How a Utah Woman Lured Husband to His Death — and Saw Plot Undone by One Critical Mistake
Kathryn Restelli pleaded guilty to murder and conspiracy to commit murder in connection with her estranged husband Matthew Restelli's July 2024 death
Kathryn Restelli lured her husband to her mother's home, where her brother ambushed Matthew Restelli and shot him
Kathryn Restelli's brother Kevin Ellis and mother Tracey Marie Grist are set to face their own jury trials in January 2026A Utah woman admitted in court this week that she conspired with her family to try and kill her husband after luring him to her mother's house last July.
Kathryn Restelli pleaded guilty to two second-degree felonies for murder and conspiracy to commit murder, as well as a first-degree felony for discharging a firearm on Wednesday, July 16, according to KSL, ABC 4, and Fox 13.
According to KSL, citing testimony from her trial, the 37-year-old woman lured her estranged husband Matthew Restelli to her mother's house in American Fork, Utah, by convincing him that she wanted to fix their relationship. ABC 4 reported that Matthew had been living separately from his wife for several months before the murder.
Over the phone, Restelli convinced her husband to drive to her mother's house and told him to walk in the front door, which she said was open, according to KSL.
When Matthew entered, Restelli's brother Kevin Ellis allegedly ambushed his brother-in-law and fatally shot him multiple times, according to the outlet, which cites authorities. KSL reported that testimony in Restelli's trial alleged that she, her brother, and their mother Tracey Marie Grist had planned to frame the murder as self-defense by lying to police that Matthew had entered the home without warning or permission.
Grist allegedly called 911 minutes after the shooting, and when police arrived, they found a knife placed in Matthew's hand in a way that raised suspicion, according to ABC 4.
Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.
KSL reported that Restelli was charged with murder under a Utah law that allows someone to be criminally prosecuted if they act in a clear mental state in an effort to commit or aid in a murder. According to the outlet, Restelli's guilty plea this week could possibly lower the charges against her brother and mother.
Ellis and Grist's own jury trials are set to begin next January, according to ABC 4. Both are charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, obstruction of justice, and two counts of domestic violence in the presence of a child,
Restelli is set to be sentenced on Sept. 9, according to KSL. She faces between six years to life in prison.
Read the original article on People
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Police reveal suspect in mystery murder of four people after baby was left on stranger's front lawn
Police are searching for a man they believe killed four members of a family in rural Tennessee before abandoning a 7-month-old baby girl in a front yard. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has named Austin Robert Drummond, 28, as a suspect in Tuesday's quadruple murder. He is still on the loose and police warn Drummond should be considered armed and dangerous. The Marshals Service is offering up to $7,500 for information leading to his capture. Drummond is about 5'10, weighs 190 lbs, and has blue eyes, brown hair, and a goatee, though he may have altered parts of his appearance since the killings, according to the TBI. He has been added to the state's 'most wanted' list. The suspect was last seen driving his white Audi A3 sedan, which has Tennessee license plate RI 01896. The vehicle can be further identified by damage it has on its driver's side, according to authorities. Drummond is wanted for first-degree murder, kidnapping, and unlawful firearm possession in connection with the murders of Adrianna Williams, 20, James Wilson, 21, Courtney Rose, 38, and Braydon Williams, 15, police say. The four victims have been identified as being the mother, father, grandmother, and uncle of the baby girl Drummond allegedly kidnapped and then abandoned on a lawn. Police have not confirmed if Drummond has any connection to the family. He has a previous conviction for aggravated robbery and was sentenced to 13 years in prison, according to WREG. He finished his sentence in September. He is facing other charges, including attempted first degree murder and drug charges stemming from his time in prison. Drummond was not released on parole or probation. Police became aware of the murders after receiving a call about a "concerning incident" at around 3.11 p.m. on Tuesday, according to the Dyer County Sheriff's Office. "A dark-colored minivan or a white mid-size SUV was reported to have dropped off an infant in a car seat at a random individual's front yard," the sheriff's office wrote alongside a photo of the child. "Thankfully a witness saw the car seat with the child and called 911." Once the deputies identified the baby they wanted to speak with her family. Around 10.26 p.m., a 911 call reported two of the victims were missing. The caller said they were searching around a home with a flashlight, according to Action News 5. The discovery of the infant and the missing persons call eventually led the deputies to Lake County where they found the victims. The crime scene is approximately 25 miles north of where the baby was found, according to deputies. A family friend, Amy Anderson, remembered Adrianna Williams, 20, as the "sweetest person." 'They're devastated. We're just thankful that the baby was spared, grateful for that,' Anderson told WREG 3. 'They were really good people, Adrianna was the sweetest person, she loved being a mama.' District Attorney General Danny Goodman Jr said the TBI and FBI are working on the case alongside several local and regional law enforcement agencies.
