Hundreds of $10K FortisBC heat pump rebates in jeopardy over contractor certification
The CBC has learned the rebates of as many as 200 Moore and Russell customers have been jeopardized by a situation that has resulted in complaints and one small claims lawsuit from people who claim they were guaranteed they would qualify for money they were later denied.
"I'm not stoked about it, that's for sure. I'm definitely pissed off," said Jeff Thompson, a North Vancouver man who has spent the past four months trying to figure out who to blame for the rejection of the rebate for his new heat pump.
"I would say be wary of Fortis rebates and who you hire. It turns out it's not a straightforward process."
'I was horrified,' says customer
Thompson is one of thousands of British Columbians who have taken advantage of rebates offered by FortisBC and the province in recent years to encourage homeowners to replace their old heating and cooling systems with high-performance electric heat pumps.
The program has become so popular the province announced plans this week to expand the program this summer to include individual suites in multi-unit residential buildings.
But in order to qualify for a rebate, customers need their heat pump to be installed by a contractor certified with B.C.'s Home Performance Contractor Network (HPCN), a database of retrofit contractors that meet specified trade designation and training qualifications.
Moore and Russell was certified with the HPCN at the time Thompson agreed to pay the company $20,000 to install his dual fuel pump. And they are certified today.
But the HPCN paused the company's certification from March 5 to May 31 — something Thompson says he only learned about after submitting his rebate application.
"I was horrified," said Thompson, who told the CBC the offer of a rebate was the main reason he had decided to go with a heat pump in the first place.
"It was a huge part because it's half the value of what the install was."
Contractor says it never got HPCN's email
Moore and Russell general manager Jeremy Slater says he only learned the company's certification had been put on pause in May after complaints started coming across his desk.
He says the problem dates back to the departure of an employee late last year. The HPCN requires all technicians to be up to date on four courses involving the basic principles of HVAC technology.
"When that person left, we needed to qualify somebody else with those courses with them, and the deadline for having that done lapsed," Slater said.
He says the Home Performance Contractor Network sent an email saying the company's account had been put on pause, but claims the email hit a firewall. Regardless, Slater says he never received it.
"And HPCN doesn't have a process — even still — to follow up or confirm with a contractor when they put them on hold. They just expect that we would get the email."
Despite the change in status, Slater says the company was still listed as a qualified contractor on FortisBC's rebate application menu, which is why customers like Thompson were even able to apply for a rebate in the first place.
"So there was no way that a customer could have known that we were put on pause, and there's no way that we could have known we were put on pause, unless we had actually received the email," he said.
"Which is concerning for us at Moore and Russell because this could still be going on with other contractors and other homeowners purchasing heat pump equipment from Fortis and any of the rebate programs, as HPCN actually provides governance for all of the rebate programs in B.C."
'It's going to turn me off in the future': homeowner
Slater says rebates worth a total of up to $1.5 million could be on the line for as many as 200 of his customers.
One of those customers filed a small claims lawsuit against Moore and Russell earlier this month, seeking $10,000 compensation for the heat pump rebate they were denied.
"After the installation, FortisBC rejected my rebate application, stating that Moore & Russell was not a certified HPCN contractor, which was a requirement for eligibility," the lawsuit reads.
"Had I known this, I would have chosen a different contractor."
Coquitlam homeowner Desmond Saisitthidej says FortisBC also denied his rebate because of Moore and Russell's HPCN certification.
"I think it's really frustrating," he said.
"I think a lot of us did this in good faith, knowing that the rebate was available, knowing Moore and Russell had previously done this and that Fortis had previously paid out — and then to get caught in the quagmire between the two ... It's going to turn me off in the future."
FortisBC 'reviewing the matter'
FortisBC says the company is dedicated to providing rebates and incentives to adopt higher-efficiency technology.
"We are aware of the concerns raised by customers regarding their rebate applications due to the standing of Moore and Russell's membership with the Home Performance Contractor Network," said corporate communications advisor Lauren Beckett.
" We appreciate our customers' understanding, and we are reviewing the matter."
In a statement, the HPCN said members are required to assign a company administrator as a sole contact for membership-related information.
"Company administrators are notified by email if there is a concern with their membership status and provided with instructions and a deadline to rectify the situation as appropriate — this includes multiple follow-up emails," the statement said.
"They can also see their membership status at any time in the HPCN Portal."
Saisitthidej and Thompson say they hope FortisBC will ultimately pay out the rebate to customers who feel they are paying for someone else's mistake.
Slater says he has been in talks with both HPCN and FortisBC.
"I would expect that, in the spirit of the program overall, they would honour those rebates for our customers," he said.
Slater says he has made changes to avoid a repeat of the problems leading up to the lapse in Moore and Russell's certification, but he also feels FortisBC and HPCN need to address communications issues that saw customers left in the dark about their status.
