Auditor-General's report: Felcra's acquisition of Gua Musang oil palm estates hasty
These include the Dabong estate and Sungai Rawit 2 estate (approved in Board Meeting No. 207/2022), as well as the Aring estate (approved in Special Board Meeting No. 217/2023).
"The acquisition of all three estates relied only on feasibility reports prepared by a Felcra Bhd subsidiary.
"Financially, the investments were questionable due to long payback periods of 11 to 22 years,even after factoring in recovery work.
"On top of that, extra costs including lease payments to Kelantan state agencies were not fully considered.
"Aside from that, palm oil yields from the estates in 2022 to 2024 were low and had not met production targets.
"Felcra is expected to spend RM5.98mil on recovery works to improve yields at these estates," read the report that was released on Monday (July 21).
It also highlighted that land selected for investment should not have unresolved legal or financial issues.
In this case, the leasehold land owned by the Kelantan Islamic Religious and Malay Customs Council (Maik) came with existing debt tied to a company, posing financial risk if the company fails to pay.
As of April 2025, the lease registration for Aring estate had not been completed due to pending approval from the Kelantan state exco, delaying the settlement of the remaining RM30.97mil payment.
The report also found that Felcra also failed to comply with contract terms requiring verification of assets and machinery during vacant possession for Dabong and Aring Estates.
"No asset registry was prepared, and audit visits found discrepancies between the number of assets stated and those actually on site," it said.
In response, Felcra said that a recovery cost of RM3.74mil was needed during the acquisition of the Aring Estate to ensure smooth production, especially for tasks such as weed control and frond pruning.
"Recovery work is still ongoing at the estate, including the construction of pest control drains, and is expected to be completed by May 2025," said Felcra.
On the verification of assets, Felcra said "the estate was purchased on a "lock, stock, and barrel" basis, meaning all assets on the estate were included in the purchase."
"Felcra took immediate action by verifying and documenting the receipt of assets and machinery through the estate manager on April 7 2025," said Felcra.
The AG report recommended Felcra improve its governance processes to ensure that all decisions related to plantation acquisitions are made collectively, align with previous resolutions and follow the company's constitution, rules and regulations.
"Any changes to earlier board decisions must be clearly documented, confirmed through a new resolution, and properly recorded by the company secretary," read the report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
4 days ago
- Borneo Post
Local sambal makes inroads into overseas markets, says Rubiah
Rubiah launches Sambal Street 2025 in Kuala Lumpur. — Bernama photo KUALA LUMPUR (Aug 1): Sambal Street 2025 aims to celebrate the heritage of local flavours and rural entrepreneurial spirit through a wide variety of sambal and chilli-based products from across the country, said Deputy Minister of Rural and Regional Development Datuk Rubiah Wang. She said that local sambal produced by rural entrepreneurs is gaining popularity not only domestically but also in overseas markets such as Singapore, Brunei and Saudi Arabia. 'These international markets are not solely dependent on the Malaysia External Trade Development Corporation (Matrade) but are also driven by the initiatives and business networks established by our entrepreneurs themselves,' she told reporters after launching Sambal Street 2025 here yesterday. Organised by Felcra Berhad, Sambal Street 2025 is intended to promote products by Felcra-supported entrepreneurs, highlight the diverse traditional sambal varieties of each state, enhance the added value of rural agricultural produce and encourage innovation in the local food industry. Meanwhile, entrepreneur Mohd Yusof Fauzi, 45, from Jempol, Negeri Sembilan, said his sambal brand Sambarindu is now available at Petronas stations nationwide and has also entered the Singapore and Brunei markets. Sambal Street 2025 features more than 30 sambal products from 16 Felcra entrepreneurs, marketed through cooperatives, petrol stations, digital platforms and export channels to Asean and Middle Eastern countries. — Bernama Rubiah Wang Sambal Street 2025
The Star
22-07-2025
- The Star
National Audit Department recovers over RM157mil in one year
