's Association of Canada estimates that Indigenous women account for roughly half of all human trafficking cases in Canada. Meanwhile, roughly a quarter of all cases across the country involve children and youth under the age of 18, according to Statistics Canada. "Some of our children and youth have experienced the effects of intergenerational trauma, poverty and abuse. This puts them in a vulnerable position to seek affection or attention," said Katherine Machimity, director of services for Tikinagan Child and Family Services, in an emailed statement. Machimity added that the organization, which is based in Sioux Lookout, hired a CARE intervention helper with funding received as part of the Anti-Human Trafficking Strategy. Yet in 2024, there were only six CARE units across Ontario, according to the province's Children's Aid Society. Communities stepping up Many communities and municipalities have taken it upon themselves to increase awareness and prevent human trafficking. Earlier this year, Grassy Narrows First Nation set up a community checkpoint in response to human trafficking concerns among its members. The creation of the checkpoint followed a community notice from the First Nation's emergency response co-ordinator, Terry Fobister, that cited "recent incidents involving attempted abductions of our band members." Airports across northwestern Ontario have also stepped up to the plate to combat the crime. Last week, the municipality of Sioux Lookout announced that its airport had partnered with the anti-human trafficking advocacy organization #NotInMyCity, which was founded by Canadian country music artist Paul Brandt. The partnership is especially important, considering Sioux Lookout has the second busiest airport in northwestern Ontario, according to the town's mayor, Doug Lawrance. "People come here for health care, education and retail business, and some of those people will be vulnerable people," said Lawrance. "Human trafficking is something that's insidious, it's difficult to track down." Thunder Bay's airport partnered with the organization three years ago, according to Jackie MacDonald, the airport authority's director of business development and revenue management. "We collaboratively put together these signs that are throughout our terminal building," said MacDonald. "In partnership with [#NotInMyCity], they do have a training toolkit that we use online that has been given to all of our staff here at the airport as well." An ever-evolving fight As Canada's online landscape continues to evolve, so too does the effort to combat human trafficking. Social media platforms that entice children and youth, such as Instagram and Snapchat, have become particularly attractive for predators and traffickers. However, Wesley added that anyone in a vulnerable situation could fall victim to the crime, regardless of gender or age. "We're really trying to focus on the youth and children but at the same time, we don't want to lose our perspective and forget that this happens to everyone." Wesley adds that human trafficking isn't always for the purpose of sexual exploitation, but can also take form in labour trafficking, particularly when it comes to family debts. To better ensure that outreach organizations — such as the Kenora Coalition Against Human Trafficking and the Kenora Sexual Assault Centre — are able to address and prevent cases of human trafficking before it happens, Wesley said it is vital that organizations are up to date on the technology being employed by traffickers. "They're using different avenues, so I think we really need to keep ourselves educated and aware of how perpetrators are actually committing the crime and then adjust what we're doing," Wesley said.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Hundreds of foreign nationals with criminal convictions evading border authorities in Canada, some for years
A patch is seen on the shoulder of a Canada Border Services Agency officer's uniform in Tsawwassen, B.C., Friday, Dec. 16, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck Nearly 600 foreign nationals with criminal convictions are evading Canadian authorities, with more than half of them on the Canadian Border Services Agency's (CBSA) 'wanted' list while avoiding removal for more than three years, CTV News has confirmed. According to the CBSA, 1,635 foreign nationals with criminal records were facing removal orders, as of mid-July. Of those, 599 — more than a third — have failed to appear for a scheduled removal proceeding, with whereabouts unknown. More than 70 per cent of the missing individuals have been convicted of 'serious criminality' in Canada. Serious criminality includes convictions punishable by a minimum of six months and maximum of 10 years in prison for a crime committed in Canada. Those could include anything from aggravated sexual assault to robbery, as well as hybrid offences, such as ones involving impaired driving or distributing cannabis to minors. 'The CBSA has an obligation to remove individuals under enforceable removal orders as soon as possible to ensure the protection and safety of Canada and the Canadian public,' wrote CBSA spokesperson Luke Reimer in an email to CTV News, after the figures were reported in the Globe and Mail. 'To support this, the Agency prioritizes cases for removal based on a risk management regime.' The CBSA wanted inventory lists cases in which removal orders have been issued, but the foreign national is evading Canadian authorities and deportation. While 193 cases have been on the list for less than a year, 45 have been on the list for one-to-two years, 46 cases for two-to-three years, and 315 for more than three years. 'CBSA officers undertake proactive investigations to locate and arrest individuals subject to an immigration warrant. Investigations are prioritized, ensuring high-risk cases have the greatest number of resources,' Reimer wrote, adding the agency does regular reviews to track down wanted individuals or confirm whether they've left Canada. 'Individuals subject to immigration enforcement have incentive not to be found and may rely on family and community members to shelter them,' Reimer also wrote. 'In addition, some individuals may resort to using alternate identities to avoid detection.' Reimer said the CBSA prioritizes removals for cases 'subject to a serious inadmissibility,' namely in instances of organized crime, human rights violations, or when the individual poses a security risk or has been convicted of a crime in Canada. Order of priority for the agency then moves on to irregular migrant asylum seekers, such individuals who cross the border between ports of entry. They're followed by failed refugee claimants, and finally, 'all other immigration violations.' In 2013, the federal government passed amendments to the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act — dubbed the Faster Removal of Foreign Criminals Act by the government at the time — to make it harder for foreign nationals and permanent residents convicted of 'serious criminality' to review their inadmissibility to Canada. 'Deportation is often viewed as an administrative measure, separate from criminal punishment,' wrote immigration lawyer Yoann Axel Emian in an article for the Canadian Immigration Lawyers Association. 