Psychiatry cannot be allowed to dominate debate on Mental Health Act
Let's be clear: the Mental Health Act, 2001 will continue to allow people to be involuntarily confined and force treated. Let's also have some clarity that under the current system, mental health outcomes are very far from satisfactory. Indeed, despite the now accepted deconstruction of 'mental illness' as simply a diagnostic construct, this system is now largely upheld because of legislative frameworks.
It begs the question, should those within the system and seeking to uphold it be allowed to constantly dominate the discourse around reform? Let's get to the heart of the real issue here — psychiatry and its wish to retain its legal powers. Psychiatrists use a legal defence of medical necessity for forced treatment but this is increasingly untenable.
As Dr Pat Bracken, the highly respected independent consultant psychiatrist, has written: If psychiatry is going to take away people's liberty and use invasive methods of treatment, then it needs to be 'confident that we can predict outcomes, and happy that we understand how our treatments work and for whom.' His conclusion – and the now widely accepted scientific reality, is that psychiatry cannot reach this efficacy standard.
The treatment on offer for people who are severely unwell and distressed is not, as some may erroneously believe, intensive therapy that seeks to get to the root cause of the issue. Rather it is drugs and sometimes electricity. There may be psychological interventions but these are few and far between.
Of course there are situations where people need acute care and medication to stabilise them, but traumatising environments that use powerful psychotropic drugs should not be the only answer when someone is in distress. People in this system are guinea pigs, labelled treatment resistant if drugs don't work, lacking insight and branded non-compliant if they don't agree with doctors and do what they are told.
Debate in Ireland is regressing as is our move towards a rights-based system. Just this week it has been reported that the Cabinet has signed off on an amendment brought to Cabinet that someone who is involuntarily admitted to an acute psychiatric unit can be detained for up to 42 days, an increase on the 21 days previously proposed under the bill. This is a flagrant move in the wrong direction with no debate and no rationale given.
In this paper recently Dr Suzanne Crowe argued that people experiencing psychosis do not know they are ill and have no insight into their psychiatric condition. This contention assumes that viewing people through a psychiatric lens is the legitimate view, ergo if a person does not subscribe to this view 'psychiatric illness', then this means they have no insight and therefore must have their liberty taken away to be sufficiently chemically restrained.
People who are struggling, who are different, who are living in a chaotic family or community, who have extraordinary experiences, who are in deep emotional distress may not have 'insight' into the limitations of psychiatric diagnosis but the way to help them and those around them is not to lock them up as second-class citizens, take away their liberty and assault their personhood.
Insight is so very important, but it is a two-way concept. In order for these 'psychotic people' to receive the help and human engagement they may need for healing, it is important that those tasked with providing care also develop insight. Insight into the multiple perspectives, experiences and circumstances that cause people to warrant support; insight into the need to provide choices that might be more conducive to people wanting to engage, and insight into the damage the 'medical model' paradigm of care causes.
This is about a fundamental right to health. Moving towards a rights-based legal system, as outlined in the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, to which Ireland is a signatory, means treating people as rights holders, not as mere subjects of legal or state control.
Consent
Unquestionably, evidence-based care should be at the core of cancer or heart, or any other type of health treatment. Therefore, it cannot be the purview of just one highly contested profession (psychiatry) to impose what is increasingly seen as a dogmatic ideology onto people who are already in a vulnerable state.
This is not to say psychiatry should not be part of a suite of measures available to people, but mental health care should be based around consent and choice — a right to choice should be enshrined in legislation, and requisite funding must be put into things like family work, peer support, peer-run grassroots organisations, community development, non-medical crisis houses and open dialogue.
Choices should not be viewed through the sole lens of a psychiatric classification system that prescribes meaning to people's struggles, distress, environmental outcomes and extraordinary experiences. These choices have long been mandated as part of the post-psychiatry paradigm for mental health service provision, and the new paradigm is awash with international examples of best practice.
In other words, there are examples of how we can do things better. Certainly, things cannot get much worse for people in distress.
