logo
SNP need two distinct arms in order to achieve their twin objectives

SNP need two distinct arms in order to achieve their twin objectives

The National5 hours ago

Yes, we have explored the currently available constitutional options and now realise that Westminster is highly unlikely to consent to a fully lawful referendum on the basis they are afraid of losing.
What the activists have lost sight of is that in 2014 we had a parliamentary majority for the agreed democratic mandate for holding a referendum. Since then we have not. That majority didn't exist before 2014 and Westminster has not consented to one since on the basis that in Holyrood we didn't gain another single-party majority.
READ MORE: Scottish Government responds to claims of 'Iranian pro-independence accounts'
Holding a constitutionally unlawful referendum is not as easy as it appears. The practicalities of doing so are immense. Who would pay for it, who would validate the result, who would accept the result?
Who would actually participate? If nothing else, how can it claim any authority, as the arch-Unionists will almost certainly not take part, and being 'unlawful' it cannot be implemented?
The only real way of demonstrating our demands is to keep returning a majority of MPs to Westminster and regain a single-party majority at Holyrood. The voted-on mandate must have a commitment to hold a single-question referendum, not just a statement of intent about independence.
The other problem would be if a Section 35 order is issued preventing us from running that. The question is of course how would that be enforced, and the most likely way is for the Scotland Act to be suspended, thereby removing all powers from Holyrood and probably preventing it from sitting.
READ MORE: Seamus Logan: Using an election as plebiscite referendum is just not going to fly
That leaves a huge conundrum, as clearly Westminster would have to appoint commissioners to run our affairs, back to the old days of the Scottish Office!
In effect, trying to hold an unconstitutional referendum would be the cessation of devolution, forcing us back to square one. So, we have to demonstrate and continue to demonstrate a majority, preferably rising, in favour of independence. No arguing amongst ourselves, or undermining each other.
The grassroots have already started the process at the UN, and we have friends in other countries. The grassroots can do the door-knocking and one-to-one persuasion and dissemination in the absence of a friendly media, but they are currently more or less on their own.
This does introduce another difficulty as the SNP do need to meet two different challenges, – on a day-to-day basis running the country within the confines of the UK constitution, important as it is, but at the same time taking a lead in the strategic goal.
Our current political leaders, while impassioned and competent, do not have the spare time to take on another important role. So for political credibility we need two arms within the SNP: the first is ongoing political administration, and the second is that of galvanising indy supporters, but not using elected politicians to front it.
The principal role of this arm will be to give the non-aligned majority of voters something for them to understand, and achieve buy-in. Not just the ideal and fuzzy concept of independence, but the pragmatic understanding of how that would work and how our economy would be placed To this end we need to offer those voters a (draft) constitution that spells out limits and powers of whoever forms our government along with a draft budget using all of our GDP, to sit in comparison with the one limited by our current constitutional arrangement. Produce something that ordinary voters get their teeth into and forms a prospectus for a new and independent Scotland.
Nick Cole
Meigle, Perthshire

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

CIA says Trump strikes will set back Iran's nuke programme by YEARS as White House calls for leaker to be JAILED
CIA says Trump strikes will set back Iran's nuke programme by YEARS as White House calls for leaker to be JAILED

Scottish Sun

time11 minutes ago

  • Scottish Sun

CIA says Trump strikes will set back Iran's nuke programme by YEARS as White House calls for leaker to be JAILED

