Russian Use of Chemical Weapons against Ukraine 'Widespread', Dutch Defense Minister Says
Dutch Defense Minister Ruben Brekelmans called for tougher sanctions against Moscow.
"The main conclusion is that we can confirm Russia is intensifying its use of chemical weapons," he told Reuters.
"This intensification is concerning because it is part of a trend we have been observing for several years now, where Russia's use of chemical weapons in this war is becoming more normalized, standardized, and widespread."
Germany's BND foreign intelligence agency confirmed the findings, saying in a statement that it had obtained the evidence alongside its Dutch counterparts. Reuters was first to report on the intelligence.
The head of the Dutch Military Intelligence Agency (MIVD), Peter Reesink, said the conclusions followed "our own independent intelligence, so we have observed it ourselves based on our own investigations."
Reuters has not been able to independently verify the use of banned chemical substances by either side in the Ukraine war.
The United States first accused Russia of using chloropicrin, a chemical compound more toxic than riot control agents and first used by Germany during World War One, in May last year.
Ukraine alleges thousands of instances of Russian chemical weapons use.
Russia's defense ministry did not immediately respond to a request to comment for this article. Russia has denied using illegal munitions and it has accused Ukraine of doing so.
Maria Zakharova, spokeswoman for the Russian foreign ministry, said on Wednesday that the Federal Security Service discovered a Ukrainian cache of explosive devices in the east of the country containing chloropicrin.
Ukraine has consistently denied such accusations.
The Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW), a disarmament agency in The Hague with 193 member states, said last year that initial accusations levelled by both countries at each other were "insufficiently substantiated".
It has not been asked to conduct a full investigation, which must be initiated by member states.
At least three Ukrainian deaths have been tied to chemical weapons use, Brekelmans said, while more than 2,500 people injured on the battlefield reported chemical weapons-related symptoms to Ukrainian health authorities.
Increased use of chemical weapons by Russia poses a threat not only to Ukraine but to other countries, Brekelmans added.
"We must further increase the pressure. This means looking at more sanctions and specifically not allowing them (Russia) to participate in international bodies like the Executive Council of the OPCW," he said.
Reesink spoke of "thousands of instances" of chemical weapons use, while also citing a Ukrainian figure of 9,000.
Rotating two-year seats on the OPCW council will be up for negotiation in the coming months.
The intelligence findings were presented in a letter to the Dutch parliament on Friday.
LARGE-SCALE PROGRAM
Russia is a member of the OPCW and, like the United States, has destroyed its declared chemical weapons stockpiles. Increased sanctions could happen in conjunction with the European Commission, which has proposed listing 15 additional new entities and individuals to its sanctions framework, including for suspected use of chemical weapons in Ukraine.
The Dutch military and general intelligence agencies, working with foreign partners, say they have uncovered concrete evidence of intensified Russian chemical weapons production. This includes heightened research capabilities and the recruitment of scientists for chemical weapons development, Reesink said. He added that Russian officials have given instructions to soldiers on the use of poisonous warfare agents.
"This isn't just some ad-hoc tinkering at the frontline; it is truly part of a large-scale program. And that is, of course, also concerning because if we don't clarify and publicize what Russia is doing, it's highly likely these trends will continue," Reesink said.
He called the use of chemical weapons by Russian armed forces "almost standing operating procedure."
"We specifically linked the use of chloropicrin to improvised munitions, such as filled light bulbs and empty bottles that are hung from a drone. When it comes to teargas, we see that they are also misusing and converting existing munitions to act as the carrier for the gas," he said.
Chloropicrin is listed as a banned choking agent by OPCW, which was created to implement and monitor compliance with the 1997 Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC).