CNN
7 minutes ago
- CNN
Virginia Giuffre's family says she would have wanted Epstein documents released
Donald TrumpFacebookTweetLink Follow The family of Virginia Giuffre — one of the women who accused Jeffrey Epstein of sex trafficking and who died by suicide earlier this year — said Thursday that she would have wanted documents related to the disgraced financier to be made public, as the Trump administration faces mounting pressure around the case. Amanda Roberts, Giuffre's sister-in-law, told CNN's Kaitlan Collins on 'The Source' that in one of their last conversations, Giuffre called for the release of the documents. 'She wanted the world to know what they've done to her and so many other survivors, and she had been fighting that till her very last day,' Roberts said. Giuffre, a prominent Epstein accuser who also alleged that Britain's Prince Andrew abused her when she was a teenager, died by suicide in April at the age of 41. In 2019, Epstein died awaiting trial on federal charges accusing him of sexually abusing underage girls. His death was ruled a suicide. Prince Andrew repeatedly denied the claims. President Donald Trump, who had decadeslong ties to Epstein, said earlier this week that the sex offender poached young women from Mar-a-Lago, including Giuffre, who worked at Trump's resort as a teenager. 'I think she worked at the spa,' Trump said of Giuffre. 'I think that was one of the people, yeah. He stole her.' Sky Roberts, Giuffre's brother, on Thursday took issue with Trump's use of the word 'stole,' telling Collins, 'She wasn't stolen, she was preyed upon at his property, at President Trump's property.' 'Stolen seems very impersonal, feels very much like an object, and these survivors are not objects,' Roberts said. He added that Trump's comments raise questions about 'how much he knew during that time.' The White House has said Trump barred Epstein from his Mar-a-Lago club 'for being a creep.' Trump has not been accused of any wrongdoing in connection with Epstein. Earlier Thursday, Giuffre's family expressed shock and raised questions about Trump's relationship with Epstein in a statement to CNN. Those comments were first reported by The Atlantic. Sky Roberts on 'The Source' also weighed in on a top Justice Department official meeting last week with Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's accomplice who has also offered to testify before Congress, but with major conditions, including immunity. Giuffre 'was preyed upon by Ghislaine Maxwell, as well as many other predators out there. But she was preyed upon at Mar-a-Lago and we were very shocked and very surprised that they were giving her a voice and giving her a platform to essentially, possibly make a deal,' Sky Roberts said. Lanette Wilson, Giuffre's sister-in-law, added that she doesn't 'see any real reason to speak with' Maxwell. 'She has perjured herself in the past and … we're talking about a sex trafficker, a monster that could do unspeakable things to young women without conscience,' Wilson added. 'So what would she do to get herself out of the situation that she's in?' Maxwell was never tried or convicted of perjury. She initially faced perjury charges, but prosecutors later agreed to dismiss after Maxwell's conviction on more serious charges, citing a desire to avoid further emotional trauma for the victims. In recent weeks, Trump has been noncommittal when asked about the possibility of a pardon or commutation for Maxwell. But a senior Trump administration official said Thursday that Trump is not currently considering clemency. Sky Roberts told Collins that Maxwell 'deserves to rot in prison where she belongs because of what she's done to my sister and so many other women.' Meanwhile, Wilson stressed that the possibility of Maxwell receiving immunity or a pardon sends a chilling message. 'It does send a message to the survivors that, you know, if you're in power, if you've got money, if you've got connections, then you're above the law,' Wilson said, later adding: 'It's just sending a message to survivors that their voices and all of the hard work that they've done for the last however many years, 10-plus years, doesn't matter.' Sky Roberts also told Collins that he wants two questions answered: 'When are we going to start believing survivors?' and 'Why aren't the documents being released?' 'They deserve justice. These survivors were — had something taken away from them they can never get back,' Sky Roberts said. 'And it's time for these monsters to be exposed and get something they can never get back, which is their freedom.'
