No plans for new public toilets to be open at night-time, says Dublin City Council manager
In a discussion that lasted over 40 minutes at a Dublin City Council meeting this evening, two dozen councillors spoke about the need to improve access to public toilets in Dublin city centre.
Many were disappointed with aspects of a recent report on the matter by the council's executive manager, which Councillor Daithí Doolan said could have done more to propose 'solutions'.
Councillor Rachel Batten said there is 'something seriously wrong within Dublin City Council in that we can't provide basic facilities within the city and I do think we need to be a little bit more imaginative in how we do it'.
The report details how the cubicles outside St Stephen's Green are the only on-street public toilets available in Dublin city and how a market consultation seeking submissions for partners to manage new public toilets attracted little commercial interest.
The report included a list of toilets located within buildings operated by Dublin City Council that are available for public use. It also used the privately-owned website 'pee.ie' to compile a list of toilets in locations like shopping centres, cultural buildings and service stations.
The council is planning to install new public toilets on O'Connell Street, Smithfield Square, South King Street and Barnardo Square by mid-2026.
These would likely only be open during daytime hours and could charge users a 50 cent fee.
The total cost of the project is expected to reach around €5.7 million.
At this evening's meeting, councillors raised questions and concerns in relation to the report and the current plans for increasing on-street public toilets in the city centre.
Several said they believed the toilets should be free rather than carrying any charge and that they should operate 24 hours a day to open up access for people who are homeless and people in the city for nightlife.
Access to the toilets for people with illnesses or disabilities was also raised, with the suggestion that there should be a normalised system of allowing priority access for people with conditions that mean quick access to such facilities is required.
Councillors questioned why the cost of the project was foreseen to be so high and whether the cost could be brought down by selling space for commercial advertisements on the units.
Many said that awareness of existing toilets that can be used by the public is low in some cases and said there should be an advertising or social media campaign, or signage outside of buildings, alerting people to locations where public toilets are available inside buildings.
Advertisement
Responding to councillors' concerns, manager Richard Shakespeare said the toilets will be 'used day in, day out' and will need 'cleaners there constantly servicing them' and potentially security staff.
He said those costs are factored into the council's estimates but that ultimately 'we have to go for procurement for this and the market will tell us what the cost of doing this is'.
'Look, the hours of operation – what we're looking at at the moment is retail hours,' he said.
'In general, people who are in town for the night-time economy are in a bar, a restaurant, a venue, a theatre – there are toilets in all of those facilities.
'If we're going to open these up 24 hours a day, the [cost] numbers I'm talking about here are going to quadruple for management.
'They need to be cleaned, so it's going to get more expensive [if they're open for longer].'
On raising awareness about existing toilets, Shakespeare said: 'We will talk to the press office on advertising the locations of where they are. Social media, that's very easily done.
'But I don't think we'll be going down the road of a proliferation of signs around the city indicating where every toilet is, but we can certainly look at what easy options are available,' he continued.
He said that CCTV could be potentially considered for security needs but that it would raise issues in relation to privacy and data protection
He said management could 'certainly look at' facilitating priority access for people with c certain illnesses.
There were 60 on-street public toilets available in Dublin city centre in the 1970s, but this figure dropped to zero by the end of the 1990s and remained at zero until 2020.
Temporary toilet units were installed outside St Stephen's Green and on Wolfe Tone Street (later relocated on Ryder's Row) in March 2020 while businesses and the bathrooms within them were closed.
The St Stephen's Green unit, which contains seven toilet cubicles, is still in place, though the Ryder's Row unit was removed in 2022 'due to low usage, high costs, and anti-social complaints'.
Both units experienced peak levels of use during the summers of 2020 and 2021, with around 23,000 visits in total per week.
That later fell to around 1,800 visits per week to the St Stephen's Green unit by the end of 2022 after business had resumed as normal following the removal of Covid-19 restrictions.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Planning refused for Airbnb operator with 10 apartments close to Dublin Castle
Dublin City Council has refused planning retention to a significant Airbnb operator close to Dublin Castle and Temple Bar to continue offering its apartments for short-term letting to tourists. Dublin Castle Suites advertises its 10 apartments on the Airbnb platform and can earn up to €350 per night, per apartment on busy weekends. The owner of the apartments facing on to Parliament Street and Dame Street would earn only a fraction of its current rental income if the apartments are to be rented for long-term letting only. A question mark has now been put over the lucrative enterprise following the council's decision to refuse planning retention to allow the apartments to continue as short-term lets. READ MORE The applicant, Olympia Real Estate Limited, now has the option of appealing to An Coimisiún Pleanála, which could reverse the council's planning refusal. [ 'We can't afford to live here': Westport housing crisis leaves no room for locals as homeowners turn to Airbnb Opens in new window ] In its decision, the council noted that there was a general presumption in the Dublin City Council Development Plan against the provision of dedicated short-term tourist rental accommodation in the city due to the impact on the availability of housing stock. The council stated that Olympia Real Estate Ltd has not provided a sufficient justification for the provision of short lease apartments at this location. It found that the proposal to continue the apartments for short-term letting 'would create an undesirable precedent for similar type development and would devalue property in the vicinity'. Olympia Real Estate Limited lodged the planning application after the council issued it with a warning letter over the use of the apartments for short-term letting. Planning consultants for the applicants, Cunnane Stratton Reynolds (CSR), stated that 'enabling housing as short-term let accommodation in this instance redirects such demand away from mainstream housing'. 'The proposed tourism accommodation will assist in the attractiveness of the area for tourists and will promote a continued busy and vibrant city centre,' the consultants added. CSR stated that its client's ability to acoustically meet the standards of normal accommodation was not available given the protected status of the premises in question. They state 'in a period of substantial housing crisis these units cannot remain vacant'. Objecting to the planned retention, Fiachra Brennan of Oakcourt Park, Dublin 20 and who works on Parliament Street said that 'these are high-quality urban apartments which should be available on the long-term rental market'. 'The applicant has pointed to issues with regard to soundproofing and insulation – this should not preclude the use of the property for its intended purpose,' he said.