"I would want to know what are we going to do differently so this never happens again," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
12 minutes ago
- CTV News
Ontario mortgage delinquencies on the rise and could climb higher still, experts warn
A real estate sign is displayed in front of a house in Toronto in this file photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Evan Buhler Mortgage delinquencies appear to be on the rise in both Ontario and the Greater Toronto Area and the numbers could get worse as Canada navigates choppy economic waters, experts say. According to data prepared for the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) by Equifax Canada, mortgage delinquencies rose to 0.22 per cent in Ontario for the first quarter of this year. That's up from 0.15 per cent in the first quarter of 2024 and 0.09 per cent in the first quarter of 2023. In Toronto, the mortgage delinquency rate hit 0.23 per cent for the first quarter of 2025. That compares to 0.14 per cent for the first quarter of 2024 and 0.08 per cent for the first quarter of 2023. Specifically, the data tracks the volume of 90-day mortgage delinquencies, which include defaults, but can also refer to late payments. While the rate might not be terribly bad by historical standards, mortgage delinquencies haven't been that high in Toronto since early 2013 and Ontario hasn't seen levels this high since 2016. Equifax reported in February that more than 11,000 mortgages in Ontario recorded a missed payment in the last quarter of 2024. The firm warned that Ontarians are struggling with their mortgages and that mortgage holders are struggling with other forms of debt as well. 'It's concerning,' says Maria Solovieva, an economist at TD Bank. Interest rates, uncertainty are factors Experts say there are two main reasons why mortgage delinquencies are on the rise now. First, the province is seeing a wave of mortgage renewals by people who bought homes with rock-bottom borrowing costs during the pandemic and are now having to renew at higher rates. But in addition to low interest rates, people also had forced savings during lockdown, Solovieva points out. 'So they had these extra funds available for them to put towards repayment,' she says. In that sense, it was predictable that some people might have difficulty making their payments now. 'There's definitely a rise in (delinquencies) associated with coming back to normalcy,' Solovieva says. Jordan Nanowski, CMHC's lead economist for the Greater Toronto Area, agrees. 'I think a rise in delinquencies is expected given that there's a lot of mortgage renewals taking place, so (that) reflects higher mortgage costs,' Nanowski says. The second thing driving up delinquencies, he says, is economic uncertainty finding its way into the labour market. 'There's a lot of economic uncertainty that in itself is already manifesting certain negative impacts,' Nanowski says. 'Especially in certain industries, we're seeing some job cuts and that could be contributing as well. So it's kind of a confluence of the two.' While the data is not clear on this point, Nanowski says the softening of the condo market could well be playing a role in delinquencies if people looking to offload those properties find they are unable to get their money out because of the weaker market. 'There definitely could be individuals that are, let's say, a little bit more tied to their property and if they have issues making payments and they're looking to sell, it's not that easy to sell,' he says. 'So in that type of environment, they might be more likely to be in arrears for longer. So market dynamics are definitely playing a factor there.' Ontario vulnerable as trade war remains unresolved Both Solovieva and Nanowski agree that going forward, Ontario could be in for a rough ride if the ongoing trade war with the United States, sparked by U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff threats, hits the job market. 'We do expect that Ontario specifically will be hit by the trade war a little bit more,' Solovieva says. 'The unemployment rate is already at 7.9 and 7.8 per cent between the two months in May and in June (respectively), so it's larger than average in Canada.' Nationally, unemployment sat at 6.9 per cent in June. 'The economic uncertainty and impacts of potential tariffs could impact employment for a lot of individuals, and that could increase mortgage arrears,' Nanowski says. He points out areas that support industries targeted by the U.S. for tariffs are particularly vulnerable. 'Windsor is probably the most exposed. Same with case Kitchener, Cambridge, Waterloo, St. Catharines, Niagara, Hamilton for steel,' Nanowski says. 'Those are places that mortgage arears might pop up a bit higher if trade tensions and economic uncertainty persist, right? And we're already seeing a bit of impact there. You're seeing some job losses in certain sectors that are more unique to that area.' CMHC could not provide the real number of mortgage delinquencies in Ontario. However, of the nearly 7 million outstanding mortgages in Canada, 0.22 per cent were in arrears in the fourth quarter of last year, according to the corporation. That translates into 15,259 mortgages across the country. Nanowski adds that while the diversified labour market within the Greater Toronto Area is something of a bulwark around Toronto, the GTA is still vulnerable in some places, such as Oshawa, where thousands of jobs are tied to the auto industry. But while there's reason for concern, Solovieva points out that for the time being, mortgage delinquencies still sit at less than a quarter of a percent. 'So it just tells you that, yes, there is strain, especially in those very not affordable regions,' she says. 'But it's not something that will basically, at this point, be a breaking point.' Are you having difficulty making your mortgage payments? CP24 and CTV News Toronto want to hear from you. Email us at torontonews@ with your name, general location and phone number in case we want to follow up. Your comments may be used in a CP24 or CTV News story.