KUALA LUMPUR: A total of RM157.73mil has been recovered by the National Audit Department through audits done between 2024 and June this year, says Auditor-General Datuk Seri Wan Suraya Wan Mohd Radzi. She said the amount was collected through penalty claims, outstanding rent, the collection of Liquidated Ascertained Damages (LAD), overdue land leases, and the collection of duties and taxes. 'The amendments on the Audit Act 1957 (Act 62) also empowers the Auditor-General to audit other bodies, including registered companies that receive financial guarantees from the government. '(This is) to track public funds through the new approach of 'Follow The Public Money Audit', issue any guidelines if necessary and provide any recommendations in addressing serious misconduct to prevent the misuse of public funds,' she said in a statement yesterday. She has also revealed that a total of 1,856 gazetted government companies have been audited through the eSelfAudit system. Wan Suraya said five audits have been conducted involving seven ministries, with the total costs of audited programmes and projects reaching RM48.873bil. 'The scope of the audit encompasses programmes, activities or projects that were implemented within the 11th and 12th Malaysia Plan.' The audits, she said, had found irregularities involving several agencies such as Felcra, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia and the army. For Felcra, it was revealed that there were weaknesses in governance in the procurement implementation of leasing one oil palm plantation in Sandakan, Sabah, and three oil palm plantations in Gua Musang, Kelantan, which involved procurements totaling RM241.76mil in the period from 2022 to 2024. Meanwhile, the audits on the procurement and services at UKM found irregularities in tender and procurement processes involving RM58.45mil. 'This happened when the tender procurement committee had chosen companies that were not recommended by the technical evaluation committee, financial evaluation committee and pre-tender committee,' said Wan Suraya. She said there were also weaknesses in the contract administration and procurement management under the armed vehicles management by the army, which saw a total of RM162.75mil failed to be collected. Fines on the company causing the delay in maintenance, repair and supply of spare parts, were worth RM1.42mil. 'In addition, it was found that the procurement of maintenance services, repairs and the supply of spare parts for armored vehicles totaling RM107.54mil was carried out in small fragmented parts,' said Wan Suraya.
Free Malaysia Today
21-07-2025
- Free Malaysia Today
Ensure accountability in deals flagged by A-G, says TI-M
TI-M president Raymon Ram said the Auditor-General's Report must not be 'an annual ritual of regret' but followed by structural reforms. (Facebook pic) PETALING JAYA : Transparency International Malaysia (TI-M) has urged the government to ensure accountability after the Auditor-General's Report 2025 flagged issues involving several projects worth hundreds of millions of ringgit. TI-M president Raymon Ram said the report unveiled irregularities and systemic weaknesses in financial management and procurement oversight, necessitating structural reforms. Raymon said such issues were not new and had been repeatedly flagged by the audit department, but they had continued because of outdated procedures, weak oversight and a culture of impunity. 'Where is the accountability for all these lapses? 'The government must take a firm stance and hold the leadership accountable for discrepancies involving public funds. 'These recurring findings highlight institutional weaknesses that demand more than administrative corrections; they require structural reform,' he said in a statement. Raymon said the revelations further erode the confidence of Malaysians in public institutions. The A-G's report flagged serious issues on how more than RM460 million of government funds was spent on land deals, university tenders, and defence contracts between 2020 and 2024, naming Felcra Bhd, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), and the army. He urged the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission and the police to initiate investigations into these issues to look into the possibility of fraud, abuse of power or negligence. He also called on the relevant government ministries, departments and agencies to disclose the remedial actions they would take within 30 days to show responsibility and ensure public confidence. The government must make it mandatory for independent third-party experts to be roped in to monitor high-risk procurements under 'integrity pacts', involving civil society and professionals from the private sector, he said. Raymon also urged Putrajaya to table a comprehensive public procurement law that outlines transparency standards, penalties for non-compliance and clear procurement dispute mechanisms. 'The A-G's report must not be an annual ritual of regret. 'It must serve as a catalyst for reform, one that rebuilds institutional integrity, ensures justice for wrongdoing and protects the interests of the rakyat,' he said.
