Tennessee man faces execution for killing his wife and her 2 sons, 3 years after surprise reprieve
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — A Tennessee man who killed his wife and her two teenage sons was scheduled to be executed on Thursday morning, three years after he was saved by a last-minute reprieve.
Oscar Smith, 75, was scheduled to receive a lethal injection of the barbiturate pentobarbital at 10:10 a.m. Smith has always claimed to be innocent, and in an interview with The Associated Press recently, he primarily wanted to discuss the ways he felt the court system had failed him.
He was convicted of fatally stabbing and shooting his estranged wife, Judith Smith, 13-year-old Jason Burnett and 16-year-old Chad Burnett at their Nashville, Tennessee, home on Oct. 1, 1989. He was sentenced to death by a Davidson County jury in July 1990 for the murders.
In 2022, a Davidson County Criminal Court judge denied requests to reopen his case despite some new evidence that the DNA of an unknown person was on one of the murder weapons. The judge wrote that the evidence of Smith's guilt was overwhelming and the DNA evidence did not tip the scales in his favor.
Tennessee executions have been on hold for five years, first because of COVID-19 and then because of missteps by the Tennessee Department of Correction.
Smith came within minutes of execution in 2022 before he was saved by a surprise reprieve from Republican Gov. Bill Lee. It later turned out the lethal drugs that were going to be used on him had not been properly tested. A subsequent yearlong investigation turned up numerous other problems with Tennessee executions.
The Correction Department issued new guidelines for executions in December. The new execution manual contains only a single page on the lethal injection chemicals with no specific directions for testing the drugs. It also removes the requirement that the drugs come from a licensed pharmacist. Smith's attorney, Amy Harwell, has characterized it this way: 'It's as if, having been caught breaking their own rules, TDOC decided, 'Let's just not have rules.''
The new protocols are the subject of a lawsuit filed by Smith and other death row inmates. A trial in that case is set for next January.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
35 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Vanguard News Launches Vanguard Incarcerated Press to Amplify Voices from Inside the Prison System
06/12/2025, Davis, California // PRODIGY: Feature Story // Vanguard News Group Vanguard News Group has officially launched its groundbreaking prison journalism initiative, Vanguard Incarcerated Press (VIP), a program built on education, justice, and the transformative power of storytelling from within the prison system. The program was born from an unlikely and deeply moving source: a Nepali family advocating for a loved one who had been wrongly convicted and sentenced to over 300 years in prison. Vanguard News founder David Greenwald was introduced to other incarcerated individuals, motivating him to create a prison newspaper. The publication never fully came to fruition due to overly restrictive prison policies. But the idea planted a seed. 'I visited him multiple times a year over seven or eight years,' said Greenwald. 'He introduced me to folks who were trying to launch something powerful behind bars. Even though the prison itself was too conservative to allow that paper to thrive, it made me realize how badly this kind of platform was needed.' Now, that dream has become a reality. Vanguard Incarcerated Press is a print and digital journalism platform led by and for incarcerated individuals. The publication mails physical newspapers to its subscribers, including courts, institutions, and justice advocates, and features new articles regularly on its website. All stories are written, edited, and reviewed with the direct involvement of incarcerated people themselves. Three incarcerated individuals currently serve on the editorial board, reviewing submissions, editing pieces, and approving content for publication. Others contribute as writers, and for many, it's the first time their voices have been heard outside prison walls. 'Seeing your own byline in print when you're locked up; it means something,' said Greenwald. 'It builds pride, purpose, and a sense that your story matters.' VIP mirrors the success of Vanguard's Court Watch program, which trains college students in journalism and legal observation. But in this case, the participants are incarcerated people, many of whom never graduated high school. Through the program, they learn to write, report, edit, and build the kind of skills that reduce recidivism and increase their chances of parole. One graduate of the early pilot effort, formerly incarcerated for nearly a decade, is now earning his bachelor's degree and sits on Vanguard's Board of Directors. His story, and many others, show what's possible when people are given a second chance and the right tools to succeed. Vanguard News is now collaborating with a state university professor to formalize the program into a certified curriculum. The goal is to develop a journalism certificate (and potentially a degree track) that incarcerated students can complete from inside, gaining a recognized credential they can carry into life after prison. 'This is twofold,' Greenwald explained. 