logo
Should Canada target Big Tech in trade war negotiations with the U.S.?

Should Canada target Big Tech in trade war negotiations with the U.S.?

Calgary Herald30-04-2025

Article content
Canada passed its own Digital Services Tax (DST) last year, rather than wait for an international agreement to establish common taxation standards that had been in the works. The DST aims to force big tech companies to pay their fair share of taxes and imposes a three per cent levy on digital services revenue over $20 million retroactive to 2022. Canada's move prompted an outcry from the U.S., which threatened retaliatory tariffs on 'discriminatory' taxes on American companies.
Article content
Canada's DST seemed destined for the chopping block earlier this year as Ottawa sought to stave off Trump's tariff threats, with Trump singling out Canada and France for implementing digital services taxes in a February executive order.
Article content
Article content
'These non-reciprocal taxes cost America's firms over US$2 billion per year. America has no such thing, and only America should be allowed to tax American firms,' the order proclaimed.
Article content
But the calculus may have now changed.
Article content
With the trade war in full swing, Ottawa is unlikely to back down on its DST plans for the first payments supposed to take effect this summer, said Michael Geist, the University of Ottawa's Canada research chair in internet and e-commerce law.
Article content
'Policies designed to ensure that tech companies pay their fair share have been raised for years — and will now no doubt continue to be raised,' he said.
Article content
Not only could increasing taxation of big tech be added to Canada's trade negotiation arsenal, but concerns about the lack of U.S. reliability raises bigger questions about big tech's role here, Karanicolas said.
Article content
Article content
Article content
'The time for naiveté is over. (The U.S.) could pull the rug out from under us if they chose to,' he said, pointing to Canada's reliance on U.S.-owned digital infrastructure, from cloud computing to enterprise software, as well as the dominance of U.S.-owned digital media platforms which could influence Canadian public opinion.
Article content
That might have seemed far-fetched when dealing with a close ally, but America's new hostile stance means the possibility can't be discounted.
Article content
'We've seen now the willingness of the U.S. government to abuse the powerful position that American tech platforms have,' he said, pointing to allegations that the Trump administration pressured Ukraine to sign over its critical minerals by threatening the country's access to internet satellite provider Starlink. Meanwhile, Meta has said that it is prepared to ask the Trump administration to safeguard the U.S. tech sector against tough-on-tech rules from jurisdictions such as the EU.
Article content
Preventative policies could come in the form of better rules that safeguard Canadian ownership over vital digital industries, such as national ownership requirements for social media companies, to supporting decentralized social media like Mastodon and BlueSky to dilute the power of big tech platforms, Karanicolas said.
Article content
Federal regulations prohibit American broadcasters or telecoms firms from buying out Canadian ones. Yet Canada has allowed American companies to 'completely dominate' information ecosystems relied on by Canadians.
Article content
'We should be thinking about these as critical national interests that we need to maintain Canadian sovereignty over,' he said.
Article content
Canada should make it as easy as possible for Canadians to switch to technological alternatives, according to Keldon Bester, executive director of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project (CAMP). And where there are no alternatives, robust competition and privacy rules, such as the EU's DMA, can help ensure that dominant tech firms play by Canadian rules and keep them accountable to public oversight, he said.
Article content
Article content
But actions targeting U.S. tech firms run the risk of triggering retaliation from the White House and could further strain Canada-U.S. ties.
Article content
'We have found out that it doesn't matter what you do, you will be subject to the whims of the (Trump) administration,' Bester said. Stricter rules from Ottawa doesn't mean that Canada is placing a bullseye on any country or set of companies, but sending a message that Canada is a sovereign nation.
Article content
'You don't get a free pass just because you push us around,' he said.
Article content
Chios Carmody, a professor and director of the Canada-United States Law Institute at the University of Western Ontario said earlier this year that Ottawa must stand firm on the DST and not 'cave in to U.S. demands.'
Article content
Article content
At the same time, he cautioned that big tech isn't 'necessarily a foe' and has a role to play in building a strong Canadian tech industry.
Article content
Whatever action Ottawa decides should prioritize Canada's economic and national security interests, Karanicolas said.
Article content
'We can't cower in fear due to the threat of retaliation. Any steps that we take shouldn't just be targeted towards American platforms. But taking these steps … to try to impose better accountability and transparency … is something that's in Canada's interest.'
Article content

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'When our mates need help, Australia is there': Fire crew from Down Under deployed in Alberta
'When our mates need help, Australia is there': Fire crew from Down Under deployed in Alberta

CBC

time18 minutes ago

  • CBC

'When our mates need help, Australia is there': Fire crew from Down Under deployed in Alberta

