Crashed Jeju Air jet still had working engine, probe update says
South Korean investigators have suggested that the Jeju Air plane involved in December's deadly crash could have continued flying for longer, despite damage to its engines due to a bird strike.
:: Lee Geun-young
That's according to their latest progress report seen by Reuters.
Instead, the Boeing jet belly-landed at Muan airport on December 29 and slammed into an embankment.
All but two of the 181 people on board were killed.
The July 19 update was not publicly released after the victims' families complained, saying parts of it were misleading and appeared to blame the pilots without exploring other factors.
The five-page report is not yet final, but contains details about the plane's two engines.
:: Lee Geun-young
According to the update, the left engine was less damaged than the right after the bird strike.
But it was shut down 19 seconds after it was hit.
The remaining, right engine was more badly damaged.
Still - the update said - it was "confirmed to be generating output sufficient for flight".
A source had told Reuters on Monday, the probe found the pilots had shut off the less-damaged engine after the bird strike.
But the newly emerged details raise the possibility that the remaining engine, despite the damage, could have kept the plane aloft for longer.
However - the update did not say what level of performance it still had.
Or what options that might have given to the plane's crew, before the jet landed in the opposite direction of the runway from its initial plan without its landing gear down.
The probe is expected to last months, as investigators reconstruct the plane's technical state and the picture understood by its pilots.
Experts say most air accidents are caused by multiple factors and caution against putting too much weight on incomplete evidence.
The investigation board did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
8 hours ago
- CBS News
Small plane crashes in Everglades in Broward, two onboard rescued, authorities say
Two people were rescued after their small plane went down in the Everglades. The plane was bound for North Perry Airport when it crashed west of Pembroke Pines just before 9 a.m. Tuesday morning. Rescuers in airboats raced to the scene. Broward Sheriff Fire Rescue battalion chief Michael Kane said the two people on the plane were not hurt and they were being taken to a command post at Holiday Park. This is a developing story, check back for updates.
New York Times
17 hours ago
- New York Times
Takeaways From the Times Investigation Into the Jeju Air Crash
Seven months after Jeju Air Flight 2216 crashed at Muan International Airport in South Korea, the cause of the accident is still being investigated. The crash — the worst aviation disaster on Korean soil, with 179 dead — came shortly after the pilots reported a bird strike. Investigators are also looking into whether the pilots may have erred by shutting down the less- damaged engine after colliding with the birds. But the high death toll may owe more to circumstances on the ground. After crashing on its belly without its landing gear deployed, the plane skidded along the runway and slammed into a concrete wall before bursting into flames. 'There is a cause for the accident and a separate cause for death,' said Lee Jun-hwa, an architect based in Seoul who lost his mother in the crash. A New York Times investigation found that a series of design and construction choices led to the presence of the concrete hazard close to the runway. Government regulators ignored a safety warning, making a disastrous outcome of any collision more likely. Reporters for The Times obtained blueprints and other design documents and asked five experts to review them. They also combed through documents issued by Korean authorities over the last 26 years. 1The original design in 1999 said that the antennas would be mounted on breakable structures. Antenna Nearly 14 feet Runway Breakable structure Slope not to scale Base In the original design, the wall was 866 feet from the end of the runway, close to its location during the crash Antenna Nearly 14 feet Runway Breakable structure Slope not to scale Base The original design specified 866 feet, where the wall is located today Antenna Nearly 14 feet above runway Breakable structure Base To runway 2But by 2007, a concrete slab was built on top of concrete pillars, which were covered by a dirt mound. Antenna Runway Slope not to scale Over 7 feet Base Dirt Concrete pillars Antenna Runway Slope not to scale Over 7 feet Base Dirt Concrete pillars Antenna Over 7 feet To runway Base Dirt Concrete pillars 3Last year, the slab was reinforced with more concrete on top, for a total slab thickness of nearly 3 inches. Antenna Runway Slope not to scale About 14 feet Antenna Runway Slope not to scale About 14 feet Antenna To runway About 14 feet Note: Diagrams are not to scale and are based on drawings of approved plans, which may differ from what was built. Sources: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, South Korea and Korea Airports Corporation (drawings); Lee Jun-hwa (slab thickness measured after the crash) Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Note: Diagram based on drawings of the concrete structure of both runways, which may differ from what was built. Sources: Korea Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and Korea Airports Corporation (drawings). Photo by Chang W. Lee/The New York Times Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