It can cause severe irritation to the skin, eyes, and respiratory tract. If ingested, it can cause burns in the mouth and stomach, nausea and vomiting, as well as difficulty breathing or shortness of breath.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asharq Al-Awsat
an hour ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
EU to Stockpile Critical Minerals Over War Risk
Brussels says it will build up emergency stockpiles of critical minerals and cable repair kits as concerns mount over the EU's vulnerability to attack. 'The EU faces an increasingly complex and deteriorating risk landscape marked by rising geopolitical tensions, including conflict, the mounting impacts of climate change, environmental degradation, and hybrid and cyber threats,'' the European Commission said in a draft document setting out a stockpiling strategy, seen by the Financial Times. Member states should co-ordinate backup supplies of food, medicines and even nuclear fuel, the EU executive said. It would also accelerate work on EU-level stockpiles of items such as cable repair modules 'to ensure prompt recovery from energy or optical cable disruptions' and commodities such as rare earths and permanent magnets, which are crucial for energy and defense systems. Several instances of potential sabotage to underwater communication cables and gas pipelines in recent years have caused concern about the vulnerability of critical infrastructure. The strategy is part of a wider push by the EU to improve the security and resilience of the 27-country bloc. Last month, General Carsten Breuer, the German chief of defense, warned that Russia could attack an EU member state within the next four years. The higher-risk environment was driven by ''increased activity from hacktivists, cybercriminals and state-sponsored groups,' the document said. The EU is also more susceptible than many other regions to the effects of climate change as it is warming twice as fast as the global average. Wildfires in Crete forced 5,000 people to evacuate the island this week. In a report commissioned by the EU in October, former Finnish president Sauli Niinistö said that security should be considered a 'public good' and called for a preparedness mindset. On stockpiling, he said that Brussels should 'define targets to ensure minimum levels of preparedness in different crisis scenarios, including in the event of an armed aggression or the large-scale disruption of global supply chains.' The EU in March also advised households to stockpile essential supplies to survive at least 72 hours of crisis. On Tuesday, the United States announced the launch of a critical minerals initiative with Australia, India and Japan as part of efforts to counter China. In a joint statement after talks in Washington, the countries' foreign ministers said they were launching the Quad Critical Minerals Initiative, which they called an "ambitious expansion of our partnership to strengthen economic security and collective resilience by collaborating to secure and diversify critical minerals supply chains."
Arab News
3 hours ago
- Arab News
Sanctions? No big deal, say Russian middle class couple
MYTISHCHI: For Sergei Duzhikov and Maria Tyabut, a middle-class couple living in a town just outside Moscow, Western sanctions on Russia over the conflict in Ukraine have been manageable. The pair drive a Chinese car, vacation in Venezuela and buy 'Camembert' cheese made in Russia. Their modest two-bedroom apartment in Mytishchi, home to 300,000 people northeast of the capital, has been recently renovated and their Chinese-made fridge is stocked with Russian goods. Despite warnings of a looming recession and high inflation, they and many other Russians feel their economy has adapted successfully to Western sanctions, even if it means parting with some well-known Western brands for good. 'From the perspective of my everyday life — home, family, work, leisure, friends, hobbies, and interests, I honestly don't feel the impact of sanctions,' said Maria, who works at a cosmetics company. 'There aren't any brands that have left such a void that I can't live without them,' the 43-year-old added. Supermarkets have found a range of domestic and foreign alternatives to Western products, including Camembert cheese, one of Maria's creature comforts. 'It's delicious. I haven't tried real French Camembert, so I can't compare,' she admitted. 'Overall, my life hasn't changed much,' she told AFP. Western countries first levied economic sanctions against Russia in 2014, after Moscow annexed Crimea from Ukraine. Those sanctions became significantly tighter following Moscow's full-scale assault on its neighbor. Moscow responded by ramping up production of domestic goods, shifting its trade away from the West to what it calls 'friendly' nations like China and importing other items through third countries. For ordinary Russians, the most noticeable effect of this was an exodus of Western brands from supermarket shelves and from the high street. Among the most well-known brands to leave was fast-food chain McDonald's, famously replaced by Russian-owned 'Vkusno i tochka' (which translates to 'Delicious, Full Stop') in 2022. Maria's husband Sergei, a funeral director, said he had 'no complaints' about the quality of the food. 'The kids love it,' he said of the restaurant chain. When shopping, Maria buys a new brand of yoghurt that replaced one belonging to French company Danone. Danone left the Russian market in 2022 and eventually sold its operations to a businessman linked to Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov. Some Russian companies have also been able to import popular Western goods via third countries, albeit at a higher cost. As for vacations, Maria and Sergei have opted for trips across Russia and Latin America. Most European countries cut off direct flights to Russia shortly after the offensive began, while some tightened entry requirements for Russian citizens. The couple said they had been to Venezuela, a country under US sanctions, which they described as a nation of 'friendly people who love Russians.' The couple admitted there were a few teething issues. Two years ago, after a car accident, Sergei said he waited 'three months' for spare parts to repair his Korean-made Kia because of sanctions. 'That's when I realized that it probably made sense to sell my beloved Korean car and replace it with a similar Chinese one,' he told AFP. Maria also said she noticed it was harder to find products in 'certain' categories of goods. But overall, she said, 'I don't feel deprived in any way. Certainly not when it comes to food. There's a wide and rich selection.' The Russian economy has been marked by volatility since Moscow launched its Ukraine offensive in 2022, a military assault that has resulted in tens of thousands of deaths. The country reported strong economic expansion in 2023 and 2024, largely due to massive state defense spending on the conflict, but is now slowing down after a period of what officials called 'overheating.' Inflation has also been running high, clocking in at more than double the central bank's target for over a year. Maria and her husband's combined income is around 300,000 rubles (around $3,800), higher than the average wage for one person of around 100,000. While Maria acknowledged prices were going up, she said her family was not 'crying' about it. 'It's not like we used to buy a kilogramme (35 ounces) of buckwheat three years ago, and now we can only afford 600 grams,' she said. 'They are rising little by little.'