CNN
8 minutes ago
- CNN
Virginia Giuffre's family says she would have wanted Epstein documents released
Donald TrumpFacebookTweetLink Follow The family of Virginia Giuffre — one of the women who accused Jeffrey Epstein of sex trafficking and who died by suicide earlier this year — said Thursday that she would have wanted documents related to the disgraced financier to be made public, as the Trump administration faces mounting pressure around the case. Amanda Roberts, Giuffre's sister-in-law, told CNN's Kaitlan Collins on 'The Source' that in one of their last conversations, Giuffre called for the release of the documents. 'She wanted the world to know what they've done to her and so many other survivors, and she had been fighting that till her very last day,' Roberts said. Giuffre, a prominent Epstein accuser who also alleged that Britain's Prince Andrew abused her when she was a teenager, died by suicide in April at the age of 41. In 2019, Epstein died awaiting trial on federal charges accusing him of sexually abusing underage girls. His death was ruled a suicide. Prince Andrew repeatedly denied the claims. President Donald Trump, who had decadeslong ties to Epstein, said earlier this week that the sex offender poached young women from Mar-a-Lago, including Giuffre, who worked at Trump's resort as a teenager. 'I think she worked at the spa,' Trump said of Giuffre. 'I think that was one of the people, yeah. He stole her.' Sky Roberts, Giuffre's brother, on Thursday took issue with Trump's use of the word 'stole,' telling Collins, 'She wasn't stolen, she was preyed upon at his property, at President Trump's property.' 'Stolen seems very impersonal, feels very much like an object, and these survivors are not objects,' Roberts said. He added that Trump's comments raise questions about 'how much he knew during that time.' The White House has said Trump barred Epstein from his Mar-a-Lago club 'for being a creep.' Trump has not been accused of any wrongdoing in connection with Epstein. Earlier Thursday, Giuffre's family expressed shock and raised questions about Trump's relationship with Epstein in a statement to CNN. Those comments were first reported by The Atlantic. Sky Roberts on 'The Source' also weighed in on a top Justice Department official meeting last week with Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's accomplice who has also offered to testify before Congress, but with major conditions, including immunity. Giuffre 'was preyed upon by Ghislaine Maxwell, as well as many other predators out there. But she was preyed upon at Mar-a-Lago and we were very shocked and very surprised that they were giving her a voice and giving her a platform to essentially, possibly make a deal,' Sky Roberts said. Lanette Wilson, Giuffre's sister-in-law, added that she doesn't 'see any real reason to speak with' Maxwell. 'She has perjured herself in the past and … we're talking about a sex trafficker, a monster that could do unspeakable things to young women without conscience,' Wilson added. 'So what would she do to get herself out of the situation that she's in?' Maxwell was never tried or convicted of perjury. She initially faced perjury charges, but prosecutors later agreed to dismiss after Maxwell's conviction on more serious charges, citing a desire to avoid further emotional trauma for the victims. In recent weeks, Trump has been noncommittal when asked about the possibility of a pardon or commutation for Maxwell. But a senior Trump administration official said Thursday that Trump is not currently considering clemency. Sky Roberts told Collins that Maxwell 'deserves to rot in prison where she belongs because of what she's done to my sister and so many other women.' Meanwhile, Wilson stressed that the possibility of Maxwell receiving immunity or a pardon sends a chilling message. 'It does send a message to the survivors that, you know, if you're in power, if you've got money, if you've got connections, then you're above the law,' Wilson said, later adding: 'It's just sending a message to survivors that their voices and all of the hard work that they've done for the last however many years, 10-plus years, doesn't matter.' Sky Roberts also told Collins that he wants two questions answered: 'When are we going to start believing survivors?' and 'Why aren't the documents being released?' 'They deserve justice. These survivors were — had something taken away from them they can never get back,' Sky Roberts said. 'And it's time for these monsters to be exposed and get something they can never get back, which is their freedom.'