In 2013, the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture explicitly stated that forced psychiatric treatment may amount to torture or ill-treatment, especially when not evidence-based. Doctors may be offended that their well-intentioned treatment is causing harm, but advocates cannot dampen the quest for change and justice to appease psychiatrists.
Because the harsh truth is that while some coercive practices might not always meet the legal threshold for torture, they do often qualify as inhuman or degrading treatment. Surely if there is even a question that 'care' could be considered as something akin to torture, this requires radical debate and reform.
Jennifer Hough is a human rights and social justice advocate
Dr Líam Mac Gabhann is Associate Professor in Mental Health Practice at Dublin City University
Read More
Watchdog to create code of practice for using surveillance in mental health services
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
01-08-2025
- Irish Examiner
Health workers see inclusion as central to caring for patients
Training to raise awareness of diversity and inclusion among medical workers is boosting the quality of services being delivered to patients, says Dr Suzanne Crowe, president of the Medical Council. Dr Crowe, who works in paediatric intensive care, says that an inclusive medical workforce leads to greater understanding of patients' needs, culturally competent care, and ultimately, better health outcomes for patients. Speaking during Cork Pride 2025, which runs from July 26 to August 3, Dr Crowe says that she welcomes Pride events, which allow us to pause and reflect on the importance of accepting people for who they are. In this Q&A interview, Dr Crowe outlines some of the areas in which Irish health service providers have been very positive in ensuring diversity and inclusion in how patients are cared for, while also highlighting a number of areas where further improvements would be beneficial, notably further supports to help doctors with a disability to carry out their work effectively. Does the Irish medical profession see itself as actively diverse and inclusive? I think the medical profession does see itself as diverse, and increasingly inclusive. Medicine as a profession welcomes people from all walks of life, and there is increasing diversity in terms of gender and sexuality, so I would see it as being inclusive in this sense. In my opinion, we've made a lot of progress over the last couple of decades in certain areas, particularly in diversity of ethnic backgrounds, as well as from a gender balance point of view. The profession is increasingly seeing equal numbers of men and women working in medicine, in fact, we're seeing a shift towards it being more female-dominated in some specialisms. Our most recent (2024) Medical Workforce Intelligence data shows that the gender split among GPs in Ireland had slightly more females (52.4%) than males (47.6%). The majority of female GPs are between the ages 30 and 59, and older age brackets from there and above are dominated by males. This suggests that as older male GPs retire, the proportion of females in general practice will continue to grow. As well as this, in 2024 our clinically active medical workforce consisted of 13.8% of doctors who qualified in the EU/UK, and 27.8% who qualified outside of Ireland, the EU and the UK — meaning that 41.6% of our medical workforce qualified outside of Ireland. Without these doctors, our health system would collapse immediately. An area that could be improved upon is for doctors with a disability. Further supports should be put in place for doctors with a disability to carry out their work effectively. Overall, the profession does regard itself as diverse and inclusive. In what ways does the sector's openness help with attracting and retaining talent? The healthcare sector is very active in attracting talent, both in Ireland and abroad. Doctors are united as protectors of health — of the individual, and the community; and Ireland is now seen as an open, democratic, and progressive society to live in. That's why a career in medicine in Ireland can be rewarding for those who have experienced trauma or marginalisation for their beliefs, and are seeking to contribute to an inclusive, modern society. While openness brings many benefits to medicine, it's worth noting areas that still need attention, such as long working hours, working environment, and conditions. We may be attracting talent, but need to ensure we're retaining our workforce in Ireland by providing a sustainable environment to work in. Do you believe there is a link between having a diverse workforce and safer patient outcomes? I believe there is. As doctors, we should ensure that we advocate for trust, partnership and informed consent in our relationships with patients. The Medical Council carried out research in 2023, which showed that 80% of people feel it is important to be treated as a partner in their healthcare by their doctor. What this essentially means is that patients want their doctor to be approachable — someone they can bring personal concerns to. This same survey showed that people in Ireland believe that the elderly (57%), members of the travelling community (34%), refugees (33%) and immigrants (32%) are among the minority groups most at risk of receiving substandard care. Members of minority groups have unique healthcare needs and may find it easier to speak to a doctor who comes from a similar background. If the patient can relate to their doctor, they'll feel understood, in a safe space, and like their care will be approached in a non-judgemental way. This helps patients feel safe in communicating with their doctor, which helps the doctor to personalise their treatment plan and direct it to specific issues. It can help the patient to follow their plan when there's a good relationship. All these elements