'We're exposing injustice through our reporting, but we're also giving people inside a real skillset, a path forward, and dignity.' Despite its promise, the program faces steep financial challenges. Vanguard News operates on the margins, relying on donations, small grants, and an increasing need for grassroots fundraising. Greenwald, who now also serves as the program's primary fundraiser, says he's learned to be creative: 'We have donate buttons, we accept mail-in checks, and I've even taken donations over Cash App. You have to meet people where they are.' Supporters can contribute directly via Vanguard News' website or reach out to help fund specific program goals, including but not limited to: expanding editorial capacity to meet growing submissions, printing and mailing physical newspapers to more facilities, developing the accredited journalism certificate program, or providing tablets and tech access for easier communication between contributors and editors. Vanguard Incarcerated Press is not just another publication. It is a lifeline; both an outlet for incarcerated individuals to tell their stories and a tool for social change. It reminds society that those behind bars still have a voice, and for many, that voice is the beginning of redemption. Greenwald sums it up best: 'We're helping the public understand the system while aiding the people in the system to change their own lives. That's the power of journalism.' Media Contact Name: David Greenwald Email: [email protected]@ Source published by Submit Press Release >> Vanguard News Launches Vanguard Incarcerated Press to Amplify Voices from Inside the Prison System
Associated Press
35 minutes ago
- Associated Press
An immigrant in Wisconsin has been released on bond after false accusation he threatened Trump
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A man who was falsely accused of threatening to assassinate President Donald Trump and threatened with deportation to Mexico was released Thursday from a Wisconsin jail on bond, three weeks after federal immigration agents arrested him. Ramón Morales Reyes, 54, was accused of a writing a letter threatening Trump in a social media post by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem that got widespread national coverage. The post includes Morales Reyes' photo and an excerpt from the letter he purportedly wrote in English. But the claims quickly fell apart as Wisconsin authorities determined that Reyes, who doesn't speak English well or write in the language, was framed. Morales Reyes was a victim in a violent 2023 attack where his bike was stolen. According to authorities, the alleged attacker, Demetric D. Scott, forged the letter to try to clear his case. Morales Reyes was set to be a witness in Scott's July trial for armed robbery and aggravated battery. Morales Reyes was released after paying the $7,500 bond that an immigration judge set on Tuesday. Speaking to WISN-TV, Morales Reyes said he and his lawyer will fight his deportation. 'I believe (the lawyer) knows the history and all of you know what happened,' he said. Judge Carla Espinoza said at the immigration court hearing in Chicago that Morales Reyes was not a threat to the community. Morales Reyes, a married father of three U.S. citizen children, works as a dishwasher in Milwaukee. He was arrested by immigration agents last month after dropping a child off at school. He immigrated from Mexico in the 1980s and doesn't have legal permission to be in the U.S. This year, he applied for a U visa, which is for people in the country illegally who are victims of serious crimes. Getting such a visa can take years. Homeland Security issued a statement to reporters last week saying that although Morales Reyes was no longer considered a threat to Trump, federal attorneys would still pursue an immigration case. The government alleges that Morales Reyes reentered the U.S. numerous times without a visa. Morales Reyes had been held in the Dodge Detention Center in Juneau, about 70 miles (113 kilometers) north of Milwaukee. He was released after the federal government did not appeal the setting of his bond. Noem's social media post blaming Morales Reyes for an assassination attempt, which was circulated by Trump supporters, remains online. ___ Tareen reported from Chicago.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
Alleged child sexual abuse victim Cindy Clemishire, father file suit against Robert Morris, his wife and Gateway Church
Cindy Clemishire, the woman at the center of the child sex abuse case involving Gateway Church founder Robert Morris, and her father have filed a lawsuit against the church founder, his wife and several current and former church leaders. The suit alleges the defendants knew about Robert Morris' deceit, hid it and made millions of dollars from his "moral failures and rape of Plaintiff, Cindy Clemishire." The lawsuit names Gateway Church, Robert Morris, Robert Morris' wife Deborah Morris, Thomas H. Miller, Jr., John D. Willbanks III, Kevin Grove, Jeremy Carrasco, Kenneth W. Fambro II, Gayland Lawshe, Dane Minor, Lawrence Swicegood, Steve Dulin and the Robert Morris Evangelistic Association Inc. Miller, Willbanks, Grove, Carrasco, Fambro, Lawshe, Minor and Dulin are identified as Gateway Church elders and Swicegood as the former Executive Director of Media and Communications for Gateway. Deborah Morris, Robert Morris' wife, is listed a former leader of the women's ministry at Gateway. The scandal surrounding Gateway Church's Robert Morris The public controversy for the megachurch began in June, when Cindy Clemishire publicly claimed the church's founder, Robert Morris, sexually assaulted her starting in 1982 when she was 12 years old. Robert Morris was a traveling evangelist in his early 20s and had become close with her family. Those allegations were first published by The Wartburg Watch, a North Carolina-based church watchdog blog, and then picked up by The Christian Post. Cindy Clemishire told CBS News Texas the alleged abuse continued until 1987. Cindy Clemishire CBS News Texas Robert Morris acknowledged in a sermon in 2014 that he was "sexually immoral" when he was a young man and admitted to "inappropriate sexual behavior" In a statement to the Christian Post. "When I was in my early twenties, I was involved in inappropriate sexual behavior with a young lady in a home where I was staying," he