Question Time sees woman share 10-year health battle in debate on 'failing' NHS
Question Time on BBC One tonight featured a debate around the NHS in Scotland and how one in three people are turning to private healtcare due to long waiting lists
A woman described how she felt she was "failed" by the NHS on two separate occasions in a poignant moment on tonight's Question Time.
This week's debate took place in St Andrews in Fife, Scotland with host Fiona Bruce sitting on the panel alongside Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP, Anas Sarwar MSP, Andrew Bowie MP, Thomas Kerr and Lesley Riddoch.
A large part of the BBC show tonight was centered around whether Scotland's NHS is "dying before our eyes". Anas Sarwar, leader Scottish labour highlighted how one in three people are forced to go private for healthcare and one audience member explained how she was part of that shocking statistic.
The female audience member asked, "I'd just be interested to know how you measure the improvements that you're seeing in the NHS if you're saying that the waiting lists are going down? Is it not just because more people are going private? Just today I was getting a private surgery having been failed by the NHS twice."
The woman, who did not disclose the nature of the surgery she needed, went on to explain how she was forced to turn to private healthcare after being "failed" by the NHS on two separate occasions.
She added: "I first got this looked at nearly 10 years ago by an NHS specialist dermatologist who didn't think there was anything to be concerned about, I followed up again a year ago, I was told the same thing and I'm not blaming these doctors who are very pushed for time, I work in healthcare myself but then I went to see a private doctor because I am fortunate to have the means to be able to pay for private health insurance and as soon as they saw it they immediately rushed me to have it removed. But I firmly believe that healthcare should be accessible to everyone and it should be equal, but I've kind of been forced into this situation where I don't want to deny myself the healthcare that I can afford but it shouldn't be at the expense of others."
In response Thomas Kerr, representing Reform UK, explained "too many people are going private," and said "the NHS isn't working in it's current system, it does have to be looked into and it does have to be reformed". He added: "Just throwing money at it doesn't work, we've seen that time and time again, we've had record funding in th NHS that is still not working for people on the ground."
When asked by Fiona if he supported the idea of a mixed economy like the French system he added: "As long as healthcare is free at the point of need for anyone who needs it then I don't mind where someone gets their healthcare at all. If you can afford it and you want to pay it privately then that's entirely up to a person individually."
He went on to address the problem in Scotland of the number of doctors leaving the NHS, he said: "We have a higher tax system in Scotland which is making people who are learning in our universities like here in St Andrews are then leaving to go down to England or to go travel abroad, I think we have to look at the tax system in Scotland to make sure it is fair to try and keep our home grown talent here to make sure the NHS works."
Mr Kerr was then grilled about Brexit by broadcaster and commentator Lesley Riddoch. She said: "Right Thomas, what happened to the £380m quid a week we were going to get from Brexit?" She went on to say: "We've got a bit of a mess going on with healthcare here, we've got a static life expectancy which is shameful given the amount of wealth there is in this country and overall our health is not great."
Question Time has now finished for the summer, it will be back on our screens in September.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
9 minutes ago
- Sky News
'Life-changing' drug for teenager who lost mother to genetic condition
A teenager who lost her mother, aunt and uncle to a genetic condition is the first person in Europe to receive a "life-changing" drug. Mary Catchpole, 19, from Great Yarmouth, suffers from a rare inherited disorder called activated PI3-Kinase delta syndrome (APDS), which leaves people with a significantly weakened immune system. The condition was passed down by her mother's side of the family, with her mother Sarah dying aged 42 in 2018, while her aunt Helen died aged 12, her uncle Edward when he was 39 and her grandmother Mary when she was 48. APDS patients are vulnerable to repeated infections, causing them to face a lifetime of antibiotics and immunoglobulin replacement therapy to prevent infections and organ damage, and a bone marrow or stem cell transplant - until now. A new drug called leniolisib (Joenja) is a simple tablet taken twice a day and is the first ever targeted treatment for APDS. Ms Catchpole, who is the first person in Europe to receive the medicine after it was made available on the NHS, said taking the new drug is "life-changing" as it means she can leave behind huge amounts of medication. "I was diagnosed with APDS aged seven and it's had a big effect on my life. I had lots of cannulas when I was younger and lots of hospital trips," she said. "I had a permanent line in the side of my body when I was younger, which they put medicine in regularly at the hospital." Ms Catchpole added that she wasn't allowed to do much physical activity, including dancing, which she's "always loved to do". "It has been hard," said the teaching assistant, who lives with her father Jimmy, 64, and her brother Joe, 20, who does not have APDS. The condition was identified by Cambridge researchers in 2013, with Ms Catchpole's family playing a key role in its discovery, as her mother and uncle were both patients at Addenbrooke's Hospital and were offered DNA sequencing to find out whether there was a genetic cause for their immunodeficiency. The researchers found a change in their genes that increased activity of an enzyme called PI3-Kinase delta, meaning this enzyme is effectively "switched on" all the time, preventing immune cells from fighting infection. Professor Sergey Nejentsev, from the University of Cambridge, who led the research that discovered APDS, said: "As soon as we understood the cause of APDS, we immediately realised that certain drugs could be used to inhibit the enzyme that is activated in these patients." The new drug works by inhibiting the PI3-Kinase delta enzyme, effectively normalising the immune system of the patient. "This new drug will make a huge difference to people living with APDS," Dr Anita Chandra, consultant immunologist at Addenbrooke's and affiliated assistant professor at the University of Cambridge, said. Ms Catchpole says she can now look to the future with optimism and lead a normal life. "I really want to become a dance teacher," she said. "I absolutely love my current job as a teaching assistant but I'd also like to go on some adventures as well. I've always felt different so it will be nice to feel like I belong." There are between 40 and 50 people in England who are known to have APDS.