combined help to enhance patient care and improve patient safety. Does training help promote a more actively diverse and inclusive approach to recruitment? Training our future workforce at an early stage to have an open, empathetic approach to people of different backgrounds helps ensure that Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DE&I) awareness is already part of their understanding when they start work. Discrimination and lack of understanding can impede the path to compassionate healthcare. Bringing DE&I awareness to students throughout the lifecycle of the doctor from school into undergraduate and postgraduate education; will help doctors to address potential biases. Not only do they then have the awareness, correct language, and training about DE&I, but they'll eventually look to recruit that diversity into their own teams, because they know it'll increase inclusion, produce better working environments, and ultimately enhance patient care when treating patients of different backgrounds. Celebrating Pride also provides chances to educate and to learn, promote awareness and increase understanding of issues faced by the LGBTQI+ community. We saw a great turnout of doctors and healthcare workers from the HSE and LGBT Ireland for the Dublin Pride Parade a couple of weeks ago, and I have no doubt the representation will be strong for Cork Pride as well. LGBT Ireland's LGBT+ Champions programme is available to doctors and healthcare professionals to help understand the identities and advocate for their LGBTQI+ patients. These are provided by LGBT Ireland, the HSE, post graduate training bodies, universities, advocacy groups and charities.
Irish Examiner
30-07-2025
- Irish Examiner
Ireland finally bans HCC 'but we must be vigilant about new drugs'
The Government has been urged to remain vigilant and responsive to new drugs trends after it banned an addictive cannabis substitute which has been commonly sold in vapes or as edibles and which has been linked to serious medical episodes and psychosis in young people. The classification of hexahydrocannabinol (HHC) as an illegal drug, agreed by Cabinet on Tuesday, means the import, export, production, possession, sale, or supply of products containing HHC is now illegal, giving added powers of enforcement to gardaí. Addiction experts and youth workers welcomed the move but said enforcement, vigilance, and a swift response by Government to new drug trends will be vital. Former lord mayor of Cork and now youth services manager with Cork Education and Training Board, Mick Finn, said: This move addresses the HHC products that are in plain sight. Mr Finn held a forum on heroin use in Cork while in office and has called for controls on HHC products. 'The big challenge will be enforcement, to ensure that certain shops can't stock these products anymore,' he said. 'HHC products were having a big impact on the ground, and it was reflected in all the stats, so Government and all the relevant agencies need to be more vigilant and responsive to any new trends that emerge from this ban.' Highly addictive and widely available, HHC is a semi-synthetic cannabinoid that has similar effects to cannabis and has been commonly sold as e-cigarettes or vape pens, in herbal mixtures, oils, edible jellies, and cakes, and as tinctures. Since it was first detected in Ireland in 2022, it has been linked with episodes of psychosis and hospitalisation, including one incident at a secondary school in North Cork in late 2023 when four teenagers were hospitalised after falling ill — one of at least 20 similar incidents reported at schools and in recreational settings across the country that same year. A recent 'Irish Examiner' investigation highlighted the ease with which people, including children, could buy products containing HHC. Earlier this year, 'Irish Examiner' reporter Ann Murphy exposed how easy it was to buy HHC in Ireland — and the devastating effects the drug can have. See link above. It also detailed how a 12-year-old child in Clonakilty, West Cork, could not remember his mother's name, while another had to be admitted to a psychiatric hospital after vaping the cannabinoid. A recent study by researchers in University Hospital Galway also found that HHC was the second most common drug used by patients presenting with psychosis over a 21-month period. Consultant psychiatrist Colin O'Gara warned earlier this year that HHC can have devastating effects on a young person's mental health, and that young men suffering from severe psychosis as a result of vaping HHC have required months of intensive treatment in in-patient settings. HHC has now been classified as an illegal drug after health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill brought a memo to Cabinet on Tuesday seeking to have it categorised as a Schedule 1 controlled drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977. 14 substances added to proscribed list It is one of 14 substances, including synthetic opioids and semi-synthetic cannabinoids, newly classified as controlled drugs, after the EU and the UN Commission for Narcotic Drugs identified them as posing a serious risk to public health. Addiction counsellor Michael Guerin welcomed the ban but warned that the trade will now go underground. 'It is a positive development because there has been nothing heretofore,' he said. 'Now, it's up to the authorities to enforce the legislation. "The banning of head shops was successful, and I hope the same will happen with HHC. 'The concerning thing about these HHC products was that they seemed to be aimed at the very young, and any research into mood-altering substances in adolescents shows that the effects are more profound, and predisposes them to more serious problems later on. 'But the people making money out of HHC won't go away because of this. But it's better the substances are on the list than not on the list.'
