
SNP need two distinct arms in order to achieve their twin objectives
Yes, we have explored the currently available constitutional options and now realise that Westminster is highly unlikely to consent to a fully lawful referendum on the basis they are afraid of losing.
What the activists have lost sight of is that in 2014 we had a parliamentary majority for the agreed democratic mandate for holding a referendum. Since then we have not. That majority didn't exist before 2014 and Westminster has not consented to one since on the basis that in Holyrood we didn't gain another single-party majority.
READ MORE: Scottish Government responds to claims of 'Iranian pro-independence accounts'
Holding a constitutionally unlawful referendum is not as easy as it appears. The practicalities of doing so are immense. Who would pay for it, who would validate the result, who would accept the result?
Who would actually participate? If nothing else, how can it claim any authority, as the arch-Unionists will almost certainly not take part, and being 'unlawful' it cannot be implemented?
The only real way of demonstrating our demands is to keep returning a majority of MPs to Westminster and regain a single-party majority at Holyrood. The voted-on mandate must have a commitment to hold a single-question referendum, not just a statement of intent about independence.
The other problem would be if a Section 35 order is issued preventing us from running that. The question is of course how would that be enforced, and the most likely way is for the Scotland Act to be suspended, thereby removing all powers from Holyrood and probably preventing it from sitting.
READ MORE: Seamus Logan: Using an election as plebiscite referendum is just not going to fly
That leaves a huge conundrum, as clearly Westminster would have to appoint commissioners to run our affairs, back to the old days of the Scottish Office!
In effect, trying to hold an unconstitutional referendum would be the cessation of devolution, forcing us back to square one. So, we have to demonstrate and continue to demonstrate a majority, preferably rising, in favour of independence. No arguing amongst ourselves, or undermining each other.
The grassroots have already started the process at the UN, and we have friends in other countries. The grassroots can do the door-knocking and one-to-one persuasion and dissemination in the absence of a friendly media, but they are currently more or less on their own.
This does introduce another difficulty as the SNP do need to meet two different challenges, – on a day-to-day basis running the country within the confines of the UK constitution, important as it is, but at the same time taking a lead in the strategic goal.
Our current political leaders, while impassioned and competent, do not have the spare time to take on another important role. So for political credibility we need two arms within the SNP: the first is ongoing political administration, and the second is that of galvanising indy supporters, but not using elected politicians to front it.
The principal role of this arm will be to give the non-aligned majority of voters something for them to understand, and achieve buy-in. Not just the ideal and fuzzy concept of independence, but the pragmatic understanding of how that would work and how our economy would be placed To this end we need to offer those voters a (draft) constitution that spells out limits and powers of whoever forms our government along with a draft budget using all of our GDP, to sit in comparison with the one limited by our current constitutional arrangement. Produce something that ordinary voters get their teeth into and forms a prospectus for a new and independent Scotland.
Nick Cole
Meigle, Perthshire
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Trump reveals what mystery trucks at nuke site were REALLY doing before blitz… destroying claims Iran rushed uranium out
URANIUM DELIRIUM Trump reveals what mystery trucks at nuke site were REALLY doing before blitz… destroying claims Iran rushed uranium out DONALD Trump has revealed what the mystery trucks at Iran's Fordow nuke plant were doing there before he blitzed the base. Satellite pictures captured the lorries at the underground bunker complex just hours before the US hammered it with B-2 stealth bombers in the "historically successful" Operation Midnight Hammer. 4 The Fordow plant before and after the the US bombed the site Credit: Reuters 4 The moment the missile hit the earth in the test footage 4 Trucks at the plant on June 19 - days before the US bombed it Credit: Getty 4 Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Air Force Gen. Dan Caine give a briefing on Operation Midnight Hammer Credit: Getty Some had speculated online those workers had been trying to remove the enriched uranium from the base. But Trump has posted on social media after a Pentagon briefing today and said the trucks were concrete workers. Iranian workers had desperately tried to cover the vents of the complex in concrete in the hours before the US bombed. The bunker buster bombs hit their targets just hours later and flew down the shafts and obliterated the facility. Trump said: "The cars and small trucks at the site were those of concrete workers trying to cover up the top of the shafts. "Nothing was taken out of facility. Would take too long, too dangerous, and very heavy and hard to move!" Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth revealed the Iranian's desperate attempts during the briefing held with Dan "Raizin" Caine, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Caine talked through previously unseen footage of the 30,000lb GBU-57 "bunker buster" weapon being tested. One of the bombs can be seen in slo-mo hitting a dirt target, travelling through a thick layer of earth, and then exploding in a cavity below it in the new footage. The footage came as part of the administration's efforts to prove Operation Midnight Hammer blitz on Fordow "obliterated" the plant. Caine also revealed information about the planning for the mission including that one person in the Defence Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA) had been solely studying the underground bunker complex for 15 years. That person, whose identity is classified, had effectively been able give a design of the base for the Air Force to then design a mission around. Caine said that the 30,000lb bombs had been designed with Iran's nuclear program in mind and from studying Fordow. He said: "The weapons were designed, planned, and delivered to achieve the objections in the mission space." Developing the bomb had, at one point, been using the most supercomputer hours in the United States. Caine said he didn't have intelligence on the damage, but could confirm the bombs had released properly, hit their target, and exploded. One of the pilots told Caine after the mission: "This is the brightest explosion I have ever seen, it literally looked like daylight". The Pentagon briefing on the operation came just hours after Iran's fanatical supreme leader broke his silence after not being seen in a week. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, 86, claimed victory over Israel and America despite his country being hammered in the "12 Day War". Khamenei is hiding away in a bunker deep below ground despite the ceasefire as he fears being assassinated by secret agents, the New York Times reports. The supreme leader was seen in a video sitting in front of the same brown curtain - presumably still cowardly hiding in his bunker - as he had last week. On Israel, he ludicrously claimed Iran had almost crushed the country and the government in Tel Aviv was on the verge of collapse. That's despite the IDF controlling the skies over Tehran, assassinating dozens of top generals and nuclear scientists, and destroying dozens of valuable missile batteries in just 12 days of fighting. On America, Khamenei claimed to have given the country a "severe slap" to its face and that it had "gained nothing" from the attack on Iran's nuke plants. The Ayatollah said: 'The American regime entered a direct war because it felt that if it did not, the Zionist regime would be completely destroyed. "However, it gained no achievements from this war. 'Here, too, the Islamic Republic emerged victorious, and in return, the Islamic Republic delivered a severe slap to America's face.' Khamenei also bizarrely claimed his rockets had hit the American's Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar, despite his forces giving advanced warning so the rockets could be all shot down. The supreme leader was last seen a week ago in a video message, but it's two weeks since he appeared to his people in the flesh. Stay up to date with the latest on Israel vs Iran with The Sun's live blog below...


Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Question Time sees woman share 10-year health battle in debate on 'failing' NHS
Question Time on BBC One tonight featured a debate around the NHS in Scotland and how one in three people are turning to private healtcare due to long waiting lists A woman described how she felt she was "failed" by the NHS on two separate occasions in a poignant moment on tonight's Question Time. This week's debate took place in St Andrews in Fife, Scotland with host Fiona Bruce sitting on the panel alongside Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP, Anas Sarwar MSP, Andrew Bowie MP, Thomas Kerr and Lesley Riddoch. A large part of the BBC show tonight was centered around whether Scotland's NHS is "dying before our eyes". Anas Sarwar, leader Scottish labour highlighted how one in three people are forced to go private for healthcare and one audience member explained how she was part of that shocking statistic. The female audience member asked, "I'd just be interested to know how you measure the improvements that you're seeing in the NHS if you're saying that the waiting lists are going down? Is it not just because more people are going private? Just today I was getting a private surgery having been failed by the NHS twice." The woman, who did not disclose the nature of the surgery she needed, went on to explain how she was forced to turn to private healthcare after being "failed" by the NHS on two separate occasions. She added: "I first got this looked at nearly 10 years ago by an NHS specialist dermatologist who didn't think there was anything to be concerned about, I followed up again a year ago, I was told the same thing and I'm not blaming these doctors who are very pushed for time, I work in healthcare myself but then I went to see a private doctor because I am fortunate to have the means to be able to pay for private health insurance and as soon as they saw it they immediately rushed me to have it removed. But I firmly believe that healthcare should be accessible to everyone and it should be equal, but I've kind of been forced into this situation where I don't want to deny myself the healthcare that I can afford but it shouldn't be at the expense of others." In response Thomas Kerr, representing Reform UK, explained "too many people are going private," and said "the NHS isn't working in it's current system, it does have to be looked into and it does have to be reformed". He added: "Just throwing money at it doesn't work, we've seen that time and time again, we've had record funding in th NHS that is still not working for people on the ground." When asked by Fiona if he supported the idea of a mixed economy like the French system he added: "As long as healthcare is free at the point of need for anyone who needs it then I don't mind where someone gets their healthcare at all. If you can afford it and you want to pay it privately then that's entirely up to a person individually." He went on to address the problem in Scotland of the number of doctors leaving the NHS, he said: "We have a higher tax system in Scotland which is making people who are learning in our universities like here in St Andrews are then leaving to go down to England or to go travel abroad, I think we have to look at the tax system in Scotland to make sure it is fair to try and keep our home grown talent here to make sure the NHS works." Mr Kerr was then grilled about Brexit by broadcaster and commentator Lesley Riddoch. She said: "Right Thomas, what happened to the £380m quid a week we were going to get from Brexit?" She went on to say: "We've got a bit of a mess going on with healthcare here, we've got a static life expectancy which is shameful given the amount of wealth there is in this country and overall our health is not great." Question Time has now finished for the summer, it will be back on our screens in September.


Times
2 hours ago
- Times
I've never been to Iran. Why has the crisis left me in despair?
I've spent the past two weeks glued to my phone. Not reading the news — inhaling it. Comment sections, maps, Telegram channels, satellite images, video essays of analysis and speculation. It's compulsive and nauseating, and I can't stop. Iran is under threat of war again, and I feel like I can't breathe. I'm half Iranian. My father left Iran in the 1960s, long before the revolution, not as a refugee, but simply as a young man who wanted to live somewhere else. The way I moved to London in my twenties, he moved to Europe in his. Growing up, Iran was always both close and just out of reach for me. My father made a life in Germany — he met my mother and raised my sister and I there, and kept us at a careful distance from the country he came from. There were practical reasons for this: under Iranian law, children of Iranian men are automatically citizens. We can't enter on tourist visas, can't renounce our citizenship — and in times of political instability dual nationals are at risk. He didn't want us to feel tethered to a country that could make life harder, a place that came with political baggage and a passport we'd never be able to shake.