Scroll down for the latest updates... BUNKER BUSTED CIA says Trump strikes will set back Iran's nuke programme by YEARS as White House calls for leaker to be JAILED THE CIA says Donald Trump's weekend blitz on Iran has left key nuclear sites 'destroyed' – in a devastating blow that will take 'years' to recover from. In a bombshell statement, the Agency's director John Ratcliffe confirmed 'several key Iranian nuclear facilities' were wiped out and must be completely rebuilt. 4 CIA Director John Ratcliffe pictured on March 25 Credit: Reuters 4 Craters on a ridge at the Fordow plant after US strikes Credit: EPA 4 US President Donald Trump during a press conference after the NATO summit at the World Forum The Hague Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 4 CIA chief Ratcliffe released this statement on his profile on X Credit: X 'The CIA can confirm that a body of credible intelligence indicates Iran's Nuclear Program has been severely damaged by the recent, targeted strikes,' Ratcliffe said. 'This includes new intelligence from a historically reliable and accurate source/method that several key Iranian nuclear facilities were destroyed and would have to be rebuilt over the course of years.' The chief added the CIA would 'provide updates to the American public' given the 'national importance' of the operation. It comes after White House called for the arrest of whoever leaked a classified intelligence report on Iran's nuclear sites — as Donald Trump demanded CNN's Natasha Bertrand be fired 'like a dog.' Speaking at a NATO summit press conference in The Hague, the president raged at 'fake news' outlets over reports suggesting US airstrikes failed to cripple Iran's nuke programme. Trump insisted Tehran's labs were now 'totally inoperable,' citing intelligence from both Israel and Iran confirming the scale of the devastation. The uproar followed reports from CNN, MSNBC, and The New York Times citing a leaked Defense Intelligence Agency memo that raised doubts over the extent of the damage — particularly at the Fordow nuclear site. The report was based on just 24 hours of data. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said the person responsible for leaking the classified Iran intelligence report should face jail time. 'They should go to jail,' she told Fox News' Ryan Schmelz when asked about potential punishment for the leaker. Leavitt said the DIA memo had been 'discredited' by U.S. and Israeli officials — and even by Iran itself. 'CNN ran with a story they knew wasn't fully vetted,' Leavitt told Fox News, calling it a leak from 'someone with an agenda' and noting it came from 'the same reporter who once pushed the false Hunter Biden laptop narrative.' She confirmed the FBI is investigating the leak and stressed that those responsible 'should be held accountable.' Defending the strikes, Leavitt said: 'This operation achieved what decades of diplomacy and sanctions could not.' Trump went on to slam the media outlets, saying: 'We had a tremendous success. 'And this is the New York Times. I call it the failing New York Times. It's going to hell. And CNN, which is, you know, very few people are watching, and you would think they'd do the opposite. 'So it's just fake news by CNN, which has got no ratings. It's a failed network,' he added. The president didn't hold back, declaring: 'CNN is scum, the New York Times is scum, MSNBC is scum. They're bad people, they're sick. And what they've done is they want to turn this incredible victory into something less.' Trump then unleashed on Bertrand in a furious Truth Social post: 'Natasha Bertrand should be FIRED from CNN! I watched her for three days doing Fake News… 'She should be IMMEDIATELY reprimanded, and then thrown out 'like a dog'... 'She lied on the Laptop from Hell Story, and now she lied on the Nuclear Sites Story… She should not be allowed to work at Fake News CNN... FIRE NATASHA!' Stay up to date with the latest on Israel vs Iran with The Sun's live blog below...

Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt
Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt

South Wales Guardian

time21 minutes ago

  • South Wales Guardian

Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt

Around 120 Labour MPs – including a reported 12 from Scotland – have put their names to an amendment which would block the welfare reform Bill. But on Wednesday, Mr Sarwar refused to say if he supported the reforms or the rebellion against them. When asked if he supports the Scottish MPs seeking to block the Bill at a live taping of the Holyrood Sources podcast in Edinburgh, the Scottish Labour leader said: 'My position has been quite consistent on the welfare reforms, which is I support the principle of reform. 'We have to look at the structural challenges that exist in our welfare system, even with the changes currently being proposed.' Mr Sarwar said there were 'many positives' in the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill, but added that there were 'still conversations to be had' about potential changes. Pushed again on whether he supports the rebellion, Mr Sarwar said: 'Conversations are ongoing, as you would expect. 'People are legitimately voicing their concerns, having those conversations.' Pressed again on his view on the potential revolt, Mr Sarwar added: 'We have to support the principle of reform. 'What those reforms look like has to be balanced and has to be fair.' Mr Sarwar stressed that he believed the best way out of poverty was through work, but said those who cannot work should be supported. The most controversial part of the plans will see the eligibility of the personal independence payment (Pip) in England and Wales be reduced in a bid to save £5 billion. Earlier on Wednesday, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner suggested that ministers were considering potential concessions to Labour MPs to stave off a rebellion. 'Those discussions are ongoing around making sure that the welfare reforms that we're bringing in support people into work who need that, and we're putting a huge amount of investment into doing that, but also protecting the most vulnerable,' she said in an interview with ITV's Peston programme.

Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt
Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt

North Wales Chronicle

time37 minutes ago

  • North Wales Chronicle

Sarwar dodges question on potential welfare reform revolt

Around 120 Labour MPs – including a reported 12 from Scotland – have put their names to an amendment which would block the welfare reform Bill. But on Wednesday, Mr Sarwar refused to say if he supported the reforms or the rebellion against them. When asked if he supports the Scottish MPs seeking to block the Bill at a live taping of the Holyrood Sources podcast in Edinburgh, the Scottish Labour leader said: 'My position has been quite consistent on the welfare reforms, which is I support the principle of reform. 'We have to look at the structural challenges that exist in our welfare system, even with the changes currently being proposed.' Mr Sarwar said there were 'many positives' in the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill, but added that there were 'still conversations to be had' about potential changes. Pushed again on whether he supports the rebellion, Mr Sarwar said: 'Conversations are ongoing, as you would expect. 'People are legitimately voicing their concerns, having those conversations.' Pressed again on his view on the potential revolt, Mr Sarwar added: 'We have to support the principle of reform. 'What those reforms look like has to be balanced and has to be fair.' Mr Sarwar stressed that he believed the best way out of poverty was through work, but said those who cannot work should be supported. The most controversial part of the plans will see the eligibility of the personal independence payment (Pip) in England and Wales be reduced in a bid to save £5 billion. Earlier on Wednesday, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner suggested that ministers were considering potential concessions to Labour MPs to stave off a rebellion. 'Those discussions are ongoing around making sure that the welfare reforms that we're bringing in support people into work who need that, and we're putting a huge amount of investment into doing that, but also protecting the most vulnerable,' she said in an interview with ITV's Peston programme.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store