Irish Daily Mirror
26-07-2025
- Irish Daily Mirror
Mum 'left like a rabid dog' in mental health ward where she was mocked
A mum was "left like a dog with rabies" in a mental health facility where she was mocked by staff, her daughter has claimed, following an inquest that found neglect contributed to her painful and traumatic death. Margaret Mary Picton, known as Rita, died of aspiration pneumonia after choking on paper in September 2022. Despite Rita's passing nearly three years ago, her heartbroken family had to wait until earlier this year for an inquest that would reveal the neglect she endured at Leigh Moss Hospital in Liverpool, which is run by Mersey Care mental health trust and specifically caters for patients with dementia. Rita was 76 when she passed away, but her health had been deteriorating for several years after she began suffering from vascular dementia. "Mum was a very straightforward person, she would always tell it like it is," explained Rita's daughter, Rachel Burkey, 51. "She was very good natured and would always give her kids whatever we needed. She was a really good mum. "But a few years ago I noticed changes in her behaviour and her mood. Then my sister called to say she was confused and had come at her with a knife. It was horrendous," reports the Mirror. After being in a care home in St Helens, Rita's unpredictable and sometimes aggressive behaviour led to her being sectioned under the Mental Health Act and taken to Leigh Moss on September 10, as reported by the Liverpool Echo. Upon her arrival on the ward, medics determined that Rita required monitoring at least every quarter of an hour due to her fluctuating mental state and history of self-harm incidents. An inquest at Liverpool Coroner's Court in January was told that ward personnel failed to seize chances to address Rita's erratic and perilous conduct, including an incident where she stabbed herself with a pen. Personnel failed to escalate these incidents and monitoring was not properly implemented. One member of staff, who bore responsibility for interacting with Rita on the wards, made no "meaningful attempts to engage positively" with her, the inquest determined. Even more damning, he was characterised as "unprofessional and disrespectful" when making gestures towards her. Rachel provided further details about this staff member's conduct after viewing CCTV footage during the inquest. She continued: "On the CCTV I have seen, she is in the corner, she looks like she has been there for hours. To me, she looked like she had been left like a dog with rabies. "He (the staff member) was pretending to shoot a bow and arrow at her and pretending to shoot himself in the head. He even mimicked her when she was eating paper." Coroner Helen Rimmer determined that monitoring of Rita was "limited and of poor quality", resulting in missed chances to recognise a decline in her condition and raise alarm bells. For a full 60 minutes there was no supervision of her whatsoever owing to a "communication breakdown" amongst personnel. The coroner stated: "This was fundamental basic care and supervision, which more likely than not would have led to an escalation and review of Rita's behaviour and presentation at that time had the requisite observations been undertaken." The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week The inquest heard that CCTV footage then revealed at least five, possibly six instances where Rita could be observed placing paper in her mouth, with staff present on every occasion. Whilst they did step in and remove some paper from her, they again failed to escalate concerns. On the evening of September 10, one staff member witnessed Rita consuming paper and did not take it away from her, instead gesturing an eating motion to someone else. He then positioned himself with his back to Rita, failing to adequately supervise or monitor her. In her record of inquest, the coroner states: "Staff were aware of the choking risk of paper eating but failed to escalate matters, intervene, and appropriately monitor Rita." She added: "It is more likely than not that had staff been appropriately observing and supporting Rita, they would have removed all paper from her or in the alternative escalated concerns about Rita eating paper earlier with the nurse in charge who would then have removed any paper from Rita, identified any continuing concerns and reviewed risks, which would have included