Great-granny given 'no chance' to avoid tasering by cop
An ex-police officer spared jail for killing a 95-year-old woman didn't give her "any real chance" to avoid being tasered during an encounter that lasted less than three minutes, a court has been told.
Then-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his Taser at Clare Nowland minutes after being called to the Yallambee Lodge nursing home at Cooma in southern NSW.
She died in hospital a week after the incident in the early hours of May 17, 2023.
The 35-year-old was handed a two-year good behaviour bond and ordered to complete community service in March after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter.
Crown prosecutors appealed against the "manifestly inadequate" sentence when the case went to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal in Sydney on Friday.
Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling SC argued that Supreme Court Justice Ian Harrison made a number of errors when he decided not to send White to prison.
She told the court Mrs Nowland suffered symptoms of dementia and relied on her walking frame to move around the building.
"All of the footage … shows how frail she was, how disorientated she was and how confused she was in the hours leading up to the events," Ms Dowling said.
The great-grandmother was "extremely vulnerable" at the time because she was tired, confused, frail and moved slowly.
She had no discernible reaction to his warnings or requests to drop the knife she was holding during the two minutes and 40 seconds interaction with White.
"At no time did Mrs Nowland advance brandishing the knife," Ms Dowling said.
She was stationary when he said "nah bugger it" and discharged the Taser at her chest, causing her to fall backwards and sustain a brain injury.
"(White) did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered," Ms Dowling said.
"There were many other options available to him."
Justice Harrison was wrong to conclude jailing White would be disproportionate to the seriousness of the offending.
He also mistakenly found the police officer made a "terrible mistake" but his crime was less serious than other manslaughter offences, prosecutors claim.
In his judgment, Justice Harrison decided the need to deter other police officers from committing similar offences played "only a minor role" in his sentencing decision.
But Ms Dowling believes he should have issued a strong warning to other police.
Mrs Nowland's eldest son Michael slammed the sentence as "very disappointing" when it was handed down.
"A slap on the wrist for someone who's killed our mother - it's very, very hard to process that," he said.
Mrs Nowland's family attended every day of White's trial and returned to fill rows of the public gallery during the appeal, which continues on Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Sad scenes as slain cop laid to rest
Tasmanian police have paid tribute to Constable Keith Anthony Smith, who was killed in an 'incredibly rare' shooting in the state's northwest. Constable Smith, 57, was completing a court-ordered repossession warrant on a regional property in North Motton with another officer in mid June when he was fatally shot by a man on the property. It was the first fatal police shooting in the state since 1999. On Friday, a police funeral was held for the fallen officer, who served with Tasmania Police for 25 years, at the Paranaple Convention Centre in Devenport. Soft music played in the background as attendees waited for the procession to begin and paid their respects to the fallen officer. Scores of colleagues and friends were in attendance, joining the family of Constable Smith, including his wife and 'soulmate' Janaha, three children and grandchildren. 'Forever riding', a memorial card to the veteran officer read. Family members shed tears as they laid a yellow rose and a teddy bear on the casket, sitting beside the officer's hat and white roses, which lay on the draped Australian flag flanked by mourning officers. Constable Smith earnt the Commissioner's Medal in 2011 as well as the National Police Service Medal for 15 years in service. The veteran officer moved to the Ulverstone area five years ago after working in the north and northwest region of the state. He was remembered as a 'dearly loved husband, father, poppy, son, a son-in-law, a brother-in law, an uncle, an outstanding member of the Tasmanian Police Force'. 'We will mourn him leaving us, honour his life, reverently farewell his body, and comfort one another,' the funeral MC said. His death was a shock to the entire nation, she added. 