New York Times
17 hours ago
- New York Times
Decades of Blunders Put a Lethal Wall at the End of a South Korean Runway
Concrete structure Path of plane Path of plane Concrete structure Concrete structure Path of plane Plane's tail Path of plane Concrete structure Plane's tail Path of plane Concrete structure Plane's tail Concrete structure Path of plane Plane's tail Concrete internal pillars Concrete slab Path of plane Concrete structure Concrete internal pillars Concrete slab Path of plane Concrete structure Concrete internal pillars Concrete slab Concrete structure Path of plane On Dec. 29, Jeju Air Flight 2216 made an emergency landing on its belly at South Korea's Muan International Airport after it was struck by birds. The aircraft overshot the runway and smashed into a concrete wall, bursting into flames. All but two of the 181 people on board were killed. If not for the wall, the death toll may have been far lower. Sources: Video by Lee Geun-young; photo by Chang W. Lee/The New York Times Supported by The call came on a December morning while Lee Jun-hwa, an architect from Seoul, was overseas on a business trip. 'I think Mom is dead,' his younger brother told him. A plane returning from Thailand had crashed at an airport in Muan, in southwest Korea, and their mother's name was on a list of passengers. Mr. Lee watched footage of the explosion, again and again, unable to accept that these were his mother's last moments. Weeks later, he attended a Buddhist funeral rite at the airport and was startled to see concrete slabs that peeked out from a mound of dirt at the end of the runway. Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Concrete pillars exposed after crash Concrete slab Antennas 19 concrete pillars total Note: Diagram based on drawings of the concrete structure of both runways, which may differ from what was built. Sources: Korea Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and Korea Airports Corporation (drawings). Photo by Chang W. Lee/The New York Times The slabs formed part of a structure housing crucial navigation antennas that help pilots find the runway when visibility is low. International safety guidelines say such structures should be made of material that breaks apart easily if a plane collides with them. 1The original design in 1999 said that the antennas would be mounted on breakable structures. Antenna Nearly 14 feet Runway Breakable structure Slope not to scale Base In the original design, the wall was 866 feet from the end of the runway, close to its location during the crash Antenna Nearly 14 feet Runway Breakable structure Slope not to scale Base The original design specified 866 feet, where the wall is located today Antenna Nearly 14 feet above runway Breakable structure Base To runway 2But by 2007, a concrete slab was built on top of concrete pillars, which were covered by a dirt mound. Antenna Runway Slope not to scale Over 7 feet Base Dirt Concrete pillars Antenna Runway Slope not to scale Over 7 feet Base Dirt Concrete pillars Antenna Over 7 feet To runway Base Dirt Concrete pillars 3Last year, the slab was reinforced with more concrete on top, for a total slab thickness of nearly 3 inches. Antenna Runway Slope not to scale About 14 feet Antenna Runway Slope not to scale About 14 feet Antenna To runway About 14 feet Note: Diagrams are not to scale and are based on drawings of approved plans, which may differ from what was built. Sources: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, South Korea and Korea Airports Corporation (drawings); Lee Jun-hwa (slab thickness measured after the crash) N SOUTH KOREA Rescuers on site Muan Plane wreckage Path of plane End of runway Concrete structure 866 feet Structures within 984 feet must break apart upon impact, according to international standards. N Rescuers on site SOUTH KOREA Muan Plane wreckage Path of plane Concrete structure End of runway 866 feet Structures within 984 feet must break apart upon impact, according to international standards. N SOUTH KOREA Muan Rescuers on site Path of plane Concrete structure End of runway 866 feet Structures within 984 feet must break apart upon impact, according to international standards. Sources: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, South Korea; International Civil Aviation Organization; Satellite image by Planet Labs captured on Dec. 30 Damaged antennas Concrete slab Damaged antennas Concrete slab Chang W. Lee/The New York Times Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