'Yet for many migrants in Canada, the consequences of a criminal conviction extend well beyond the sentence handed down in court.' 'A sentencing decision that might seem routine can result in removal from the country, sometimes to a place the individual has not lived since early childhood,' Emian added. 'This legal and human reality places criminal court judges in a difficult position.' Emian said the Faster Removal of Foreign Criminals Act was a 'significant development,' removing the ability of foreign nationals and permanent residents to appeal a removal order after they've been convicted or completed their sentence. The changes in the legislation 'tighten the link between criminal convictions and removal from Canada,' Emian wrote. 'Despite this legislative change, sentencing judges have continued to grapple with the impact of deportation in their decisions,' Emian also wrote. 'In some cases, they have found ways to challenge or mitigate these consequences.' Reimer said the CBSA removed a record total 18,000 inadmissible people from Canada last year, with Canada's Border Plan laying out a goal of 20,000 removals in the next two years. The border plan was first announced last December in response to U.S. President Donald Trump's threat of tariffs on Canadian goods if Canada doesn't stop the flow of drugs and migrants over the border. Also included in the plan, and in the government's 2024 fall economic statement, is more funding for the CBSA, to be used in part on boosting immigration investigations, Reimer said.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
New Saint John housing site 'committed' to being good neighbour, but businesses concerned
Social Sharing Saint John's first "green zone," a site with transitional housing for homeless people, will see residents moving in Friday, but some nearby business owners say they hope the operators are keeping public safety top of mind. The 12 Neighbours group will run the project, called Neighbourly Homes, for people who have been living in encampments. The site, on Egbert Street off Thorne Avenue in east Saint John, consists of two courtyards with a total of 28 tiny units and shared bathroom and kitchen space. Each unit has a bed, desk and iPad. The site is near a 60-plus bed shelter, which opened in the winter as the city's out-of-the-cold response but has since turned into a year-round overnight shelter. The shelter is run by the non-profit Fresh Start Services, which also identified the people who will live in Neighbourly Homes. Saint John encampment green zones aim to break barriers for city's homeless 5 minutes ago The area is also home to several auto-related businesses. Jeff Murray, owner of Saint John Spring Works Ltd., a truck shop directly behind the shelter, says he has experienced petty thefts, such as the theft of licence plates from cars, and other concerning behaviour since the shelter opened, and he fears the green zone's arrival will add to the problem. "It's sort of gotten worse since the winter. They were open 24/7 in the wintertime," he said. "Now we're having the people that are here when the shelter is not open, I guess, use it as a human dumping ground. It could be feces, it could be garbage, it could be drug paraphernalia — things of that nature." Another green zone will open later this year as part of Saint John's Housing for All strategy, launched last year. The two sites could be home to a total of 56 residents. Green zones were originally described as areas where homeless encampments would be permitted, with services such as heating and garbage pickup. But in May, the city provided full details of what has become a transitional housing site, supported by a $3.5-million funding agreement with the federal and provincial governments. Tenting won't be allowed around site Nick Shepard, Fresh Start's outreach co-ordinator, said the organization and city staff have met with businesses and are aware of concerns. He said the city will be expanding the presence of outreach workers to maintain safe areas around green zones. "One thing that will be a benefit to having spaces like these in this community is that the city will be having a 200-metre buffer around a lot of these spaces, where they're not going to allow tenting," Shepard said. The site will have security cameras, and city staff said Saint John police will do regular patrols for safety within and surrounding the green zone. Rick Dikens, whose shop, King Transmission Ltd., is across the street from Murray and steps from the green zone, has similar concerns. With a large encampment close by, Dikens said, he has experienced challenges for years. "It's nice to see the city doing something," he said. "I'm not sure if it will fix the problems that businesses like mine and the others in the area are having. I hope they can fix some lives with it." Murray said he understands that homelessness is a national problem, and that transitional housing is needed. He also believes the city cares about business's concerns. But businesses want to see governments ensure protocols are in place so he, his neighbours and their patrons aren't facing risks to their safety and properties. "Right now, I can't say that there is no risk," he said. "It is not uncommon for folks to drop off their vehicle and be confronted by someone who's on the street and not in the right mindset which is not a good feeling for anybody." Site will help rebuild lost skills Marcel LeBrun, founder of the 12 Neighbours group, said the project will break barriers that drive people to sleep in encampments instead of emergency shelters by offering a private, lockable place, without a curfew and open to pets. "The idea is to eliminate a lot of those barriers, why people might not choose emergency housing and they might choose to stay outside," LeBrun said. The Saint John site will have no rules about substance use. Admission is based on behaviour, and recovery services will be available to those who want them. "Most folks that are living rough are substance users — that's just what the reality is," LeBrun said. "Some people are substance users and functional in their lives, and for others it might cause them behavioural issues that make it difficult for them to live in communities. For us, it's really about the behaviour more than the substances." One goal of the project is to develop "tenancy maintenance skills," such as cooking, cleaning and budgeting for bills, which Shepard said can be lost when someone is homeless for years. "All the types of things that we just take for granted, like 'When do I need to clean my bathroom?'" he said. "We've seen situations where individuals are plucked out of the street or shelters and plopped into apartments and maybe the support is not enough, and they flounder because they've lost a lot of those soft skills, so they're right back to the shelters or onto the street." At Neighbourly Homes, tenants will not be required to pay rent but will instead pay roughly $5 a day for a warm meal program. Shepard said the groups operating the site are committed to being good neighbours. "If this is successful you'll see secondary sites, you'll see other agencies stepping forward, looking to do more of this alternative housing," he said.