Arab News
4 hours ago
- Arab News
France's Macron to visit UK as Starmer eyes ‘reset' with EU
PARIS: French President Emmanuel Macron is to begin a state visit to the United Kingdom on Tuesday, where he is set to address the British Parliament and co-chair a meeting on Ukraine as London seeks to strengthen its ties with Europe after Brexit. King Charles III has invited the French leader and his wife, Brigitte, on a three-day official visit during which Macron is to hold joint discussions with Prime Minister Keir Starmer at the 37th Franco-British Summit on Thursday. Talks will focus on aid to Ukraine, joint efforts to halt illegal migration crossing the Channel, and strengthening defense cooperation between the two countries. 'This is the first state visit to the United Kingdom by a European Union head of state since Brexit,' the Elysee Palace said on Friday, referring to the UK's 2016 vote to leave the bloc. 'And, especially, the first since Prime Minister Starmer signalled what he called a 'reset' of relations between the United Kingdom and Europe,,' it added. There were simmering political tensions between Paris and London in the immediate aftermath of Brexit under the previous right-wing Conservative British government. But there has been a new warmth in relations under the center-left Labour government led by Starmer, and the two countries now lead European efforts to find peace for Ukraine. Buckingham Palace confirmed on Friday that Macron would formally address the British Parliament on Tuesday, following in the footsteps of his predecessors, Charles de Gaulle and Francois Mitterrand. The king will host Macron and his wife for a state banquet at his Windsor Castle residence, west of London, where the couple will also stay. While in Windsor, Macron will privately visit St. George's Chapel to lay flowers on the tomb of the late Queen Elizabeth II. During the visit, Macron and Starmer will host the 37th Franco-British Summit in London on Thursday, where they are set to discuss opportunities to strengthen defense ties between the two countries in response to Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The agreements will be 'adapted to this profoundly changed strategic reality,' the Elysee Palace said, without offering further details. Macron and Starmer will also co-chair talks bringing together countries 'willing' to strengthen Kyiv's defenses against Moscow. The two leaders will speak with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, as well as German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, the French presidency said. This comes after the United States, Ukraine's biggest military backer since the launch of Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022, said Tuesday it was halting some key weapons shipments to Ukraine. Russia launched its largest-ever drone and missile attack on Ukraine overnight on Friday. The summit will touch upon the deployment of 'a reassurance force' to Ukraine after a ceasefire and how to 'increase pressure' on Russia to accept an unconditional ceasefire, the Elysee Palace said. Another topic high on the agenda is agreeing on a strategy to halt migrants making perilous small boat crossings of the Channel, a key political issue in the UK. As more small boats land on English shores, and the UK government comes under mounting pressure from the far right to tackle irregular migration, London has pressed Paris to do more. In recent weeks, France said it is considering stopping migrant boats in its shallow coastal waters, though the move raises safety and legal issues. And on Friday, the British government said it welcomed footage showing French police stopping a small boat carrying migrants from setting off across the Channel. The French president's visit follows King Charles's state visit to France in 2023, which was widely regarded as a success that helped boost relations. The last state visit by a French president to the UK was made by Nicolas Sarkozy in 2008.