Sky News
9 minutes ago
- Sky News
Areas of England to get extra NHS funding announced
Why you can trust Sky News NHS funding will be diverted to working-class communities, the health secretary is set to announce. Wes Streeting is expected to announce the measure as part of the upcoming NHS 10-year plan, set to be focused on closing health inequalities, during a speech in Blackpool today. About £2.2bn will be spent on staff, medicines, new technology and equipment in rural communities, coastal towns and working-class regions, according to the Department of Health. 3:09 The money, which was previously set aside to plug financial holes in the health service, can now be reinvested where it is "most needed", the department said. It added that NHS leaders have spent months cutting "wasteful" spending, such as on "back office" functions and agency staff, while reducing forecast deficits by health trusts. GP funding will be reviewed under the new plan, as surgeries serving working-class areas receive an average of 10% less funding per patient than practices in more affluent areas. Practices in some of England's poorest areas have about 300 more patients per GP than the most affluent areas, data by the Royal College of GPs suggests. 5:52 The Department of Health said poorer communities had been "neglected" for years and often have the fewest GPs, the worst performing services and the longest waits. Mr Streeting is expected to say during the announcement of the plan that "those in greatest need often receive the worst quality healthcare". He will say that this "flies in the face of the values the NHS was founded on" as "the circumstances of your birth shouldn't determine your worth". Mr Streeting is set to add: "A core ambition of our 10-year plan will be to restore the promise of the NHS, to provide first-class healthcare for everyone in our country and end the postcode lottery." The government "will prioritise investment" where towns have the greatest health needs and the fewest GPs, according to Mr Streeting.
Rhyl Journal
2 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
Ministers urged to act to protect hospice care for children
Together for Short Lives said hospices are being forced to rely on donations and funds raised from charity shops to prop up services as it called on ministers to increase ring-fenced NHS funding for children's hospices. A new poll of 30 hospices in England found almost nine in 10 (89%) expect their costs to exceed their income this financial year. The charity warned seriously ill children may die without accessing end-of-life care, symptom management and emotional and psychological support as a result. A report from the charity, seen by the PA news agency, states inflation, workforce shortages, and rising demand for care are stretching services to 'breaking point'. The report estimates costs for hospices have risen by 34% since 2021. However, statutory funding for children's hospices is still 'falling short' of what is needed, it adds. 'With reserves set to dwindle and deficits projected to grow, the future of children's hospice care is becoming increasingly unsustainable,' the authors wrote. The report also reveals disparities in funding across England, with neighbouring health authorities spending vastly different amounts on care. Together for Short Lives is urging ministers to increase ring-fenced NHS funding for children's hospices in England from £26 million in 2025/26 to £30 million by 2029/30. It said hospices have said that without this funding they would have to cut back on respite care and short breaks, emotional and psychological support, as well as end-of-life care. Nick Carroll, chief executive of Together for Short Lives, said: 'As ministers try to shift greater levels of healthcare from hospitals into communities, our amazing children's hospices are doing more than ever before to provide crucial support to seriously ill children and their families. 'But as their costs soar, they are having to rely even more on the generosity of the public amid patchy and unsustainable funding from the NHS. 'To expect the complex and often specialist healthcare these families need to be funded by charity shops and donations is wrong – we wouldn't accept this for other parts of our health and care system, so to add more uncertainty to families' lives when many simply don't know how long they have left with their children is unacceptable.' As well as providing end-of-life care, hospices also offer services including emergency support, symptom management and short breaks for respite. One parent described how she 'couldn't live without' the support of her local hospice. Laura McArthur, from Bristol, relies on the Jessie May hospice in the city for support in caring for her seven-year-old son Archie, who has cerebral palsy. But the future of the hospice remains 'unclear' after its charitable expenditure has risen sharply, and uncertainty around funding has forced it to draw on its reserve and rely on voluntary income, Together for Short Lives said. Ms McArthur said: 'Jessie May has known Archie since he was six months old. 'They have been there through it all. 'His needs are so complex, requiring around-the-clock care – at times it can be very difficult. 'Jessie May come and look after Archie so I can have a short break. 'As the years go on, caring for a disabled child is both physically and mentally exhausting. The truth is that I couldn't live without their support.' Mr Carroll added: 'As it finalises its NHS 10-year plan, the UK Government must put in place a long-term, sustainable funding model for children's palliative care in England. 'Immediately, ministers should act to protect and maintain the NHS children's hospice grant and put it on a path to £30 million by 2030. 'Only by doing so can the Government make sure lifeline services are not cut for seriously ill children, which could deny many the choice of accessing end of life care from a children's hospice.' A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'The Government recognises the incredible work that children and young people's hospices do across the country. 'We are investing £100 million to improve hospices facilities, and a further £26 million specifically for children's hospices this year, the biggest investment in hospices in a generation. 'We are also working to make sure the palliative and end of life care sector is sustainable in the long-term and are determined to shift more healthcare out of hospitals and into the community through our Plan for Change.'