'This is a harsher moment than we expected,' she said. 'With this death, it has opened more questions than it has answers.' Tasmania Police Commissioner Donna Adams recalled the letter Constable Smith wrote when applying for a role in the police force in 2000. 'He hoped to provide meaningful support to individuals while building lasting relationships founded on trust and service,' she said. 'These values, service and support, would go on to define his 25-year career.' She spoke of the numerous awards and honours handed to Constable Smith throughout his career, including the Commissioner's Medal in 2011, the National Medal and National Olive Service Medal in 2016, as well as the commissioner's 20-year clasp in 2021. An avid cyclist, Constable Smith rode more than 400km on his bicycle for Tasmania Police charity trust bike rides and raised more than $100,000 for Tasmanian charities. 'You can see that not only did Keith make a difference to the people in his community, but he touched people's lives in a way that was overwhelmingly positive and long lasting,' Ms Adams said. 'His loss has been felt across the policing family in our state, across Australia and New Zealand, and also across the Tasmanian community who knew him, who trusted him, and were better off for having been in his presence.' In a ecology read by the MC, his daughter Ava spoke of Constable Smith's kindness and unwavering love. 'My dad, I love you, I miss you,' she wrote. 'You have taught me so much. I love your big smile and your big warm hugs. 'Thank you for sharing your love of gaming, bike riding and golf with me, even though I was in the bush most of the time. 'I am so proud of you and your job. I would always tell my school friends, my dad is a policeman. 'I'm sorry for not getting out of bed for school when you called me. I love you so much for taking wonderful care of me and mum. 'I love you forever.' His wife Janaha said she was 'numb' after losing her 'gentle, loving husband'. 'I have no words. I am numb. I am lost,' she wrote in a eulogy read to the attendees. 'You are more than everything to us. You are more than just a husband and a dad. 'You are our protector, our safe place. You are the place we call home and always will be. 'You always put us first because you are the amazing person you are. 'We are so proud of you and not just for the presence you have in our lives but also for the presents you have with your Blue family and the local and wider community. 'Thank you for the best days of our life together as a family and loving Ava and I unconditionally. 'Nothing was a bother to you when it came to us. You were such a tower of strength each and every day. 'There was always a text message daily to say, I miss you. I love you. 'This is not goodbye, it is I'll see you in a minute. Love you forever, my special blue boy, from your babe. ' Choking back tears, Inspector Andrew Hanson, who began his career shortly before Constable Smith, said the fallen officer 'always had a smile on his face' and 'never let the job get to him'. 'And in fact, he managed to bring us up in times when we were feeling a bit down,' he said. He recalled the officer being a 'hugger' who always made people feel welcome and seen. 'Keith was really proud of what he did,' he said. 'He would be genuinely humbled by the outpouring of grief from the community. 'His kindness, his compassion and his wonderful nature has rubbed off on us all and I assure you that there will be a bit of Keith with us as we continue to serve the community.' Constable Smith's 'adopted' father-in-law Dudley read a touching poem in the officer's honour. 'We gather today to pay our respects to our very own Blue Angel and to pay homage to this faithful servant,' he said. 'We will forever remember and treasure his lasting legacy, his quiet demeanour and his fastidious attention to his chosen vocation.' Last week, Ms Adams said Tasmania Police had been struggling to come to terms with Constable Smith's death, adding his 25-year dedication to the force would never be forgotten. 'This week has been an incredibly difficult time for our Tasmania Police family, with the death of our respected and committed colleague, Constable Keith Smith,' she said. 'Keith served with unwavering dedication and integrity, and his legacy will not be forgotten. 'For many Tasmania Police officers, Keith was more than a colleague – he was a friend, a mentor, and a true embodiment of what it means to serve,' she said. A 46-year-old North Motton man has since been charged with murder, attempted murder and aggravated assault.