Social Sharing With wildfires burning across Alberta, firefighters defending communities under threat will be getting some help from Down Under. Crews from Australia are bound for Alberta to help in the battle against more than 60 fires raging across the province. In a post to social media, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese thanked the firefighters for their service during their upcoming deployment "When our mates need help, Australia is there," Albanese said. "Thank you to our brave Aussie firefighters heading to help battle the Alberta wildfires in Canada." The New South Wales Rural Fire Service in Australia said a group of their firefighters and specialists from Southern Highlands has deployed to Canada for five weeks. The 96-strong contingent boarded a flight to Canada Sunday and will provide critical expertise and support to the Canadian authorities "in their time of need," the service said in a post to its official Facebook page. The deployment is in response to a request from the Canadian Interagency Forest Fire Centre, the service said. 'What friends do' The Australian High Commissioner to Canada, Kate Logan, said the crews "are on their way to support their Canadian colleagues battle wildfires in Alberta." She said such overseas deployments build on the countries' proud co-operation under the Australia/Canada Memorandum of Understanding on emergency management, but "more importantly, it's what friends do." Australia also sent firefighters to Canada in 2024 to help fight a massive wildfire that forced the evacuation of Jasper National Park, as well as other fires earlier that month in British Columbia. The Yukon government, meanwhile, says it is sending 20 firefighters to fight wildfires in Alberta and will be there for nearly three weeks. According to the Alberta government, more than 1,000 Alberta firefighters are currently battling wildfires across the province and help has already come from far away as conditions grew volatile in recent weeks. In an update on the wildfire response on Friday, the province said firefighters and aircraft from British Columbia, Quebec, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Washington State, Oregon and Idaho had already been deployed in Alberta to assist on the front lines. WATCH | Evacuation orders refused, the implications of those who stay behind: Why some refuse to evacuate during wildfires — and how understanding those choices can improve disaster plans 18 hours ago Duration 1:49 As out-of-control wildfires threaten communities across central and Western Canada, thousands of people have been forced out of their homes across Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta — but even in the face of mandatory evacuation orders and potential danger, some people may not go willingly, or at all. Across Canada, from northwest Ontario to British Columbia, hundreds of wildfires continue to burn, forcing thousands of people from their homes. In Alberta, nearly 3,000 people remain displaced and, as of Tuesday, seven out of the province's 65 wildfires were considered an imminent threat to nearby communities. As of Tuesday, more than 617,300 hectares of Alberta forest and farmland has been consumed. In all, 544 fires have sparked in the province since winter, in what has proven to be an explosive and destructive start to wildfire season across the west.

Canada joins U.K., other nations in sanctioning two Israeli cabinet ministers
Canada joins U.K., other nations in sanctioning two Israeli cabinet ministers

Toronto Star

time20 minutes ago

  • Toronto Star

Canada joins U.K., other nations in sanctioning two Israeli cabinet ministers

OTTAWA - Canada has joined the U.K., Norway, Australia and New Zealand in sanctioning two Israeli cabinet ministers for 'inciting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank.' Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich are accused of pushing 'extremist rhetoric' by calling for the displacement of Palestinians in the West Bank and the expansion of Israeli settlements in the territory. The five countries issued a joint statement announcing the sanctions Tuesday morning. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW 'Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich have incited extremist violence and serious abuses of Palestinian human rights,' the statement says. 'Extremist rhetoric advocating the forced displacement of Palestinians and the creation of new Israeli settlements is appalling and dangerous. These actions are not acceptable.' The statement says that the countries tried to work with the Israeli government on the issue of forced Palestinian displacement but 'violent perpetrators' continue to act with 'encouragement and impunity.' The statement says that while the countries imposing sanctions still support Israel's right to defend itself, the actions of the 'targeted individuals' undermine 'Israel's own security and standing in the world.' 'Today's measures focus on the West Bank, but of course this cannot be seen in isolation from the catastrophe in Gaza,' the statement says. 'We continue to be appalled by the immense suffering of civilians, including the denial of essential aid.' The sanctioned individuals are inadmissible to Canada and Canadian individuals and organizations are barred from doing business with them. Last month, Prime Minister Mark Carney joined British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron in writing an open letter condemning Israeli military operations in Gaza. The three leaders called the level of suffering in the territory 'intolerable.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW The letter called on the Israeli government to allow more food aid into Gaza and to end military operations there, and for Hamas to release its remaining hostages. The three leaders said they would take 'concrete actions' if Israel did not comply. Carney, Starmer and Macron also threatened to impose sanctions on people and groups linked to the expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank. The U.K. imposed sanctions on what it called a 'West Bank violence network' shortly after the letter was released publicly. Canada has imposed three previous rounds of sanctions on people and groups associated with expanding Israeli settlements in the West Bank. The last round of sanctions was announced in February. This report was first published by The Canadian Press on June 10, 2025. Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.

Hegseth faces sharp questions from Congress on deploying troops to Los Angeles and Pentagon chaos
Hegseth faces sharp questions from Congress on deploying troops to Los Angeles and Pentagon chaos

Toronto Star

time24 minutes ago

  • Toronto Star

Hegseth faces sharp questions from Congress on deploying troops to Los Angeles and Pentagon chaos

WASHINGTON (AP) — Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was quickly met with sharp questions and criticism Tuesday by lawmakers who pressed him about his early moves to deploy troops to Los Angeles, fire key military leaders and purge diversity programs. They expressed bipartisan frustration that Congress has not yet gotten a full defense budget from the Trump administration. 'Your tenure as secretary has been marked by endless chaos,' Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., told Hegseth. Others, including Republican leaders, warned that massive spending projects such as President Donald Trump's desire for a $175 billion Golden Dome missile defense system will get broad congressional scrutiny.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store