Supreme Court of Canada weighs appeal application from Via Rail terror case
OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada is set to decide Thursday whether to hear the appeal of Raed Jaser, who was convicted of planning to commit murder for the benefit of a terrorist group.
It's the latest chapter in a long-running legal saga that began 12 years ago with charges against Jaser and Chiheb Esseghaier for plotting attacks, including the planned sabotage of a Via Rail passenger train.
The Crown alleged that Jaser and Esseghaier had agreed to kill Canadian citizens to force Canada to remove its military troops from Afghanistan.
The Crown's evidence consisted mainly of intercepted communications and the testimony of an undercover U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation agent assigned to befriend Esseghaier.
A jury could not reach a verdict for Jaser on the rail plot charge but found him guilty of three other terrorism-related offences: one count of conspiring to commit murder for the benefit of a terrorist group and two counts of participating in the activities of a terrorist group. Esseghaier was found guilty on all counts.
The two men appealed their convictions. Counsel for Jaser and a court-appointed lawyer for Esseghaier argued the jury at the trial was improperly constituted.
In August 2019, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a fresh trial for the men on the grounds that the jury was chosen incorrectly.
The Crown successfully argued in a subsequent Supreme Court hearing that the convictions should not be overturned on the basis of an error in the jury-selection process that did not deny the men fair trial rights.
With the jury issue settled, the top court remitted the case to the Ontario Court of Appeal to deal with the men's outstanding challenges of their convictions.
While Esseghaier abandoned his appeal, Jaser persisted.
Last year, the Court of Appeal dismissed Jaser's challenge of his conviction and life sentence, prompting him to seek a fresh hearing at the Supreme Court.
In a written submission to the top court to request a hearing, Jaser's lawyers say there is disagreement across Canada about how to instruct juries in conspiracy cases — a problem they say the court should address.
'Jury instructions on the law of conspiracy are too complex,' the brief says. 'The facts of the proposed appeal present this Court with an ideal opportunity to guide trial judges on simplifying and distilling their instructions.'
Jaser's lawyers also raise questions about the application of the Canada Evidence Act concerning sensitive information and whether 'entrapment-like conduct' should be taken into account upon sentencing.
In a response to the Supreme Court, the Crown says Jaser's application should be dismissed.
'These issues are not novel and were properly rejected by the Court of Appeal,' the Crown's submission says. 'Although the facts giving rise to them are unique, they are specific to the circumstances of the applicant and do not raise any issue of public importance.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 6, 2025.
Jim Bronskill, The Canadian Press
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Lester B. Pearson School Board to join budget- cut lawsuit against Quebec government
Another English Montreal school board has joined a lawsuit against the Quebec government over budget cuts in education. The Lester B. Pearson School Board (LBPSB) is the latest to join the Quebec English School Board (QESBA)'s legal challenge after a unanimous vote Thursday night. It threatened to sue the province in late July, and the English Montreal School Board (EMSB) voted to take part on Monday. QESBA is challenging Quebec's education budgetary rules and wants them stayed. Last June, LBPSB's Council of Commissioners also adopted a resolution calling on Quebec to reverse cuts. The province is demanding its education network slash a total of $567.7 million from the 2025-2026 fiscal year: English school boards and French-language service centres were asked to cut $510.8 million, and private schools an additional $56.9 million. The school boards taking part in the lawsuit say the budget measures imposed on the entire education system are 'unreasonable and unworkable,' preventing them from presenting balanced budgets. 'As minority language school boards in Canada, English school boards are entitled to specific rights — including the authority to manage and allocate resources in ways that best serve our communities,' said the LBPSB in a news release. LBPSB Chairperson Judy Kelley says the nine English school boards under QESBA were looking at how it could be beneficial for them to join the lawsuit separately as they are all uniquely affected. She says schools are still in the process of budget correcting after the announced cuts, followed by Education Minister Bernard Drainville reinvesting some $540 million into the system, with strings attached. 'There's very specific attachments to how we can use that money. It's a real juggling act to see if you can counter some of the original budgetary regulations and rules with the new money or not,' she told CTV News. She pushed back against Drainville saying the government has increased its spending in education in its provincial budget, saying the reality is more complex. For example, teachers signed a new collective agreement that enshrined salary increases so labour is more expensive, on top of inflation. School boards also manage buildings, handle maintenance, provide services for students in school, transportation, and more. 'Imagine in all the costs in running a school board. It's not just about paying a teacher's salary to be in a classroom,' she said. 'There's so much that goes on and, in every area, costs have risen, and the funds given do not begin to match what the costs are.' Kelley stresses that all budget compressions affect student services in one way or another. The school board is confident Quebec's courts will side with them in a timely decision 'that safeguards the future of [its] students.'
