Campaigner hits out at 'PR trick' nuclear energy poll of SNP members
Robin McAlpine, founder of pro-independence think tank Common Weal, has branded the polling a "PR trick based on deliberately withholding crucial information", claiming people who responded were not given "the basic facts".
Polling for the campaign group Britain Remade, founded by a former energy adviser to Boris Johnson, found 52% of those who voted for the party in 2021 believe nuclear power should be included in Scotland's energy mix to meet the 2045 net zero target.
Meanwhile, 57% of those who voted for the party in last year's general election felt the same way, the poll found.
READ MORE: Nigel Farage says he 'doesn't want' NHS to be publicly funded
A total of 56% of Scots thought nuclear power should be part of Scotland's clean energy mix to meet the targets, while 23% disagreed, and 21% said they did not know.
Opinium surveyed 1000 Scottish adults between April 22 and 25.
However, McAlpine argues those quizzed on the topic were not aware of key points as laid out in a blog post for pro-independence Common Weal Common Weal.
He highlights the price of hydrogen electricity being cheaper than nuclear, as well as the hidden costs of building and decommissioning nuclear infrastructure.
"Would SNP voters back nuclear if it was explained that it will cost them three times as much as renewables and then also cost nearly £5000 per household just to clean them up?" McAlpine told The National.
READ MORE: Warning as 100,000 Scots face disruption and higher bills over meter switch off
He further questioned: "Do people know that it is much cheaper to run a renewable system with battery storage for short-term load balancing and hydrogen storage for long term battery storage? Are they aware that you can't turn nuclear power on and off and that it has to run at full power all the time? So it can't balance renewables when the wind isn't blowing, it can only displace renewables from the grid.
"The only conceivable purpose of nuclear in Britain is to power the south of England. Look at Fukushima, look at the power stations in Ukraine, how much risk do you want to take when you have absolutely no need to do it?
"If people are told 'more expensive, much more dangerous, can't be switched up or down or turned off, costs an absolute fortune to decommission at the end', I think you'll find they answer differently."
The SNP have argued nuclear power projects remain too expensive to be a viable alternative to renewable power.
READ MORE: UK wants to build new nuclear plants in Scotland, Ed Miliband says
Responding to the polling, SNP MSP Bill Kidd said: 'Our focus is delivering a just transition that supports communities and creates long-term economic opportunities to build a truly sustainable future.
'Nuclear remains one of the most costly forms of energy with projects like Hinkley Point C running billions over budget and years behind schedule.
'In contrast, Scotland's net zero transition is already delivering thousands of green jobs across energy, construction, innovation, and engineering. This number will continue to grow.
'Simply, renewables are cheaper to produce and develop, create more jobs, and are safer than nuclear as they don't leave behind radioactive waste that will be deadly for generations.
'While Labour funnels billions into slow, centralised projects, the SNP is focused on creating real, sustainable jobs in Scotland now.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
29 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Zia Yusuf didn't leave Reform because he was a victim of racism
Zia Yusuf was billed by some as one of the rising stars of British politics – so his abrupt resignation as chairman of Reform UK has created quite a splash. Wading in with his typical opportunistic identitarianism, former leader of the SNP, Humza Yousaf, said on X that Yusuf's departure from Reform should serve as an example to all 'people of colour' – that the 'hard-right' would never accept them, even if they make sizeable financial donations. He added that it was no surprise that the insurgent challenger party of the Right eventually dispensed with their 'brown, son-of-an-immigrant, Muslim' party chairman. While there have been reports of Yusuf being sidelined within Reform for some time, the straw that broke the camel's back appears to be a disagreement between him and the party's newest MP, Sarah Pochin. In PMQs, the recently elected MP for Runcorn and Helsby asked Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer whether he would entertain the possibility of introducing restrictions on the wearing of the burqa in the UK. Yusuf seemingly took issue with this by publicly rebuking Pochin on X. He said it was 'dumb' to argue for measures which were not official Reform policy. The writing was on the wall for Yusuf after the spat with Pochin. She is Reform's first female MP, and insulting her in public over a question in the Commons about banning the burqa – being a Muslim man – was political self-destruction and contradicted his own emphasis on 'professionalising' the party. The question itself was an entirely reasonable one. Morocco – a predominantly Muslim country where Sunni Islam is the state religion – banned the manufacturing, marketing, and sale of the burqa back in 2017. This was on the grounds of security considerations and part of a broader approach to combat Salafist influences in the North African country. If Yusuf was disappointed that certain procedures should have been followed by Pochin, this should have been discussed in private and he should have raised the importance of party discipline and order as chairman. This would have been responsible and professional chairmanship. While there is no doubt that Yusuf suffered a great amount of racist and anti-Muslim abuse from what the Reform leader has labelled 'alt-right' trolls, a more plausible explanation for Yusuf's resignation is that he found the transition from business to politics difficult – and understandably so. In the world of business, he is unquestionably successful: he co-founded a luxury concierge company which was later sold to Capital One in a £233 million deal. But chairing a fledgling political party requires a greater degree of patience – especially when it comes to instilling organisational discipline and order as part of a broader professionalisation strategy. Whether it was restlessness, disillusionment, or clashing with other personalities, Yusuf the businessman had clearly grown frustrated in his political role. And nobody can blame him for that. While the likes of Humza Yousaf would love nothing more than to portray Zia Yusuf as a non-white Muslim victim of ethno-nationalist persecution, the reality is far more complicated.