consideration of the level of Rita's supportive observations. This would have more likely than not prevented Rita from eating paper and subsequently choking." Rita shockingly collapsed shortly after, and the staff who had witnessed her eating paper failed to inform those performing CPR on her about this, hence choking prevention measures were not considered. Paramedics were summoned but were delayed due to being locked out of the hospital building. When they finally arrived, CPR had been ongoing for 25 minutes and Rita had suffered two cardiac arrests before the paramedics were informed that Rita had been consuming paper prior to her collapse. This delay prevented the paramedics from promptly removing the paper, which was obstructing Rita's airway. The coroner remarked: "This was basic care and treatment that should have been undertaken and raised sooner. Not to have provided this basic care and information to professionals treating Rita was a gross failure which more likely than not hastened Rita's death." Rachel described these failures as "sickening", adding: "I can't believe they didn't even tell the paramedics that she had chewed paper until the very end. She had two cardiac arrests before they said anything. It is hard to think of that being her end." Rita was transported to the Royal Liverpool Hospital where she developed aspiration pneumonia and tragically passed away on September 26, 2022. The coroner declared: "The aspiration pneumonia was more likely than not caused by Rita eating the paper, the resuscitation efforts that followed Rita eating the paper and collapsing or a combination of both. "The failure to immediately notify staff and paramedics that Rita had ingested paper prior to her collapse represented a failure to render care that would more likely than not have prolonged her life." Ms Rimmer continued: "Having identified a specific gross failure which clearly amounts to neglect, it is also found that the accumulation of the catalogue of missed opportunities throughout the care of Rita by those involved in her care at Leigh Moss Hospital, namely the acts and omissions mentioned above, have as a whole also amounted to neglect." Aware of the shortcomings in their mum's care, Rachel and her sister Jak sought justice but faced a lengthy wait for the inquest due to various delays. They hired a barrister for the hearing to ensure they achieved the right outcome for their mum. "I thought, I am going to get my mum justice," Rachel added. "I am going to make them tell me what they did. This was about accountability. "We came out of that inquest and we said 'we've done you proud mum', she was neglected and people will know that. I feel like we got justice and by sharing it with the ECHO everyone will know what happened." Rachel said: "Mum was a fighter, even on that day on the CCTV she was still giving as good as she got. We will remember her fight and her spirit, she went through a lot and that's the sad thing. She shouldn't have been left like a dog in the corner, with no one doing anything except teasing her and basically watching her die. "But I think mum would be looking down now and saying 'good on you girls' for us fighting like this. I can see her saying that, she was really feisty. She was a lovely mum and a strong woman who wouldn't back down from what she thought was right." A spokesperson for Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust stated: "We'd like to again offer our sincere condolences to the family, friends and loved ones of Margaret Mary Picton. While we are unable to comment on individual patient care because of rules governing patient confidentiality, we can confirm that we fully co-operated with the Coroner's investigation. We also accept the findings of the Assistant Coroner, Helen Rimmer and would like to sincerely apologise for the shortcomings in care. "A patient safety learning review was undertaken following the tragic circumstances which led to Mrs Picton's death. This is in line with the Patient Safety Incident Response Framework (PSIRF) which is the NHS approach for responding to patient safety incidents, focussing on learning and making immediate changes to ensure patient safety, through a compassionate, system based and proportionate approach. "As a Trust, we remain committed to learning with efforts to ensure that incidents of this nature do not recur." Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