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Man robbed 2 Edmonton convenience stores at knifepoint in July: police
The Edmonton Police Service says this man robbed two Edmonton convenience stores at knife-point in July 2025. (Credit: Edmonton Police Service) Police are looking for a man they say committed two armed robberies at west Edmonton convenience stores last month. The first robbery happened at 3:45 a.m. on July 23. According to an Edmonton Police Service news release, a man armed with a kitchen knife robbed the 7-Eleven store at 107 Avenue and 156 Street before running from the scene. On July 28 at 3:30 a.m., police say the same man, still armed with a kitchen knife, robbed the 7-Eleven at 95 Avenue and 156 Street. No injuries were reported in either incident. The man is described as 40 to 50 years old and was wearing dark-framed glasses and a grey hoodie with a yellow or beige skull logo on the back. He was also wearing grey pants, dark shoes, dark gloves, and carrying a knife. Anyone who can identify the man is asked to contact EPS at 780-423-4567 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477.
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Community calls for stronger transit safety measures after Muslim teen attacked on Ottawa bus
A Muslim teenager was attacked earlier this week while riding an OC Transpo bus in Kanata, an incident community leaders say is sparking renewed concern over public safety on Ottawa's transit system. Witnesses say the teen, who was wearing a hijab, was confronted with Islamophobic slurs and threats and was assaulted by another passenger. The teen suffered minor injuries but Sikander Hashmi, an Imam with the Kanata Muslim Association, says the emotional impact has rippled through the community. 'When an incident like this occurs, and especially when it involves hateful comments, Islamophobic slurs and physical assault plus threats, then that can be extremely concerning and cause quite a bit of fear, as you can imagine in the community,' Hashmi says. OC Transpo public safety officer Sabrina Pasmi condemned the act of violence, adding they're committed to ensuring all riders feel safe on every route. 'Safety is always the top priority. Always. Every day,' Pasmi says. 'It's what our staff are trained to do first and foremost and we have staff throughout the network all the time. I want to just reiterate that there is always someone there… customers are never alone.' The transit agency encourages passengers to signal the driver, use on-board emergency buttons, or contact Transit Special Constable if they feel unsafe. OC Transpo passenger assistance Examples of passenger assistance buttons that can be found on OC Transpo buses. (OC Transpo) 'It is a public space, so things can happen in any public space anywhere in the city, and all we can do is to encourage people to report anything that they see,' Pasmi adds. 'If they don't feel comfortable reporting something in the moment, they can also go on our website after the fact and submit an anonymous report with anything they might have witnessed.' Ottawa Mayor Mark Sutcliffe says he spoke with the family of the victim shortly after the attack and says incidents like this are unacceptable and require a united response. 'it's really important to send a strong message to the community that we value the members of the Muslim community that we are aware of the rising incidents of Islamophobia, rising incidents of hatred throughout the community, and that we won't accept that,' Sutcliffe says. 'As leaders in the community, we will push back against that, we will do everything we can to keep our residents safe and to make Ottawa a place that is free from hatred.' The Kanata Muslim Association is hosting community solidarity gathering in response to the assault at OC Transpo Innovation Drive Park & Ride in Kanata from 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. Friday. According to Hashmi, the event will show solidarity, reject hate, and call for safer public transit. 'This is an issue that is not specific to the Muslim community, of course, this attack was Islamophobic in nature, but public safety on transit, is, I believe, a real concern to all citizens of the city,' Hashmi says. 'It's an opportunity for us to get together for all of the above.'