said. "It was kissing and petting and not intercourse, but it was wrong. This behavior happened on several occasions over the next few years." Church elders said Robert Morris disclosed to them he'd had an extramarital affair, but not that he had allegedly abused a 12-year-old. On June 18, Robert Morris resigned from his position as senior pastor at Gateway Church. Cindy Clemishire said she has mixed thoughts and feelings regarding his resignation and believes she is not the only victim. "Though I am grateful that he is no longer a pastor at Gateway, I am disappointed that the Board of Elders allowed him to resign," Cindy Clemishire wrote in a statement. "He should have been terminated." She rebuked church elders for knowing and acknowledging her claims of sexual abuse but intentionally embracing "the false narrative Robert Morris wanted them to believe." On June 23, protesters gathered outside the church as a church elder addressed the congregation for the first time after Cindy Clemishire's statements. "As an elder, I did not know the truth and, frankly, like many of you my wife and I are shocked, devastated and grieving," said Tra Willbanks, a Gateway Church elder. "I'd like to express my personal compassion for Cindy Clemishire, I can't imagine carrying a burden like that for so many years and I want to say to you, Cindy, I'm so sorry." Four members of the Gateway Church Board of Elders, including Robert Morris' son, were put on temporary leaves of absence as an outside legal team investigated the accusations against Robert Morris, the church said on June 28. Founded in 2000, the Southlake-based Gateway Church expanded to become one of the largest congregations in the nation, drawing approximately 100,000 attendees each weekend to its nine campuses. Robert Morris broadcast his weekly program live online to over 190 countries, reaching even wider audiences. Robert Morris indicted on 5 counts of lewd or indecent acts with a child in Oklahoma In March, Robert Morris was indicted on five counts of lewd or indecent acts with a child, stemming from Cindy Clemishire's allegations. Morris, 63, was booked into the Osage County Sheriff's Office at 7:57 a.m. on Monday. By 8:11 a.m., just 14 minutes later, he had posted a $50,000 bond and was released, according to jail records. CBS News Texas / OCSO The indictment was announced by the office of Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond. A multi-county grand jury investigation resulted in five felony counts. "After almost 43 years, the law has finally caught up with Robert Morris for the horrific crimes he committed against me as a child," Cindy Clemishire said in a statement. "Now, it is time for the legal system to hold him accountable. My family and I are deeply grateful to the authorities who have worked tirelessly to make this day possible and remain hopeful that justice will ultimately prevail." According to Drummond's office, the statute of limitations does not apply to this case because Morris was not a resident or inhabitant of Oklahoma at any time. A week later, Robert Morris surrendered to officials in Osage County. Online records showed he bonded out shortly after he turned himself in. Court records showed an Osage County judge set a $50,000 bond and ordered Robert Morris to surrender his passport to the local sheriff. Mack Martin, Robert Morris' attorney, declined to comment on the charges, but said he anticipated entering a not guilty plea on Robert Morris' behalf. Court documents reveal what Gateway Church may have known before abuse allegations CBS News Texas obtained court documents, filed in Tarrant County, related to a lawsuit against the church over retirement payments. They include a proposed announcement that he was going to make to the congregation, but it was never made public. According to Robert Morris' attorney, the proposed announcement was written by Morris in 2011. In it, Robert Morris admits to "inappropriate behavior" with an underage girl, but did not name Cindy Clemishire. That 2011 announcement was never made public because, in a letter in 2007 to the board of elders, the president suggested Robert Morris "should not mention the family or Cindy specifically by name as this would violate their privacy." Gateway Church released a statement that read, in part: "We have consistently and publicly said that there were elders and employees at Gateway who knew about this issue before it became public - and either didn't take action or didn't inquire further. That was fundamentally wrong - the church elders took action, and none of those individuals are a part of Gateway Church today." Robert Morris' million-dollar demand In May, 63-year-old Robert Morris demanded millions of dollars in payments and retirement benefits from the church following his resignation in 2024. Church lawyers wrote in the court filing that "amid the chaos of his conduct had unleashed upon Gateway and his community, Morris was laser-focused on securing his financial future." According to a retirement compensation agreement included in the court filing, the retirement benefit is not payable if Robert Morris is fired or resigns for failing to adhere to church policies and causing harm to the church. The church argued that if its founder is convicted of the criminal charges he faces in Oklahoma, it would have grounds to withhold the money. Damages The lawsuit states that Cindy Clemishire and her father have also suffered damages to their reputation and image, which could continue into the future. In a news release, attorneys for the Clemishires said they are seeking civil damages in excess of $1 million, including but not limited to loss of reputation, mental anguish, and economic losses, in an amount to be determined at trial. A jury trial has been requested. CBS News Texas reached out to Gateway Church, which said it had no comment at this time.