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Fifty new bottle return bin surrounds introduced in Dublin
As part of the next stage of the project's expansion, new surrounds have been added to 'Big Belly bins', the large, enclosed public bins operated with a foot pedal. The newly designed bin surrounds can hold approximately six cans or bottles on each side. The initiative aims to make recycling more visible and accessible, while reducing litter. The project is being co-funded by Re-turn and Dublin City Council. The new surrounds are located in high-footfall areas including Smithfield Plaza, the Quays, and Temple Bar. This expansion builds on an earlier rollout of 80 bin surrounds in the city centre, and an additional 24 installed at Dún Laoghaire Harbour. According to Re-turn, containers left on the bin surrounds are collected on average within just 16 minutes. A public survey conducted by Re-turn found that 79pc of people support 'on-the-go' recycling schemes and would welcome similar initiatives in their own areas. Barry Woods, Head of Waste Management of Dublin City Council, said he is confident the scheme will create an opportunity for change. 'Re-turn's bin surrounds provide a visible, accessible, and practical way for the public to recycle on the go, reducing landfill waste and environmental pollution while supporting Ireland's strategy for a circular economy,' he said. 'Over 1.7 billion plastic bottles and cans have been recycled through the Deposit Return Scheme since it was introduced in February 2024, a testament to the commitment of the Irish people to sustainability.' CEO of Re-turn, Ciaran Foley, said they are happy to collaborate with Dublin City Council on the initiative. 'We are committed to providing the public with convenient and visible recycling options, and the bin surrounds pilot scheme is successfully delivering on that promise,' he said. Lord Mayor Ray McAdam added that the scheme was a 'significant step forward to cleaner streets'. 'Dublin is leading the way with Re-turn's bin surrounds on Big Belly bins across the city centre. This simple, effective idea is already making a visible difference,' he said. 'The strong public support shows a real appetite for on-the-move recycling. It's a big step towards cleaner streets, a greener city, and a stronger circular economy for everyone.' Galway city and Carlow town have been identified as the next locations for the bin surround programme.
Irish Times
5 days ago
- Irish Times
St Stephen's Green and Temple Bar waste compactors to tackle street rubbish in weeks
Large on-street waste compactors, similar to the size of a small caravan, will come into operation at St Stephen's Green and Temple Bar in the first week of September, Dublin City Council has confirmed. Within weeks of the compactors going live, businesses and residents on 90 streets in the south inner city will be permanently banned from leaving rubbish bags at the kerbside for collection. The council described the move as a 'massive change to waste management in the city', adding that it was 'probably the most significant' in many years. Legislation requiring the use of bins instead of refuse sacks came into force in 2016 but thousands of Dublin residents and businesses were given a derogation from the rules because their properties were unsuitable for wheelie bins. READ MORE Streets in the city centre, or inner suburbs with no gardens or no direct back access, were mostly affected. However, the council has long sought to rid the city of plastic waste sacks which are frequently torn apart before collection by seagulls, vermin, and household pets, resulting in litter strewn streets. The problem was exacerbated, the council said, by the introduction of the deposit return scheme which resulted in people deliberately ripping open bags seeking bottles and cans to retrieve cash deposits at return machines. The council at the beginning of last September announced plans to ban the use of refuse bags on 90 streets in the south inner city from January 1st. [ Dublin's dumpers have 'no sense of pride', says council waste chief Opens in new window ] Customers are being issued with fobs/ cards by their waste companies to allow them to use the compactors, the council said The four-month stay would allow waste collection companies three months to switch customers to bins where possible, or come up with alternative collection services, the council said. However, by the start of this year only 35 per cent of customers had moved from using bags to wheelie bins, though some companies had established direct collection services, where customers can arrange a time to meet bin lorries and hand over their sacks so they don't sit on the street. The council agreed to the installation of large municipal waste compactors for use by businesses and residents where alternatives were not practical. The compactors were due to be in place last March, but due to a number of requirements for their installation, including connections to the electricity network, the project was delayed. However these issues have now be resolved, the council said. 'All required works are scheduled to be completed by the end of this month and it is therefore expected that they will be fully operational in the first week of September.' Two compactors, approximately 5m long and nearly 2.5m tall, are being installed, one at the top of Grafton Street at St Stephen's Green, and the other on Fownes Street, down the side of the former central bank building in Temple Bar. Businesses and residents on 90 streets in the south inner city will be permanently banned from leaving rubbish bags at the kerbside for collection. Photograph: Kinga Krzeminska/ Getty Images Customers are being issued with fobs/ cards by their waste companies to allow them to use the compactors, the council said. The containers are sealed, it said, and the waste drum can only be opened by those with access cards and codes, and will not be available to the general public. Staff from the companies 'will also be on site for a period of time once the system goes live to show customers how the compactor units operate' the council said. Once the system is operating satisfactorily, the council said it will move to implement a similar bag ban on the northside of the city.
