HC terms Pune man's arrest illegal over 48-hour delay in court production
A division bench of justice Mahesh Sonak and justice Valmiki Menezes ruled on Friday that Hanumant Nazirkar's arrest, though formally recorded much later, effectively began at 1pm on October 25, 2024, when Baramati police picked him up from Pune's Shivajinagar metro station.
Nazirkar and his wife had been booked by the Baramati Taluka police in connection with a March 3, 2023 complaint accusing them and others of cheating the complainant of ₹ 3.37 crore. His plea for anticipatory bail had been earlier rejected.
While police formally recorded his arrest only at 9pm on October 26, he was produced before a magistrate around 12.20pm on October 27 — nearly 48 hours after being apprehended. Nazirkar moved the high court challenging the legality of this delay, citing Article 22 of the Constitution and Section 57 of the Criminal Procedure Code, both of which require a person taken into custody to be presented before a magistrate within 24 hours.
The government's counsel argued that Nazirkar was not under arrest during this period, claiming he was being medically evaluated — first referred from Baramati to Sassoon Hospital in Pune, but ultimately admitted to a private hospital in Baramati shortly after midnight and discharged only on the evening of October 27. They pointed out that Nazirkar's son was with him and that he had remained in touch with his family over the phone.
The court, however, rejected this line of defence. 'The arrest commences with the restraint placed on the liberty of the person and not with the time of arrest recorded by the arresting officer,' the bench said. 'The test is whether a person has been deprived of their liberty to go where they please.'
The judges observed that once Nazirkar was apprehended by police, his liberty was curtailed — making it an arrest in the eyes of the law. They held that relying on the 'pre-arrest medical examination' argument to bypass the 24-hour rule would defeat the purpose of constitutional protection and could encourage abuse of power.
'There is no legal provision that allows exclusion of time for medical examinations prior to arrest. Such police conduct could lead to unscrupulous tendencies,' the court noted, terming the arrest illegal.
Nazirkar was ordered to be released on bail upon furnishing a personal bond of ₹ 1 lakh and one or more sureties in the same amount.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nirbhay Morning Walk in Kolhapur marks Dabholkar death anniversary, calls for action against superstition
Kolhapur: Young rationalists in Kolhapur city organised the 'Nirbhay Morning Walk' on the 12th death anniversary of Narendra Dabholkar, chanting "Narendra Dabholkar Amar Rahe" on Wednesday. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The walk commenced at Bindu Chowk, proceeded to Shivaji Chowk, CPR Chowk, Dasara Chowk, and returned to Bindu Chowk. Narendra Dabholkar, the founder of Maharashtra Andhshraddha Nirmulan Samiti, an anti-superstition forum, was murdered in Pune on this day in 2013. In May 2024, Pune's special court convicted two people for Dabholkar's murder. However, activists argue that the masterminds behind the killings remain at large. Krushnat Swati, an activist, said, "The two accused were held guilty. However, state govt has not made efforts to challenge the acquittals of three other accused people. There is no effort on the part of the investigation to reach out to the masterminds of the murders of Dabholkar and Govind Pansare." Activists have called for the law criminalising superstition to be implemented nationwide and for the Maharashtra law, enacted following Dabholkar's death, to be reinforced. The youths committed to following a rationalist path, rejecting superstition, and pledged to continue Dabholkar's work. They also chanted the victory of the Constitution of India during the walk. One participant said, "The Constitution clearly defines that the state, that is, govt machinery, should take steps to create awareness of scientific thoughts; however, it rarely happens, and the responsibility comes upon us to take the thought forward. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now " In Sangli, a delegation of activists met with the district administration to present a petition demanding that the CBI expedite its efforts to challenge the acquittals in the Dabholkar murder case. Additionally, at various locations, Dabholkar's books were sold at half the regular price.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
US citizen residing in Mumbai cheated of 2.7cr, sr bank mngr to be booked
Mumbai: After HC expressed shock over conduct of investigation officer, the state told the Bombay high court it will book a senior manager of Kotak Mahindra Bank in a case where an American citizen (75), who resides in Mumbai and is married to an Indian, was allegedly cheated of nearly Rs 2.7 crore by her relationship manager. Justices Ravindra Ghuge and Gautam Ankhad, on Aug 13, noted that police inspector Sachin Khondre, who registered the FIR narrating Elizabeth Iler's complaint, did not add Sainath Gharse as accused. Iler, retired professor of a New York university, sought direction to D N Nagar police to add IPC Section 409 (criminal breach of trust by a banker) to the FIR and for speedy probe against relationship manager Radheya Waghole, his wife Bhavana and others involved. Her petition said she holds NRE and NRO accounts with Kotak Bank's JVPD branch. Waghole, having access to her finance details and foreign remittances, "manipulated" her into transferring substantial funds under the pretext of secure, bank-approved investments promising high returns. He introduced Bhavana as a financial adviser. They lured her into investing through their two companies. Iler was made to sign blank beneficiary owner forms and share OTPs and digital authorisations. Amounts were transferred to third party entities and their companies. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai | Gold Rates Today in Mumbai | Silver Rates Today in Mumbai While Iler filed a police complaint on March 3, the FIR was registered on July 9 without Section 409. Her advocate Himanshu Maratkar said as bank officials were involved, the section should have been invoked. The judges said, on perusal of the FIR's contents, prima facie Section 409 is attracted. Iler's complaint indicated a "deceptive role" played by Gharse. He convinced her that depositing the money with Waghole "involved no risk as he is his colleague." Prosecutor Shreekant Gavand said the IO was instructed by the law officer not to invoke Section 409. The zonal DCP concurred with the opinion. Hence, Gharse's name was not mentioned as an accused. "Our judicial conscience is shocked. While four long paragraphs of the complaint clearly indicate the role of Gharse, yet, he has not been added as an accused,'' the judges said. Gavand said while adding Section 409, Gharse will also be added as an accused. The judge disposed of Iler's petition but kept it on Sept 2, to report compliance of the directions. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Disturbing that Catholic religious being targeted: Church magazine
Panaji: The archdiocese of Goa and Daman, in the latest issue of its bulletin, 'Renovacao', has stated that it is extremely disturbing and hurtful that priests, nuns, and law-abiding faithful who selflessly contribute towards the civilised social fabric of the country are targeted as being unconstitutional and unlawful. 'It is still surprising that the Church in India, despite the backing of Articles 25 to 28 of the Constitution, never made attempts to convert anyone by illegitimate means. It is much more astounding that those who studied in Catholic/Christian educational institutions and benefited from Catholic/Christian medical institutions, are conniving with the anti-Christian groups,' stated the editorial, 'Justice the foundation of a civilised society'. 'It is still more frightening that the selfless services rendered by Christian organisations towards those where no other organisation or community dares to tread are confused with human trafficking and against the anti-conversion laws,' the editorial added. The bulletin went on to state that the Christian community in India, and especially the Catholic Church, contributed tremendously to maintaining and exercising the principles of justice, thereby promoting the sustainability of a civilised society. 'Despite being a negligible minority in terms of numbers, the Catholic Church contributed tremendously in the fields of education, medicine, hygiene, and social upliftment, irrespective of creed, region, language, and culture,' it stated, adding that the Church always upholds the principles of justice and works towards the foundation of a just and civilised society despite being mistakenly misunderstood and harassed. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