Scotsman
30 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Hamilton by-election: Keir Starmer, Reform chief and Kemi Badenoch react to 'remarkable' vote result
The Hamilton by-election result was a major boost for Labour - and prompted a congratulatory post from Sir Keir Starmer. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Sir Keir Starmer has claimed people in Scotland have 'voted for change' following Labour's shock win in the Hamilton by-election. The Prime Minister congratulated Labour's new MSP Davy Russell and looked ahead to next year's Scottish Parliament election, describing the poll as a chance to 'turbo-charge delivery'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scottish Labour candidate Davy Wilson arrives at a polling station to cast his vote | Getty Images Mr Russell took the seat vacated by the death of Scottish Government minister and SNP MSP Christina McKelvie. Posting on social media on Friday morning, Sir Keir said: 'People in Scotland have once again voted for change. Next year there is a chance to turbo-charge delivery by putting Labour in power on both sides of the border. 'I look forward to working with you.' Labour's candidate, who is the deputy lord lieutenant of Lanarkshire, beat the SNP's Katy Loudon, who fell to her third defeat since 2023. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad When the votes were counted, Mr Russell polled 8,559, Ms Loudon took 7,957 votes, and Reform's Ross Lambie secured 7,088. Kemi Badenoch's party came in fourth | Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire The win comes against the backdrop of national polls which position Scottish Labour in third place behind the SNP and Reform UK – and will undoubtedly give a boost to Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar's bid to become first minister at next year's election. Responding to the result, SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn congratulated Mr Russell. Writing on social media, he said: 'Congratulations must go to Davy Russell - I'm sure that was an incredible moment for both himself and his family. 'And commiserations to Katy Loudon. A wonderful person and candidate who has given her all for our party and movement.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Much of the Hamilton campaign had been dominated by a Reform UK advert – branded 'racist' by Labour and others – which had alleged Mr Sarwar would 'prioritise' the Pakistani community. A surge in support for Nigel Farage's party saw Reform come in third place in Hamilton, just 800 votes behind the SNP – although there had been speculation Reform could come second or possibly even win the seat. Reform UK deputy leader Richard Tice insisted the party was 'delighted' with the result. Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, he said: 'It's truly remarkable. We've come from nowhere to being in a three-way marginal, and we're within 750 votes of winning that by-election and just a few hundred votes of defeating the SNP, so it's an incredible result.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad At a press conference criticising the European Convention on Human Rights, Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said 'of course' the public are 'likely to be angry' with the Conservatives. Asked whether she thought it was too late to change the Conservative Party and how long she would give herself to turn things around, the Tory leader said: 'We have four more years of Labour ... what's our country going to look like then?
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Why Reform was the other big winner in the Hamilton by-election
The Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election is a surprise win for Labour - giving the party a much needed boost with eleven months to the full Scottish Parliament the other big winner was Reform UK who finished third behind the recorded their best ever parliamentary election result in Scotland - with a 26% share of the John Swinney is to remain as Scotland's first minister, it seems he cannot rely on presenting the SNP as the only alternative to Nigel Farage and Reform UK. Follow reaction to Scottish Labour's by-election victory Both the SNP and Labour lost vote share in this by-election but the punishment for the SNP, in power at Holyrood for the last 18 years, was far repeatedly framed this contest as a two horse race between them and Reform UK. Their billboards in the constituency still make that claim. It was obviously reality, this was a three horse race that Labour won by a nose to take the seat from the SNP - which now has big questions to ask itself about its strategy for 2026. If Reform can do half as well in the contest next May, they can expect to have their first MSPs elected and gain a significant foothold at would break the traditional consensus that Scotland needs more immigration to fill job vacancies and offset the effects of an ageing established parties acknowledge that concerns about immigration featured in this by-election in a way they have not biggest losers in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse are the Conservatives who finished a distant fourth and appear to be struggling to counter the rise of here is a significant setback for the Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay and offers no encouragement to Kemi Badenoch and the UK party. This is also not a victory that Sir Keir Starmer can really claim as his own. Labour said in recent days that they had identified enough support to beat the SNP and it seems a successful ground operation got those voters to Starmer's popularity in Scotland has plummeted since he swept to power last summer, heavily defeating the like cutting winter fuel payments for pensioners seem to have harmed his standing and that policy is to be revised, perhaps as early as next prime minister made no appearance in the campaign despite announcing the strategic defence review in Glasgow on Monday. Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has acknowledged public discontent with the UK Labour said that voters had made clear their frustrations and that Sir Keir Starmer must now go further and faster in delivering the economic change he promised at the general by-election outcome alters the prevailing narrative in Scottish defeating the SNP across much of the central belt of Scotland last summer, Labour has lost opinion polling has them heavily trailing the SNP in Holyrood voting intentions. This by-election result runs counter to that trend, albeit that it is a localised win on a low turnout. Voters consistently told anyone who would listen that they were fed up with politicians of all stripes, not least those in power at Holyrood and next May's election, John Swinney hopes to be able to demonstrate improvements in public services like the NHS. And labour will argue the nationalists have already had too long and that a change of government is by-election has restored some confidence in Scottish Labour and reminded the SNP that they can take nothing for granted. But it has put all parties on notice that Reform UK could - for the first time - be a significant force in Scottish politics.