CBS News
3 hours ago
- CBS News
2 Massachusetts educators charged with manslaughter after student drowns on field trip
Two educators are facing manslaughter charges after a student drowned on a summer field trip in western Massachusetts last July. Twelve-year-old Giver Essien was with classmates when she went missing in a pond in Great Barrington. The Berkshire District Attorney said Pittsfield educators Linda Whitacre and Meghan Braley did not follow state-mandated water safety regulations. The teachers allegedly had more than double the number of children swimming at once than legally allowed for one lifeguard. "Nobody knew who was in the water when, where or at what time and that is all against the law in Massachusetts," said Berkshire District Attorney Timothy Shugrue. Shugrue said required swim tests were not completed before the trip either. Giver Essien's father recalls getting the devastating news. "When they called me and said I can't find her, I was like, what do you mean you can't find her?" Richard Essien said. "Then in 10 minutes she calls again and says we found her. She was under the water. I said which water?" Giver Essien, 12, died on a field trip in Great Barrington, Massachusetts. Family photo That call came from one of the two Pittsfield educators who are now criminally charged in the girl's death. Warnings ignored The investigation, according to the DA, found that at least three children reported to Braley that Giver was unable to swim and had gone under the water, but the warnings were ignored. The DA also says the teachers didn't notice she was missing until 30 minutes after all the other kids had gotten out of the water. Those details are a gut punch for Richard Essien, who is urging parents to check in with their child's summer camps. "This is the season. With this kind of weather, whether you like it or not, the kids might want to go to the water. Be careful. Cautious," Essien said. The teachers face three charges including involuntary manslaughter and reckless endangerment of a child. The DA said he doesn't think they intended harm but claims their "reckless conduct" led to the 12-year-old's death.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
House party horror as CEO killed, 15yo arrested
The co-founder of the Universal Store clothing company and CEO of another company has been stabbed to death during a house party in a ritzy Brisbane suburb. Greg Josephson, 58, who co-founded the youth fashion brand with his brother Michael in 1999, was found dead at his Clayfield house in the city's north, shortly after 8pm on Thursday. A 15-year-old was arrested near the home. He was later charged with one count of murder. Police were called to the home where a large party was taking place. Officers arrived to find Mr Josephson dead upstairs. Mr Josephson sold his interest in Universal Store in 2018, with the brand valued at about $100m at the time. Opening their first shop in Carindale, the brothers grew the business into one of Brisbane's best-known retail brands, with more than 80 stores now open across Australia. A large group of teenagers was present at the scene, including the 15-year-old boy. Acting Assistant Commissioner Rhys Wildman said police alleged a household implement was used during an altercation between Mr Josephson and the teen. 'There was some sort of altercation that's resulted in this 58-year old male tragically losing his life,' he said. 'It's not a case of carrying knives, it's unfortunately allotted in a home.' Following investigations, detectives charged the 15-year-old Clayfield boy with one count of murder. The teenager was refused bail and will front Brisbane Children's Court on Friday morning. Police said the teenager contacted them to report the incident. 'That male person indicated to us that he had some involvement, had some knowledge of something that had happened here,' Inspector Jane Healy said. 'He is the only person who was aware of what happened.' The boy, along with the other teenagers, were assisting police with their investigation. Inspector Healy said police arrived at a 'confronting' scene. 'We are still establishing the timeline of what has happened at this address. There were about 30 young people here,' Inspector Healy said. 'It's still extremely early and the situation was quite chaotic, confusing and confronting scene when police arrived, 'There's quite a few young people that need to be interviewed, so until we get that done we won't be able to get a real idea of what has happened here.' Mr Wildman confirmed the gathering was a planned event with none of the other attendees involved in the incident. 'Police are not looking for any other party, so it was an individual, the 15-year-old is the sole offender that we allege was involved in this incident.' Mr Wildman said the rest of the teenagers were transported to Boondall Police Station on Thursday night before their families were contacted. 'This is quite a traumatic incident that occurred, so the welfare of those young people will also be considered in this,' he said. Detective Acting Superintendent Craig Williams confirmed that police located the weapon allegedly used in the murder. 'I can confirm that there was a party under way at the house with a number of young persons at the house,' he said. 'As for what had occurred prior to the incident, it is still under investigation.' Mr Williams said the teenager sustained a minor injury and the house remained a crime scene. The Child Protection Investigation Unit was involved in investigations, police said. Police are urging anyone with information, or with CCTV or dashcam footage from the area, to come forward to assist with the investigation. After graduating with a commerce degree from Griffith University in 1987, Mr Josephson spent 12 years working in leasing, holding roles at major firms including Jones Lang LaSalle, Lendlease, and Westfield. He purchased the Noosa Reef Hotel for $13.9m in 2021. The popular businessman has been remembered as a 'kind' person by a shocked friend. 'We are completely in shock,' he said. 'He was such a kind person, you just don't expect this to happen so close to you. 'It's just so incredibly sad.' Universal Store expressed its condolences to Mr Josephson's family in a statement released on Friday. 'We wanted to share the sad news that Greg Josephson, who founded our company and played a significant role until 2018, has recently passed away,' the statement said. 'Our sincere thoughts and condolences are with his family at this very sad time.'