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
All in on ETFs? Experts share how to diversify your portfolio — without overdoing it
TORONTO — Exchange-traded funds have exploded in popularity, and so have investment strategies based only on ETFs, but some investors might be wondering whether that could lead to their portfolio being too diversified. Financial experts say allocating an entire portfolio to ETFs can be a viable strategy, but it's important for investors to know what holdings are in the funds they're buying. When looking at portfolio diversification for ETF-focused investors, Jonathan Rivard, general principal at Edward Jones, said it's important to consider the individual's time horizon and risk appetite. 'You could absolutely be 100 per cent invested in ETFs. But you want to know what's in the ETF and what the allocation looks like. Some ETFs will be balanced; they'll have a mix of stocks and bonds in them. Some will be sector products,' Rivard said. 'The important thing comes down to understanding what does this basket hold? And if I own multiple ETFs, what does it look like across multiple ETFs in terms of asset allocation?' Prerna Mathews, Mackenzie Investments' vice-president of ETF product strategy, said there are a few key points to keep in mind regarding diversification, notably, it is important to think beyond just diversifying by geography. 'So (if) you're starting with the core Canadian, U.S., international exposure, don't stop there. Think about how fixed income plays a role in your portfolio, real assets, there are thematic products, and there are alternative ETFs. There are a lot of different drivers of return that can be added to a portfolio available in ETF form,' she said. Another consideration is buying ETFs with different investment styles, she said, which may include combining traditional index ETFs with others that are actively managed or have low volatility. Time horizon is also an important consideration, where those with a longer investment horizon may want to focus on growth, she said, taking on more risk with higher equity exposure. Regarding fixed income, Mathews said to be aware of the differences between short- and longer-term yields, adding that most investors will likely not have exposure to every duration of fixed income and should know the relevant trade-offs. 'In some cases, you can get a very attractive yield at the short end of the curve without taking on significant risk as you would on the long end,' she said. 'Really understanding the trade-off there and likely having some short-term fixed income in the portfolio would be viable. But aggregate bonds over a 30-year time period are generally a good place to be.' Mathews said there is also a growing number of investors opting for an asset allocation ETF. She said this type of ETF is essentially eight to 12 ETFs 'all packaged up in one,' and has served as a core holding for those looking for a 'set it and forget it' investment. Despite the benefits of diversification, Mathews said there are dangers to being overly diversified. This might occur for someone investing in Canadian equities through an ETF but also buying into an asset allocation ETF, Mathews said. In that case, the investor may end up with more Canadian equity exposure than anticipated. Similarly, with the TSX financials sector representing around 30 per cent of the overall index, an investor with a TSX-focused ETF and a Canadian banks-focused ETF could end up with too much exposure to Canadian bank stocks. 'There is a risk of having too much product in your portfolio. Sometimes that can creep up on us when we're not doing a full look through to what each ETF might be investing in,' she said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 24, 2025. Daniel Johnson, The Canadian Press
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Digby affordable housing project on hold as federal funding dries up
A plan by a Digby, N.S., non-profit to build affordable housing on the site of a former downtown motel is at a standstill as the group awaits word on federal funding. The Digby & Area Housing Coalition Society purchased the former Siesta Motel in 2022 with an aim to turn the existing building into affordable housing, coalition chair Nancy Robinson said. Subsequently, it was decided that it would be more cost efficient to demolish the motel and build 34 units on the site. The units would serve seniors and other vulnerable people facing Digby's severe housing shortage. Robinson said the units would be genuinely affordable, with tenants spending no more than 30 per cent of their income on rent, including utilities. She said they already have many applicants for the units. After securing $300,000 in funding including provincial grants for design work and municipal approvals, the $11.2-million project was construction-ready this spring and awaiting the release of federal funds. After waiting for the outcome of the federal election, Robinson said the group was told the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's affordable housing fund, their expected funding source, had been depleted. 'That's a lot of money' CMHC said in an email to CBC that it's affordable housing fund "has attracted significant interest and success, resulting in numerous high-quality applications," but did not indicate if and when it will be replenished. Robinson said the devastating news has left the project in limbo. "That's a lot of money and it's very difficult to make that up," she said. "It's nerve-racking, not just because of the number of people that are waiting for housing, desperately waiting for housing, and Digby where there's really basically nothing available and certainly nothing affordable." Robinson said the delay leaves the volunteer organization having to cover significant costs, including the $2,600-monthly mortgage payment on the vacant property. The delay couldn't come at worse time for Digby, she said. The community's housing shortage has reached emergency levels. She said the funding issue appears linked to broader changes in federal housing policy. While Ottawa works to implement its new housing plan, she said existing programs like the affordable housing fund have been allowed to lapse. Robinson said she understands the need for systemic reform, but immediate action is needed to help people in desperate need of appropriate housing. The coalition has launched a local fundraising campaign and is exploring alternative financing options. Chris D'Entremont, the Conservative MP for Acadie-Annapolis, which includes Digby, said it was strange the program was still taking applications even though it said its funds have been depleted. He said billions of dollars have gone into the fund, which has existed since 2018. "We're hoping that as the fall rolls around, of course, there's going to be a budget coming," he told CBC Radio's Information Morning Nova Scotia. Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne "has said that there will be a program coming, that there should be funding. So we're hoping it will be topping this off." With demolition delayed from its planned May 2025 start, Robinson said completion could now slip to late 2026. Meanwhile, for the applicants the wait continues with no clear resolution in sight. "They are desperate. It's palpable. It's tragic, really," Robinson said.
